The Liars Among Us - The American Spectator | USA News and Politics
The Liars Among Us
Nikole Hannah-Jones (YouTube screenshot)

The impeccably credentialed National Association of Scholars (NAS), which strives for, among other things, truth in academic discourse, focused in a recent webinar on the peril that truth faces amid our present racial anxieties.

The new “truth” being vetted on the progressive left is that the whole of American history stems from chattel slavery.

The Constitution, the Declaration of Independence, July Fourth — forget it. Everything we thought we knew about America is false. Slavery is the sun around which our national solar system spins. We have a new explanation of the American story, tailored to shame us in the face of white racism. America didn’t begin in 1776; it began in 1619, with the arrival of the first African slaves. Our intellectual elite class is finally latching on. It remains for the rest of the country to catch up. Or so goes the new theme song, with lyrics crafted by the authors of the New York Times’ so-called “1619 Project.” The Times’ purpose — I am not exaggerating — is to effect national repentance through an altered understanding of slavery as our central experience. The project’s keystone outrage is the assertion that the colonists threw off British rule so as to make the new world safe for human bondage.

Into the fog of misinformation steps valiantly the NAS, its webinar offering corrective truths that you wouldn’t have imagined 10 years ago — five even — would require firm restating.

The distinguished historian Wilfred McClay of Oklahoma University and the longtime civil rights activist Robert Woodson say, in essence, in their presentations: Huh? Where’d this stuff come from? They say so , nonetheless, not on the basis of gape-mouthed wonderment but of genuine knowledge of their country’s history: not least its historical grapplings with the conundrum of white-black relations and how to get them right for the whole nation’s sake.

I commend the NAS website ( as the place to go for taking in the webinar as a whole. I shall not attempt in this small space to recount the two learned participants’ bristling defense of America’s track record as a free society: full of deficiencies (as all human enterprises must be); faltering at times; unfinished; but effulgent with the light of sheer effort to meet the challenge of planting liberty’s banner in a new land. The “1619 Project,” despite the Pulitzer Prize it earned the Times, is long-faced, lugubrious, narrow-eyed, closed-minded on the subject. America’s leading historians of the colonial/revolutionary/federal period have joined hands with McClay and Woodson in dismissing the 1619 Project’s eccentric slant on what the founders and their heirs were up to; e.g., preserving slavery.

The Constitution that our outrageous founders crafted guarantees, among other treasures, free speech. The 1619 folk have every right to contend, if they desire, that George Washington whipped 10 slaves every day before breakfast. Yet freedom depends on truth, and on any society’s adherence to it. The notions of substituting falsehoods for demonstrable and long-received truths about the country we live in is dangerous to that country’s prospects. The effects of hatred resulting from sharp divisions are in play in Kenosha, Portland, and other luckless venues.

A great irony presently on view is the contention over on the progressive left that Donald Trump is a lousy, !#%#$#@ liar. (Except that no one bothers, in these our liberated times, to say “!#%#$@” anymore!) I wouldn’t doubt that Trump himself understands that oft times he makes up stuff out of thin air, then says, like Dr. Cure-All on his vividly painted wagon, “Step right up folks! Gaze on my never-fail potion for the Room-uh-tiz!” Numerous of us wish he’d stop it.

However, among the oldest of human truths is that two wrongs don’t make a right. You don’t make up for a Trumpian distortion by lying about the nation he heads: over-stating its human sins, calumniating its heroes and heroines, imputing the lowest motives to its institutions.

The 1619 Project is a lie: a fabric of distortions, omissions, and irrelevancies: so far out of sync with the facts as hardly to compete with what we’ve known about ourselves and our country since… always. We’ll get past this. The necessity of getting past it — that’s the tragedy.

Willliam Murchison’s latest book is The Cost of Liberty: The Life of John Dickinson.


Sign up to receive our latest updates! Register

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: The American Spectator, 122 S Royal Street, Alexandria, VA, 22314, You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact

Be a Free Market Loving Patriot. Subscribe Today!