The Spectacle Blog

On Awlaki And Illiteracy

By on 10.1.10 | 2:30AM

In response to Wednesday's post about the targeting of Anwar al-Awlaki, Kevin Williamson splutters:

Whatever kind of conservatism is arguing that we should invest the president with sole, secret, unreviewable authority to order the assassination of U.S. citizens because the alternative is unworkable (!) in the considered view of John Tabin, because war exists (!) -- I am not that kind of conservative, I suppose. I propose we call that school of thought ahistorical, morally illiterate conservatism.

Perhaps we should call Williamson's school of thought plain old illiterate conservatism, as in incapable of reading, because I don't see how one could read my entire post and come away with the belief that I think the President should have "sole, secret, unreviewable authority" when I propose a mechanism of review to check the President's authority a few sentences after the bit that Williamson quotes.

If Williamson would like to respond to the points I actually made, I'll be happy to engage him, but it ought not be too much to ask for him to refrain from charging me with depravity on the basis of positions that I don't hold.

Like this Article

Print this Article

Print Article

More Articles From John Tabin