The Spectacle Blog

Compare and Contrast

By on 10.30.05 | 4:23PM

"The truth is the engine of our judicial system, and if you compromise the truth, the whole process is lost.'' -- Special Prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald, last week, announcing the indictment of Lewis "Scooter" Libby, Chief of Staff of Vice President Dick Cheney, on two counts of making false statements to the FBI, two counts of perjury for lying to a grand jury, and one count of obstruction of justice.

"It depends on what the meaning of the word 'is' is." -- President Clinton, testifying before a grand jury in 1998, when asked whether he had previously lied under oath.

"Special Counsel Fitzgerald's investigation and ongoing legal proceedings are serious, and now the process moves into a new phase. In our system each individual is presumed innocent and entitled to due process and a fair trial." -- President Bush, commenting last week on the indictment of Scooter Libby.

Send to Kindle

Re: Belated Fitzmas

By on 10.30.05 | 4:19PM

I think I can reconcile nervousness at the White House with optimism that there will be no more indictments. Here's how:

Fitzgerald wants to put Scooter Libby in jail. Consider this detail from Michael Duffy (whose report absolutely drips with contempt for the Bush Administration): "a source close to the investigation told TIME that Fitzgerald and Libby's attorney Joseph Tate discussed possible plea options before the indictment was issued last week. But the deal was scotched because the prosecutor insisted that Libby do some 'serious' jail time." Fitzgerald would prefer to strike a deal that puts Libby away without a trial. Note this comment from Fitzgerald's press conference: "I can tell you that no one wants this thing to be over as quickly as I do, as quickly as Mr. Eckenrode does. I'd like to wake up in my bed in Chicago, he'd like to wake up in his bed in Philadelphia, and we recognize that we want to get this thing done."

Send to Kindle

The CIA vs. The White House

By on 10.30.05 | 3:11PM

Tom Maguire highlights evidence that Valerie Plame wasn't very covert, and that her outing apparently did no damage to CIA operations. But the CIA won't issue a damage assessment until legal proceedings are complete. Comments Maguire:

Is that how it works when our national security is threatened and lives are on the line - the CIA waits a few years until the trials are over, then assesses the damage?

Come on, we see through this - if the CIA prepared a formal report, it would be subpoenaed as evidence, and the jury would laugh out loud at the "no damage" assessment. So the CIA filed a criminal referral in 2003, got the White House tied up in a two year investigation, and now they are laughing out loud. Well played, especially if you like a spy service that shrugs off executive oversight by inventing crimes and playing dirty tricks.

That said, Fitzgerald saw through their outing ploy, else, where are the indictments for the leaks to Novak and Pincus?

Send to Kindle

Don’t Hire This Man

By on 10.30.05 | 1:48PM

Byron York wrote the other day that his legal-eagle sources "are unanimously appalled by the performance of Libby's lawyer, Joseph Tate." Apropos of that, check out Tate's public spin on the case. If your memory is foggy, that's something to say when you're testifying, not something to say after your sworn testimony fails to hold up. Doing so may well have saved Libby from the trouble he's in now.

Libby had better get a good criminal defense attorney to take the lead in his defense ASAP, if he doesn't want to spend the rest of his life in jail.

Send to Kindle

Cocktail Talk

By on 10.30.05 | 10:47AM

Saturday night hitting the booze again, talking to people still only talking about Miers and Plame.

Sunday morning, the buzz was about the "analysis" coming out of the newspapers and the talk shows, that being that President Bush had been wounded badly by all of this trouble, and that he needed to rebuild trust with the American people.

Many Republican and conservative consultants and White House advisers tell us that this just goes to show that once again, the MSM doesn't get it: "The President only has to worry about, really about making his base happy. A happy base means that legislation is moving, businesses are making money, national defense is strong, courts are full of restraint and government is shrinking. All of those things make the base happy, and guess what? That makes a lot of other people happy, too. Not Democrats or liberals, but people who count on election day," says a Republican pollster.

Send to Kindle

Belated Fitzmas

By on 10.29.05 | 11:42PM

We keep hearing from people who should know that some Republicans outside of the White House -- and some inside -- are being much too dismissive of the indictment of Lewis Libby and its potential repercussions on others down the road.

"This investigation is not over," says an adviser to the White House. "The indictment was meant to send a very clear message, and if people haven't figured it out yet, and they are breathing a sigh of relief, then they are in for a very bitter surprise."

Send to Kindle

Camp David

By on 10.29.05 | 11:35PM

As long as Miers doesn't return from Camp David with a renomination in hand, and Card doesn't return having been nominated for the Treasury Secretaryship he covets, what's the problem? If what the White House told us about Miers' role in the Roberts nomination process is accurate, and everything we've heard seems to bear that out, then she did a good job for the President and for conservatives. There is nothing to suspect they won't give the President strong advice.

White House insiders say that while President Bush has not yet had a "Come to Jesus" moment, the past ten days have come pretty close. He understands that this pick can either put his agenda back on track, or it can put his Presidency back into a sink hole of no return.

Right now, the biggest names in play are Alito, Luttig and Corrigan from Michigan. Any three would be more than satisfactory.

Send to Kindle

Time for a Transplantagenet

By on 10.29.05 | 7:18PM

Prince Charles, whose recent marriage to good old whatshername is a sedative for Americans, is coming to preach to us. According to the Daily Telegraph reports, Charles, "...will try to persuade George W Bush and Americans of the merits of Islam this week because he thinks the United States has been too intolerant of the religion since September 11...The Prince, who leaves on Tuesday for an eight-day tour of the US, has voiced private concerns over America's "confrontational" approach to Muslim countries and its failure to appreciate Islam's strengths."

Send to Kindle

From Posted Comments

By on 10.29.05 | 4:21PM

Someone going by the numerical code of "0701" pushes back on our reporting that Joe Wilson was talking himself up and his Niger trip in green rooms all over town: "Which is all hearsay on your part unless you have a verifiable source."

Well yes, we do. Beyond having heard it directly, NBC's Andrea Mitchell has reported several times about Wilson's activities and loose tongue prior to the publication of his NY Times op-ed.

Send to Kindle

Blood Lust

By on 10.29.05 | 1:57AM

If much of Washington is celebrating the indictment of Lewis "Scooter" Libby, the most famous vice-presidential chief of staff since Bill Kristol under Dan Quayle, the Washington Post's op-ed page hasn't joined in, at least not on slow Saturday. A joint op-ed by David B. Rivkin Jr. and Lee A. Casey blows Patrick Fitzgerald into space:

Special counsel Patrick Fitzgerald's indictment of I. Lewis "Scooter" Libby should be the final proof that the system of "special prosecutors" is bankrupt and ought to be abandoned.

Fitzgerald, a highly respected federal prosecutor from Chicago, was given the task of investigating whether Bush administration officials had violated the Intelligence Identities Protection Act by "leaking" the identity of CIA employee Valerie Plame.

Send to Kindle