The Spectacle Blog

Scrambling to Oversimplify

By on 5.26.11 | 2:49PM

I was amused by this item over at Frum Forum. Various writers, including me, are described as scrambling for "excuses" to explain the NY-26 loss. But the post doesn't bother to offer an actual arguments as to why these explanations are false or unpersuasive. It is simply assumed to be self-evident that the deciding factor was Paul Ryan's plan for Medicare and no other factor needs to be considered or discussed, let alone refuted.

Now, as a matter of fact, I think I gave a pretty balanced appraisal of what went wrong in NY-26 and what the implications could be. But pretending that Jack Davis is meaningless and that this was an ordinary election strikes me as pretty silly.

Like this Article

Print this Article

Print Article

More Articles From W. James Antle III