Here are my thoughts on Saturday’s GOP debate broadcast by ABC
and co-sponsored by the Des Moines Register and Yahoo.
Rick Santorum - A respectable performance. He
didn’t complain about not getting enough time to speak but time is
running out on him. He did get a hearty laugh from the audience at
the end of the debate when he said the Republican National
Committee didn’t know his name when he first got elected Congress.
Quin Hillyer has
a good take on Santorum’s dilemma.
Rick Perry - He had several good moments during
the debate. Perry was the voice of reason when the other
candidates were arguing over Newt Gingrich’s statement about the
Palestinians. He drew solid applause when he said that President
Obama’s foreign policy was the problem, not Newt’s
statement. Perry also connected with the debate audience when
he said his fidelity to his wife “is stronger than a Texas
handshake.” Another good Perry moment was when he speaking about
his childhood said that “luxury wasn’t in his lexicon.”
Perry was feeling his oats. He even felt confident to challenge
Romney on the individual mandate although he wouldn’t take a
$10,000 bet on it.
Mitt Romney - He had a very good night. When
Newt reminded everyone he would have been a career politician had
he beat Ted Kennedy in 1994, Romney said it was the best thing that
ever happened to him. He was less solid ground when it came to the
discussion on Israel. But he was quick on the draw and seemed to
connect with the audience more than usual. When Bachmann asserted
he wouldn’t repeal Obamacare, Romney drew big applause when he
said, “Oh yes, I would.”
Newt Gingrich - Prior to tonight, not so much
as a negative word had been directed at Newt’s way. Well, that sure
changed. Naturally it was to be expected with Gingrich’s rise in
the polls. Of course, George Stephanopoulos put out the bait and
once Romney bit everyone else jumped in. Newt was on the defensive
and wasn’t at his usual ease. He drew jeers when he said that
Romney would have been a career politician had he beat Ted Kennedy
in 1994. However, he got back on track and more than held his own
with Romney especially where it concerned Israel. From here on,
Ron Paul - He put in another solid performance
and resonated with the audience throughout the night. The fact that
Perry and Romney made a point of lavishing praise upon him is
indication that for better or for worse he has become a powerful
force in the Republican Party.
Michele Bachmann - It seemed like she was
trying to get by on cuteness (i.e. “Newt Romney”, “Win, Win, Win”)
although her anecdote about Palestinian indoctrination of children
was poignant.
Jon Huntsman - It is amazing what he
contributes to the discussion when he’s not in the room.
The next GOP debate is scheduled to take place in five days on
December 15th at 9 p.m. in Sioux City and will air on the Fox News
Channel.
RJ| 12.11.11 @ 2:28AM
I think the key point of the debate tonight, which unsurprisingly went unnoticed by the ABC commentators was Mitt Romney's response to Newt's recent comments about Palestinians and Newt's rejoinder. Romney admitted that Newt's comment was accurate, but Mitt stated he would only say it after calling the Israeli Prime Minister and asking if it would help. Newt's rejoinder, about the need to speak the truth and reminding people of Ronald Reagan going against his advisers in labeling the Soviet Union as an "evil empire" and later saying "Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this wall" was a killer. That exchange illustrated the weakness of Romney and the strength of Newt. Romney was hurt far more by this exchange than by his "$10,000 bet" with Perry.
Also, given the number of silly questions (How many jobs can you promise in 4 years) and Democratic bias of the commentators, I think the GOP candidates should revert to a prior format, where they agree to appear on networks, such as CNN, but only if the questions are asked by more informed sources, such as a prior debate where The Heritage Foundation and the American Enterprise Institute. We would get much better questions and have better debates.
Regarding the other candidates, I thought Bachmann and Paul did well.
Kitty| 12.11.11 @ 6:55PM
I loved his Kennedy comment. Those jeers were from McRomney's supporters, of which I am not.
Wayne| 12.11.11 @ 8:22PM
I just heard Obama have the gall to say that he saved the US from the Great Depression. One can't make this stuff up. I we can't knock the tar out of Obama in 2012 this country deserves to face the next 20 years with Obama.