- Home
- About Us
- Contributors
- Departments
- Topics
- Back Issues
- Weekly Archives
- AmSpecBlog
- Subscribe
- Newsletter
- Advertise
- Donate
- Contact Us
- Daily Digest
- Templeton Essays
search
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
The Right Prescription
Health Care Overhaul Threatens States
(Page 2 of 2)
Michael Greve, an American Enterprise Institute scholar who focuses on federalism, said that any state that accepts Medicaid money would have to go along with any conditions the federal government attaches to it. “The central problem is the temptation by the states,” he said.
However, he said that the imposition of health insurance exchanges on the states raises much more complex legal issues involving the hotly contested concept of “conditional preemption,” which is when the federal government tells states to enact a given regulation or else have the federal government do it for them. Greve said his hunch is that the current U.S. Supreme Court would find such a provision unconstitutional.
As legislation moves through Congress, at least one state is trying to protect its citizens against federal overreach. Last month, the Arizona state legislature voted to include a referendum on the 2010 ballot that would amend the state constitution to prevent anybody in the state from being forced to participate in any health care system. Practically speaking, the provision would mean that people and businesses in Arizona would be exempt from insurance coverage mandates.
“This is an effort to create a federalism shield to protect the rights of Arizonans,” said Clint Bolick, a director at the Phoenix-based Goldwater Institute, who supports the measure.
In 2008, Arizona voters narrowly rejected a similar proposal by less than 9,000 votes out of more than 2.1 million cast after then Gov. Janet Napolitano campaigned vigorously against it. But Bolick said that the 2010 proposition has different language that prevents opponents from arguing that it would affect existing state programs.
The legislation would not seek to address the issue created by the imposition of an insurance exchange on the state, but Bolick said such a provision could be challenged under the “anti-commandeering” principle. This applies when “the federal government enlists the state as if it were an agent of the federal government,” he said. “That raises constitutional alarm bells.”
Christie Herrera of the American Legislative Exchange Council, which boasts 1,800 conservative state legislators as members, said that efforts are already underway in five other states (Indiana, Minnesota, New Mexico, North Dakota, and Wyoming) to imitate the Arizona example if it succeeds next year.
Health care has already been the subject of several failed state experiments. In 1994, Tennessee expanded Medicaid coverage, but by 2003 its health care system was deemed “not financially viable” and Democratic Gov. Phil Bredesen was forced to rein in the program.
In 2006, then-Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney signed health care legislation in which the state government forced individuals to obtain coverage and offered them subsidies to purchase government-designed plans on a government-run exchange. The result has been skyrocketing costs and longer waits in doctors’ offices. A Rasmussen poll taken last month found that just 26 percent of voters in the overwhelmingly liberal state said the effort was a success.
Instead of learning from these failed experiments, Democrats in Washington are planning to use federal power to muscle all states into replicating them.
Philip Klein is The American Spectator's Washington correspondent.
Comments
Leave a Comment
Related Articles
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Hank Rearden| 7.14.09 @ 8:03AM
Good article. I'm glad you mentioned Kennedy. Why anyone would take any of the legislation he wrote seriously is beyond me seeing as his biggest success in life was not being convicted of vehicular manslaughter. Remember, this is the same genius that Bush had author No Child Left Behind, a grand piece of legislation that is yet another unfunded mandate.
cary loos| 7.14.09 @ 11:23AM
Thank you for raising the "Federalism question."
I don't know what it will take to wake Americans up to this danger. Incombent protected sultans
will imposing their will where no contravening authority exists in opposition. We have witnessed this phenonenon in action since the "Great Society" programs of the sixties and it has only accelerated in the last six months. Let freedom ring and grant the States the stones to exercise their push back responsibility.
Lu Dumak| 7.14.09 @ 11:25AM
Our Representatives should be using the 10th and 14th amendment to fight this farce of Goverment health care. We should start by putting Kennedy on the health care he wants for the American people.
