The Spectacle Blog

The Amazing Political Double Standard for Religion

By on 9.13.09 | 10:24PM

The point has been made by outstanding thinkers like Stephen Carter and Richard John Neuhaus that the New York-Washington, D.C. establishment eats up left wing religion and declares it delicious.  Give a radical a cross and we have activists bravely "speaking truth to power" and "speaking prophetically."  Put the cross in the hands of a conservative and suddenly secularism is the better course and church and state must be rigorously separated lest theocracy loom every closer.

I tried to draw attention to this double standard in my new book The End of Secularism by talking about both history and current events which prove the point.  Mollie Ziegler Hemingway provided an excellent example in her Houses of Worship column for the Wall Street Journal last Friday as she reminded readers about the way faith-based initiatives have been viewed in this administration and its predecessor.  

Bush filled the faith-based initiatives office with a prominent Ivy League sociologist and then with a former lawyer for Mother Theresa.  Obama has chosen a Pentecostal preacher in his twenties to head up the office. Barry Lynn of the Americans for the Separation of Church and State was an avid critic of the Bush office.  His position today?  He serves on the advisory council's task force for the office.  Strangely, his concerns about the interaction of religion and politics seem to have dissolved now that the presidency has changed hands.  

As I read Ms. Hemingway's cutting piece, I couldn't help but think about the Swedish socialists of the late 19th and early 20th centuries who were determined to destroy the tie between the nation's church and state.  Once they gained power, however, they had a change of heart.  The church could prove useful under their enlightened leadership.  I wonder if Barry Lynn feels the same way.

Send to Kindle

Like this Article

Print this Article

Print Article