Never Trumpers: The Unbearable Rightness of Being - The American Spectator | USA News and Politics
Never Trumpers: The Unbearable Rightness of Being

Tom Nichols is not sad about losing friends over this election. He says,”Put another way, if my opposition to Trump is going to cost me friends, then all I can say is: So be it.”

The Professor knows he’s right and that all will come to see his rectitude eventually. “With my friends and family who still cling to Trump, I never waver from my insistence, directly and firmly, that they are making a terrible mistake, and that Trump is making them worse people for being involved in his message.” [Emphasis added.]

A few more chestnuts from Mr. Nichols:

“But Trump’s candidacy isn’t really about politics, which is why it divides people so deeply.”

“In fact, Trump’s policies are not policies. They’re just feverish revenge fantasies.”

“Trump’s supporters are now like roaring drunks in a bar fight, people who you might have tried to reason with five drinks earlier but now are just lashing out at everyone in every direction.”

“This blind madness puts both political and emotional distance between Trump supporters and the rest of us.”

“In the end, I can only say it again: if I lose a friend only because I am opposed to man who is, in my view, a mortal enemy of everything American, then so be it.”

Now, contrast this with Mark Steyn’s piece coming out on the same day:

Trump is demonized as a Caesar – the strong man as embodiment of the state – but in fact his rise was driven by highly specific policies: build the wall, end mass Muslim immigration, make health insurance purchasable across state lines. Trump is inviting you to vote for something; Clinton to vote for someone: With Hillary, power and authority are all, and public policy is simply collateral damage.

Nearly 50%, possibly more, of the country will vote for Donald Trump. Are they all vengeful, unthinking, “roaring drunks” beheld by “blind madness?” If so, why is the republic worth saving at all? With a good percentage of the U.S. electorate living on the dole and the rest just flailing in a haymaking rage, what’s the point?

I’m sick of being reduced to an unthinking zombie for taking Trump and his phenomenon seriously. People support Trump for valid reasons. Like it or not, his policy positions won support. For any candidate, choosing Trump is a mix of policy, personality, philosophy and gut decision. So I’m going to list the reasons, as crystalized as possible, that people would vote for Trump.

Let’s start with the most superficial, Personality:

  1. Donald Trump is energetic and cheerful. After years of morose droning, it’s refreshing to see a guy with a spry step. For all the negative Nancy talk, he seems to believe something can be done.
  2. Donald Trump is not condescending. He talks to voters (and not at them) like he knows them and is relatable. The Obama and media who love him have been so tired of the stupid people they must deign to govern. The people get the message loud and clear. Trump actually seems to like people and interact with them.
  3. Donald Trump is bombastic and funny. He’s impolitic. He’s a happy warrior. His style is a tonic to the focus-grouped politico-speak that passes for communication.

Now, there’s Philosophy:

  1. Donald Trump believes that political correctness is killing our culture. Without invoking “free speech” as a concept, he embraces it in action and is pushing back the boundaries of what can and cannot be said. He’s exasperated at the mealy mouthed b.s. that no one in real life–except the most insufferable social justice warriors, by the way–talks like. His frustration mirrors an electorate frustrated not just with moral rules about how to act but how to speak and worst, how to think.
  2. Donald Trump believes that the American culture is worth building and saving. His buildings are a monument to American greatness. He believes in bigger, better, faster, more awesome. This is a quintessentially American phenomenon. It’s Times Square and Hollywood and the St. Louis Arch and the Hoover Dam and skyscrapers and the moon and going to Mars. Apologize for America? No.
  3. Donald Trump believes in people. Read his books, look at old interviews. He’s like a white Oprah–encouraging people to follow their dreams, dream big, and work hard. Gild your house in gold and screw anyone who says you should do different. It’s your life–go out and make it great.