Pingback| 7.14.09 @ 3:01PM
The American Spectator : Health Care Overhaul Threatens States :: General Resources links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 7.14.09 @ 3:06PM
ADF Alliance Alert » Health care overhaul threatens states links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 7.14.09 @ 3:25PM
The American Spectator : Health Care Overhaul Threatens States | Tips From isabell links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 7.14.09 @ 4:58PM
The American Spectator : Health Care Overhaul Threatens States links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 7.14.09 @ 4:58PM
The American Spectator : Health Care Overhaul Threatens States links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Death is Americas salvation| 7.14.09 @ 5:06PM
Health care for all is a must, because you are not incontrol of your own destiny. The State decides if you live or die, and many will be euthanased, no longer productive, serves no purpose you have a destiny with death.
No more private insurance put public health to control who lives and who dies.
The planet is over populated, and must be reduced to under 3 Billion people, that is the Zionist policy. Nothing you can do about it Americans does not control America it's controled by Zionist.
All people who whish to be elected has to be confirmed by Zionist and swear an allegiance to APIAC and Israel.
America is the only country on earth that has to do that swear allegiance to a foreign body.
Pingback| 7.14.09 @ 5:50PM
The American Spectator : Health Care Overhaul Threatens States | My Health and Lifest links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Brittanicus| 7.14.09 @ 6:39PM
MEDICAL CARE SHOULD BE THE CHOICE OF EACH AMERICAN
The deciding factor in implementing health care for everybody--LEGALLY--in America, is the Publics voice? Those who want to just follow the same old road, can do so with the profit taking commercial insurance. Those who would be satisfied with a government run health care program, can now start demanding it from the lawmakers. Those who see a Universal health care system, similar to most developed countries in Europe, should start informing every Representative and Senate politician starting today. Rationing in places like England, was caused by the major impact of uncontrolled immigration.
Most American working class can do--without-- high premiums, pre-existing condition clauses. deductibles, co-pays that is representative of the wealthy medical care insurers. Whatever pertains to your family, you should start ruffling the indifferent feathers of the people in Washington at 202-224-3121 Just like illegal immigration , we cannot afford anymore to subsidize the business that hire them or the millions of illegal families.
Pingback| 7.14.09 @ 7:03PM
The American Spectator : Health Care Overhaul Threatens States | health links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Alan Brooks| 7.14.09 @ 7:13PM
NO POINT IN TRYING, THE TROLLS WILL DROWN YOU AT THIS BLOG.
we are just going through the motions now. game over
Alan Brooks| 7.14.09 @ 7:20PM
btw, AS is relative sanity in this misfired 21st century, but the cover photo of the guy-- even if he is a doctor-- holding a naked boy is okay but perhaps slightly unwise in the Age of Jacksonian democracy. we have to be nobler than Caesar's wife; this isn't the '80s; now we have to walk on eggs!
Alan Brooks| 7.14.09 @ 7:20PM
btw, AS is relative sanity in this misfired 21st century, but the cover photo of the guy-- even if he is a doctor-- holding a naked boy is okay but perhaps slightly unwise in the Age of Jacksonian democracy. we have to be nobler than Caesar's wife; this isn't the '80s; now we have to walk on eggs!
Alan Brooks| 7.14.09 @ 7:54PM
why am I upset about the trolls? look at the "America Will Die" posts. who does Daphne work for, anyway? Al Jazeera?
Pingback| 7.14.09 @ 10:06PM
Obama run healthcare crashes state budgets links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Alan Brooks| 7.14.09 @ 11:21PM
and spam from Louis Vuitton and Gucci along with 'America is the death of Daphne' or whomever.
Finrir| 7.15.09 @ 12:53AM
Here I am, a 15 year old, concerned about this topic. Of cource people my age and younger should be concerned. The debt that this bill will put on our contry will leave me, my children, my grandchildren, and maybe even my great grandchildren left to pay it off. We will all be broke. I urge everyone old enough to urge their senators and representatives to vote NO on this bill, or you could consider this country destroyed. I for one, will move to either Canada or England later in life should this retardedness pass. It is simply a taxation overhaul.
