Home » Hot off the Press » The Line-Item Veto Fight
It’s getting pretty silly. After Steven Calabresi wrote a defense of Giuliani, Douglas Kmiec countered with another piece taking Romney’s side. But Kmiec’s argument is rather childish, because he selectively cites liberal opponents of the veto and conservative supporters of it to reach the conclusion:
Most conservatives will have no trouble figuring out that one.
The problem with Kmiec’s guilt by association line of argument is that it can easily be turned right back at him. Scalia may have dissented, but he joined Breyer’s dissent, while Thomas and Rehnquist concurred with Stevens’s majority opinion. Furthermore, in Congress, Ted Kennedy was one of the supporters of a line-item veto.
So, I guess the voters have to choose up sides: Rudy, Thomas, and Rehnquist; or Mitt, Breyer, and Kennedy.
Here's a collection of items that wind their way from...Read More
It wasn’t about Israel. It was Nov. 28, 1941. Israel,...Read More
Zakiya Carr Johnson hates the American system. She hates American...Read More