Then, the Policy:

  1. Donald Trump wants to put up a wall. It’s pretty simple. I may disagree with the implementation, but it IS a policy. It’s just a policy that a lot of people don’t like. Unfortunately for them, lots of people do like the policy which accounts for Trump’s success.
  2. Donald Trump wants to keep Americans safe in more concrete ways: stem the tide of Muslim immigration, for one. Again, people may not like it, but it IS a policy.
  3. Donald Trump wants to rebuild infrastructure. This is not the Barack Obama-enrich-your-Solyndra-buddies-to-redistribute-funds plan. When Trump says that he wants to rebuild airports and make them look beautiful, it’s difficult to argue with him that it’s necessary. Fly through LAX or LaGuardia.
  4. Donald Trump is for less hectoring, more freedom: This is less tangible, but it’s difficult to argue a negative. There’s all sorts of things Trump doesn’t want to do–regulate everything to death, in other words. Think bathrooms and guns and speech and religion, etc. He is willing to let people be.
  5. Repeal and replace Obamacare. This policy is harming nearly every American in some form or fashion.
  6. Donald Trump wants America to be respected abroad and that means countries pulling their own weight. He believes that a weak and obsequious America makes an unstable world.

Gut Decision: He can be obnoxious, but he’s not a politician. Hillary is horrible. He can’t be worse and could be a lot better.

Tom Nichols calls Trump a “a scam artist whose entire career has been based on victimizing the working class.” Donald Trump took a couple million dollars and made a couple billion. He lost big too, and then gained it back. He’s employed thousands of people. That is something. It’s not like he lost $6 billion of the taxpayers money as Secretary of State, for example.

Ross Douthat says that a vote for Trump:

…is a vote, in other words, for a far more chaotic and unstable form of political leadership (on the global stage as well as on the domestic) than we have heretofore experienced, and a leap unlike any that conservative voters have considered taking in all the long years since Roe v. Wade.

Indeed, it is. Why would sane people, maybe over 50% of the electorate, believe that voting this way is a rational choice? Tom Nichols believes it’s revenge. Other friends have told me that it’s racism (conservatives with straight faces have said this to me.) Ross Douthat gives this reasoning:

I agree with them that grave evils will follow from electing Hillary Clinton. But the Trump alternative is like a feckless war of choice in the service of some just-seeming end, with a commanding general who likes war crimes. It’s a ticket on a widening gyre, promising political catastrophe and moral corruption both, no matter what ideals seem to justify it.

If one believes “grave evils” will come of electing Hillary, part of the answer is right there.

The anti-Trumper has to believe every Trump bombast as literal (no satire, no humor, no exaggeration) while simultaneously arguing that he won’t follow-through with anything he’s said and will disappoint voters expecting someone conservative. Most people know, though, (well this writer does, anyway) that Trump isn’t a conservative. He’s all over the road ideologically–like most Americans.

The anti-Trumper has to believe that a known, grave evil emanating from Hillary Clinton is less bad than an unknown, hypothetical evil in Donald Trump. Hillary is 100% against conservative ideals, but…what? She will control the executive branch and solidify the corruption. That is absolutely certain. It’s bizarre to have people argue that Trump is quasi-liberal and might do bad things so don’t elect him because it makes you a bad person, while simultaneously saying that yes, Clinton is 100% liberal and will do bad things, but she’s not as bad and voting for her is the right thing to do. (Or the dodge–voting for Evan McMullin is the right thing to do.)

Republican voters have had it. They are rolling the dice with their eyes wide open. They believe if Trump only does half of what he says it will be better than all of what Hillary does.

The true conservative impulse is to conserve traditions, ideals and institutions. Guys like Mr. Nichols and Mr. Douthat seek to conserve processes and policies and status quo. They fear disruption. Republican voters are looking to conserve something more fundamental:  ideas that made America great–ideas like freedom of speech and belief, sovereignty, and American exceptionalism.

Donald Trump voters have legitimate, positive reasons to vote for the man. They also have legitimate reasons to fear Hillary Clinton.

Tom Nichols says this isn’t about politics. Wrong. This is exactly politics. People seek to vote their interests and when it’s between Hillary and Donald, they believe Donald Trump represents their interests best.


Melissa Mackenzie
Follow Their Stories:
View More
Melissa Mackenzie is Publisher of The American Spectator. Melissa commentates for the BBC and has appeared on Fox. Her work has been featured at The Guardian, PJ Media, and was a front page contributor to RedState. Melissa commutes from Houston, Texas to Alexandria, VA. She lives in Houston with her two sons, one daughter, and two diva rescue cats. You can follow Ms. Mackenzie on Twitter: @MelissaTweets.
Sign up to receive our latest updates! Register

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: The American Spectator, 122 S Royal Street, Alexandria, VA, 22314, You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact

Be a Free Market Loving Patriot. Subscribe Today!