Whenever I try to make this point, my more intellectual friends
sneer that I'm just being a know-nothing populist, but here is
University of Maryland professor
James G. Gimpel:
For 50 years now, survey research has suggested just that: It
is, in fact, wrong, because there is no coherent center. There
are no fixed, well-considered policy positions in the center to
which voters there adhere.
The research suggests that those who at various times occupy
this center, often described as moderates or independents, are
not very knowledgeable about or interested in politics. They do
not follow campaign coverage closely, are inconsistent in their
policy views, and are often not able to identify what positions
are liberal or conservative.
What characterizes the centrist voter is not some peculiar set
of policy positions, but rather ignorance of policy issues in
general, coupled with vague impressions of the "goodness" or
"badness" of the times. So-called centrist or moderate voters
can't even be counted on to vote.
This relates to the Samuel Popkin "low-information rationality"
theory
I referenced yesterday. Making an ideological or
policy-specific interpretation of election results ignores the
fact that independent voters decide elections and these voters
are generally the least-informed members of the electorate.
It's like the $700 billion bailout. The Ordinary American doesn't
know the intricate details of the financial crisis, but he can
figure out that the government is giving a fat wad of cash to a
bunch of high rollers who've already screwed up big-time, and he
doesn't like it. It is not lowbrow populism to tell this voter,
"Yeah, you're right," because there are plenty of respectable
economists who say the bailout was a lousy idea. But if you
incorrectly assume that the independent voter is a "centrist,"
you're going to miss the chance to make the
libertarian populist argument.
Good God. Too bad "research" or "authority" is necessary to tell
us what is patently obvious to anyone who has ever spoken with a
"moderate".
Bob| 11.14.08 @ 4:29PM
RSM -- you missed the point again. Certainly there are low
information voters in the center -- and in the right and left as
well. And on any specific topic, a real centrist position is
difficult if not impossible. But that's not what defines
centrists/moderates/independents. What defines them are positions
that are topic specific that are not CONSISTENTLY right or left.
For example, you can have strong fiscal conservative and national
security strength positions while being socially libertarian.
Most unthinking people here would call that a RINO. You might be
a conservative Democrat with similar beliefs except that you
believe in bigger government rather than smaller government.
You ideologues miss the point completely which is why you will
continue to lose elections and lose the emerging populations. I
just wish you guys would think rather than expound.
Billy Bob| 11.19.08 @ 10:49PM
Bob: You're what in these parts we call a Concern Troll.
Matthew Vadum| 11.14.08 @ 4:18PM
You do great research, Stacy!
the-gunslinger| 11.14.08 @ 4:25PM
Good God. Too bad "research" or "authority" is necessary to tell us what is patently obvious to anyone who has ever spoken with a "moderate".
Bob| 11.14.08 @ 4:29PM
RSM -- you missed the point again. Certainly there are low information voters in the center -- and in the right and left as well. And on any specific topic, a real centrist position is difficult if not impossible. But that's not what defines centrists/moderates/independents. What defines them are positions that are topic specific that are not CONSISTENTLY right or left. For example, you can have strong fiscal conservative and national security strength positions while being socially libertarian. Most unthinking people here would call that a RINO. You might be a conservative Democrat with similar beliefs except that you believe in bigger government rather than smaller government.
You ideologues miss the point completely which is why you will continue to lose elections and lose the emerging populations. I just wish you guys would think rather than expound.
Billy Bob| 11.19.08 @ 10:49PM
Bob: You're what in these parts we call a Concern Troll.