Pingback| 7.15.09 @ 2:06AM
How Old Is America | All Days Long links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Danny Jackson| 7.15.09 @ 2:29AM
got time. Well, nice article buddy… Someone will love to read this infor if I tell her about this. She’s really interested in this subject. Thanks again… Please come visit my site collection agencies when you
Pingback| 7.15.09 @ 10:39AM
| gopnation links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
supra shoes| 7.15.09 @ 11:13PM
I must say this is a great article i enjoyed reading it keep the good work.
jordan 6 rings| 7.17.09 @ 4:52AM
Good article. I'm glad you mentioned Kennedy.
Pingback| 7.21.09 @ 1:15AM
House bill would destroy private insurance—and private medicine « AAPS News of the Da links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Richard Baker| 7.22.09 @ 4:38PM
Death is Americas salvation:
Are you volunteering to be one of the subjects of the population reduction you say must happen? May I be of assistance in your personal reduction?
ed hardy store| 7.24.09 @ 2:08AM
i like
cheap handbags| 7.25.09 @ 7:20PM
We only sell the top grade replica cheap handbags, some of them are genuine leather handbags, yet the price is far lower than the authentic designers want you to pay. We lead you to a genuine pool of bags : collections in wide range: handbags, shoulder bags, clutches, tote bags, purses and wallets, the hottest brands you can find like replica Louis Vuitton handbags, Replica marc jacobs handags, Replica Prada handbags, Coach,Replica Chloe handbags,Burberry, Dior,replica Chanel handbags, Chloe,Replica gucci handbags, Dolce & Gabbana,Replica Balenciaga handbags . Crafted to the highest standard, from the finest materials in the industry, we guarantee the toppest Replica Hermes handbags at low price you'll find anywhere.
george| 7.29.09 @ 2:24AM
LV Bequia Leather handbag , commonly referred to as
Louis Vuitton Bequia, or sometimes shortened to
Louis Vuitton Classic China Run handbags has become one of the most
Louis Vuitton Classic China Run luxury brands.
outlet louis vuittongood
lv outletl like
louis vuitton outletsgood
louis vuitton outlet storesnice
s| 8.20.09 @ 11:16AM
Cheap Jordan,Cheap Jordan shoes,Retro Jordan,Air Yeezy Shoes,Supra shoes,Kanye West ShoesJordan shoes,New Jordans,Air Yeezy,Air Force Ones,Nike Dunks,Retro Jordan, Cheap Jordan Shoes,Nike Dunk High,True Religion Jeans,New Air Force OnesAir Yeezy Shoe,Supra Shoes,Retro Jordan,Creative Recreation,Nike DunksNike Air YeezyTrue Religion,Air Jordan Shoes,Air Shox,Air Max,Dunk Shoes.Air Jordan,Cheap Jordans,Jordan Shoes,Cheap Air Jordans,Air Jordan Shoes
business of china| 8.21.09 @ 1:00AM
This article was extremely interesting, especially since I was searching for thoughts on this subject last Thursday. Feel free to check out my site china business when you got time.
china's map| 8.21.09 @ 1:01AM
I really liked your blog! You have some great content. I would love some feedback on my site map of china when you got time.
dropshippngwatch| 9.2.09 @ 9:53AM
Replica Watch
Replica Watches
Fake Watch
Sales Replica Watches
Fake Watches
Fake Watch
Replica Watch
Replica Watches
Fake Watch
replica Rolex watches
Replica Rolex Watches
Replica A.Lange&Sohne; Watches
Replica Alain Silberstein Watches
Replica Audemars Piguet Watches
Replica B.R.M Watches
Replica Baume & Mercier Watches
Replica Bell&Ross; Watches
Replica BMW Watches
Replica Breguet Watches
Replica Breitling Watches
http://www.dropshippingwatch.com
Wedding Dresses| 9.10.09 @ 12:44AM
Read this article, some knowledge toWedding Dresses
Designer Wedding Gowns
understand, thank you, the author
uggboots| 10.15.09 @ 9:58PM
Your site is excellent, and I really like.
In the present lively world, food and clothing put on the line in our life have already to obtain the sublimation, life needs the entertainment,each kinds of color and design are finitely looks like the young women's hairstyle , every day them wearing uggboots shose
weight| 11.12.09 @ 4:35PM
Hi, everybody here, I just spent " http://www.shinebride.com" title="Wedding Dresses">Wedding
Dresses