Tim Kaine is citing his religion in defense of his opposition to the death penalty. His new ad (last one here) has him saying, “As a Christian missionary in Honduras, I learned that life is sacred. And that’s why I oppose the death penalty. I’ll carry out a death sentence, because that’s the law, but I won’t change my religious beliefs.”
A few points:
-No one’s questioning his religious belief. They’re questioning his activism against the death penalty. Likening it to the gulags shows a callousness for the most grave injustices.
-He only learned about the sacredness of life in his 20s? He was raised Catholic, so why didn’t that sink in before then?
-The Catholic Church doesn’t even teach outright opposition to the death penalty — it’s not grouped among inherent evils like abortion, which Tim Kaine has never lifted a finger against like his anti-death penalty work. In fact, Church teaching allows that the death penalty may be a just punishment. Avery Cardinal Dulles explains it particularly well in this 2001 article in First Things:
To which Catholic teaching does Tim Kaine subscribe?
Notice to Readers: The American Spectator and Spectator World are marks used by independent publishing companies that are not affiliated in any way. If you are looking for The Spectator World please click on the following link: https://thespectator.com/world.