Total student loan debt
continues to skyrocket even as other kinds of consumer debt are
slowly coming down in the wake of the financial crisis. It
continues to get more expensive to go to college, students are
leaving with a lot more debt, and they’re graduating with degrees
less likely to see a payoff. Oh, and the federal government owns
85% of all student loan debt.
Just like housing, many student loans were made with
little or no research into whether borrowers were fit. Federal
Stafford loans are basically automatic for college students, and
government backing for other types of loans gave other student
lenders little reason to be picky… Defaults on federal student
loans jumped from 7 percent to 8.8 percent in the most recent
fiscal year. That measures just recent borrowers who were already
behind within two years of their first payments coming
due.
One of the things that has seemed to unite a lot of the 99%ers
is the complaint that a college degree isn’t a ticket to universal
success any more. And they’re right: it’s not! It used to be
thought that just any college degree could get you a
good-paying job in your field of choice. That’s turning out not to
be true. The degrees
that pay are called STEM degrees: science, technology,
engineering and math. Sending more kids to college to get visual
arts degrees does nothing positive for the economy and is a poor
individual investment decision.
Alex Tabarrok last week noted a shocking statistic:
more people graduated with computer science degrees in 1985 than
did in 2009. There are fewer engineers and about the same
number of statisticians. But more and more kids are going to
college in droves. What gives?
They’re majoring in things like performing arts, communications,
psychology… lots of humanities and soft sciences. And the federal
government takeover of student loans - passed in the Obamacare
reconciliation bill - puts the federal government on the hook
for all these bad investments in humanities degrees.
There won’t be a student loan bubble like there was a housing
bubble. The economy won’t completely collapse when it turns out
that many of these degrees aren’t worth the debt. But the current
state of affairs, in which we think that everyone should go to
college no matter what their choice of discipline, is
unsustainable. Somehow, I doubt the regulators are going to catch
this one either.
sotto voce | 11.7.11 @ 2:29PM
Obama is pushing the fallacious idea that everyone deserves a college degree for his own reasons, which have nothing to do with whether or not a person earns a useful degree and everything to do with creating an army of useful idiots at taxpayer expense. He knows universities have become indoctrination mills for the left. As anecdotal evidence, I offer this story of a dear friend who went back to school after a lengthy hiatus to earn her BA in social studies. She graduated but has been unable to find a job in social services because she fulfilled her language requirement with German instead of Spanish (where was her student adviser?). All she took away from her expensive education are dyed-in-the-wool beliefs that capitalism is inherently evil and that communism is superior to a constitutional republic. She's an otherwise smart person and old enough to know better. Her transformation was alarming and took place right before my eyes. To maintain our friendship we avoid political discussions.
jay| 11.7.11 @ 3:34PM
The site provided does not support the idea that STEM is where the money is, so much as it indicates that engineers make more. Perhaps there is other information about supply and demand that better bolsters the case, but looking at the chart, Biology majors are at $37,900 and Philosophy majors get $39,800. The methodology indicates that professors of Philosophy would not be included in that figure either.
There is also the possibility that as we succeed in encouraging students to pursue STEM, that the wages will fall.
It might be best to educate all the collegebound that the receipt of a degree will not cause a house with a Prius in the garage to be deeded to them, and that they will still have to compete for a job regardless of educational attainment.
Bob K.| 11.7.11 @ 9:23PM
And what does all this have to do with Herman Cain groping a Bimbo?
PCC| 11.8.11 @ 1:23AM
Government student loan guarantees have fueled the exorbitant rise in university fees and should be capped.
Josh Winters | 11.8.11 @ 5:47PM
If you want to look at stats then why is it that the unemployment rate is over 9% for people without a college degree and hovering over 3% for students with a degree.
A college education gives you opportunity, which is a hard word to find these days given the current state of the economy.