The American Spectator : The Spectacle Blog : All 'Checkoff' Taxes Are Dumb, 'Christmas Tree Tax' Included

Text Size

The Spectacle Blog

All 'Checkoff' Taxes Are Dumb, 'Christmas Tree Tax' Included

By Joseph Lawler on 11.9.11 @ 10:26AM

The news that the Obama Department of Agriculture is implementing a "Christmas Tree Tax" has provoked outrage from folks worried about a War on Christmas -- and also those worried about taxes.

The tax, however, wasn't the Obama administration's idea. It was the Christmas tree lobby's creation. Real Christmas trees have been steadily losing market share to artificial trees, so growers and retailers lobbied the Department of Agriculture to institute a checkoff tax and use the funds to promote real trees. The USDA has similar programs for a number of commodities, e.g. "Got Milk?" and "Beef: It's What's for Dinner" The feds are authorized to raise revenues for such programs under the Commodity Promotion, Research, and Information Act of 1996.

Needless to say, there is no problem in the Christmas tree market that necessitates this program. I haven't seen any poll numbers, but I'm going to go ahead and assume that Americans are satisfied with the currently available types of Christmas trees, and that their choices of trees are reasonably informed.

The Christmas Tree Tax is not part of some larger War on Christmas, it just represents the successful lobbying efforts of Christmas tree growers. But their struggles are not the public's problem. If they want to fund a promotional campaign for their product, they should do it themselves, without involving the USDA.

That goes for all similar checkoff taxes, such as the ones for beef, milk, soybeans, etc. There's no reason the federal government should be involved in shaping consumer preferences. The Christmas Tree Tax has done something useful in reminding us that the Commodity Promotion, Research, and Information Act of 1996 is a dumb law.

Update: Beef slogan corrected.

View all comments (5) | Leave a comment

C Bowen| 11.9.11 @ 11:12AM

Thanks, Newt!

Bill Hussein O'Stalin| 11.9.11 @ 11:26AM

The Department of Agriculture should be put out to pasture.

Jack Park| 11.9.11 @ 11:28AM

A law that lets an agency decide to impose checkoff taxes on "commodities," which turn out to include beef, milk, soybeans, and Christmas trees sounds like a vague and overbroad delegation of authority from Congress to the agency. We need to put teeth into the non-delegation doctrine.

Rick Tarkka| 11.9.11 @ 11:46AM

"Where's the Beef" was a marketing slogan from Wendy's. Not USDA.

Adam| 11.9.11 @ 12:15PM

Enough with the cronyism already! People wake up and realize that it's no longer a Republic for the people by the people...its' now, for the corporations with the most money for their pocket books! They've cleverly disguised the word lobbyist for someone who buys off our leaders to have whatever they want for to better their P&L and shareholders...This country its on its way to becoming just another 3rd world country ran by bribery & payoffs! Tax Christmas trees for a PR campaign? Really? Are you kidding me?...