The Spectacle Blog

Torture or Not?

By on 1.4.06 | 7:04AM

Is the White House having the McCain torture bill both ways? After strongly opposing McCain's amendment to the defense appropriations bill, which President Bush signed last month, the White House appeared to cave to popular and political sentiment. However, the Boston Globe reports that President Bush, citing his Constitutional authority as commander-in-chief, is interpreting the law to have exceptions when national security is at risk.

I appreciate that White House lawyers have found a way around McCain's potentially disastrous law. But if they're correct, and the loopholes are Constitutional, wouldn't that suggest that the McCain bill is unconstitutional? And that, knowing this, the President signed it anyway? As with campaign finance, another sad, unconstitutional deal with the gentleman from Arizona, it appears that the President did the popular thing while crossing his fingers behind his back.

Like this Article

Print this Article

Print Article

More Articles From David Holman