The Ninth Circuit Experience - The American Spectator | USA News and Politics
The Ninth Circuit Experience

Last week a three-judge panel on the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled a Tex-Mex restaurant chain must pay hundreds of thousands of dollars in damages for violating the American with Disabilities Act.

The appeals court said Chipotle Restaurants violated the disabilities act because a wheelchair-bound customer could not see his food being prepared above a 45-inch-high counter and therefore was denied the complete “Chipotle Experience.”

As an empathetic person, I tried to put myself, if not in the judges’ shoes, then at least in a closet in the eminent jurists’ chambers, thereby eavesdropping on an historic moment of opinion-making:

(Judges return to their chambers, take off robes, loosen ties, unbutton pants, kick off shoes and recline with feet on desks.)

JUDGE REINHARDT: So, how do you want to play this one?

JUDGE FRIEDMAN (Digs into dish of M&Ms. Pops several into mouth. Chews): Another damn fast food restaurant. Enough already.

JUDGE REINHARDT: They’re everywhere.


JUDGE REINHARDT: I was going to say cockroaches.

JUDGE FRIEDMAN: Them too. We used to have this nice strip over on Hillcrest. Very chic. Mediterranean, sushi, a nice kosher deli. Then some Neanderthal builds a garage mahal and lets all these damn chains move in. Bloopies, Harbys, Jimmy Jones.


JUDGE FRIEDMAN: They’re the worst. Such commercials.

JUDGE REINHARDT: Yeah. The fish love that crap.

JUDGE FRIEDMAN: Next thing you know, half the haute cuisine joints are gone, out of business.

JUDGE REINHARDT: Of course they are. They can’t compete with the swill them chains dish out. I mean, how much does a tub of pig fat cost?

JUDGE FRIEDMAN: (Belches) No wonder this country’s full of lard asses.  

JUDGE REINHARDT: Buzzing around in their little motorized shopping carts.

JUDGE FRIEDMAN: Loading up on the Twinkies and Ding Dongs.


JUDGE FRIEDMAN (Laughs fondly): Reminds me of when that Albuquerque jury stuck it to McDonald’s after that one old bag spilled coffee in her lap.

JUDGE REINHARDT: That was some trial! (Considers.) You know what I think? I think this case has that kind of potential.

JUDGE FRIEDMAN: Hold on. You’re forgetting — that case was — what do they call it? A slam dunk. This one, I mean, you must admit the plaintiff’s case was a little weak.

JUDGE REINHARDT (Sullenly): Yeah. And where did they come up with this “denying the Chipotle Experience” stuff? My God!!

JUDGE FRIEDMAN: Watching some pimply faced kid make your burrito. That’s some experience.

JUDGE REINHARDT: How starved for entertainment was this guy?

JUDGE FRIEDMAN: Kind of pathetic, when you think about it.

JUDGE REINHARDT: What was this, his twentieth ADA lawsuit?

JUDGE FRIEDMAN: I should keep track?

JUDGE REINHARDT (Laughs): Beats working, I guess.

(Judges silently stare at their stocking feet.)

JUDGE REINHARDT: Let’s say, I mean, as a kind of thought experiment…


JUDGE REINHARDT: Say we were to reverse the district court any way.

JUDGE FRIEDMAN: But the plaintiff’s case —

 JUDGE REINHARDT: I know. Ridiculous.

JUDGE FRIEDMAN: I was going to say dreadful.

JUDGE REINHARDT: Doesn’t matter. All we got to say is there’s been a clear violation of the disabilities act.

JUDGE FRIEDMAN (Leans forward, snaps fingers): Discrimination.

JUDGE REINHARDT: Exactly. You know what today is, don’t you?


JUDGE REINHARDT: It’s the anniversary of the passage of the Americans with Disabilities Act.

JUDGE FRIEDMAN: The timing would be perfect!

JUDGE REINHARDT: That’s what I’m saying.


JUDGE REINHARDT: Of course, there’d be hell to pay.

JUDGE FRIEDMAN (Shrugs): Naturally.

JUDGE REINHARDT: Lots of blowback.

JUDGE FRIEDMAN: They’ll call it judicial activism.

JUDGE REINHARDT: Might try to impeach us.

JUDGE FRIEDMAN: Thank God we don’t have to run for re-election.

JUDGE REINHARDT: You ain’t kidding.


JUDGE REINHARDT: Of course, we’d be reversed

JUDGE FRIEDMAN: Right… You mean the Supremes?

JUDGE REINHARDT: Naturally. Even the lefties on the court would have to reverse.

JUDGE FRIEDMAN: But at least we’d get to stick it to the junk-peddling bastards. Not a bad day’s work, if you ask me.

JUDGE REINHARDT: Then it’s settled?


(Judges rise.)

JUDGE REINHARDT: You think we should run this past Judge Nelson?

JUDGE FRIEDMAN: Naw. I already spoke to her in the hallway.

JUDGE REINHARDT: What’d she say?

JUDGE FRIEDMAN: She said she was going to take a nap.

JUDGE FRIEDMAN: She say anything else?

JUDGE REINHARDT: Yeah, she said, “Let’s stick it to the junk-peddling bastards.”

JUDGE FRIEDMAN (Laughing): That’s our girl.

Sign Up to receive Our Latest Updates! Register

Notice to Readers: The American Spectator and Spectator World are marks used by independent publishing companies that are not affiliated in any way. If you are looking for The Spectator World please click on the following link:

Be a Free Market Loving Patriot. Subscribe Today!