Dead Wrong Dissent - The American Spectator | USA News and Politics
Dead Wrong Dissent

Robert VerBruggen ought not be so impressed by the Henderson dissent in Parker. The argument that the Second Amendment doesn’t apply to DC because the District is not a state is completely implausible, at least from an originalist perspective. The “security of a free State” language was understood at the time of ratification to mean “security of a free country” — as Eugene Volokh notes, it’s a formulation that comes from Blackstone’s Commentaries. Blackstone used “state” as a synonym for “nation,” and so did the Framers; the word “state” is used in that sense in several places elsewhere in the constitution, in reference to “foreign state[s].” And remember that when the constitution was written, the US included the Northwest Territory; does it really make sense to think that the Framers would deliberately deny rights to Americans in that region?

(UPDATE: Robert VerBruggen replies here.–Ed.)

Sign Up to receive Our Latest Updates! Register

Notice to Readers: The American Spectator and Spectator World are marks used by independent publishing companies that are not affiliated in any way. If you are looking for The Spectator World please click on the following link:

Be a Free Market Loving Patriot. Subscribe Today!

Stop the Inflation Grinch From Stealing Christmas!

That’s right, the Grinch (Joe Biden) is coming for your pocketbooks this Christmas season with record inflation. Just to recap, here is a list of items that have gone up during his reign. 

Gas: 40%+
Beef: 20%+
Used Cars: 20%+
Lodging: 17%
Eggs: 13%

What hasn’t increased? The cost to subscribe to The American Spectator! For a limited time, we are offering our popular yearly subscription for only $49.99. Lock in the lowest price of the year by subscribing today

The Grinch Stole Christmas Sale
Commander-in-chief of Christmas inflation