The American Spectator

home
ADVERTISEMENT
Print Email
Text Size

The Spectacle Blog

Nick Schulz argues today in Forbes that there is such a thing as free lunch: high-skilled immigration. "Kick open the nation's doors to high-skilled immigrants," he writes. "There isn't a bigger no-brainer move than this." He further argues that the "wide consensus" among those who have studied the issue suggests that high-skilled immigrants are net job creators.

There are two problems with this free lunch, however. The first is that family reunification is the primary basis of legal immigration into the United States, not skills. Each year, over 70 percent of legal immigrants are admitted mainly because they are related to someone already here. That immigration, plus the vast majority of our illegal immigration, is low-skilled. That's part of the reason there is also a "wide consensus" among labor economists that the net economic benefit of our current immigration is actually very small, to the extent that it exists at all.

Second, it is debatable to what extent programs like the H-1B and L-1 visas attract people who are truly high-skilled and job-makers rather than job-takers.  These are non-immigrant visas, of course, but it's not entirely clear they constitute a free lunch.

Nevertheless, as I noted in my review of Mitch Daniels' book, more high-skilled immigration may mean less of the kind of immigration we are already getting.

View all comments (13) | Leave a comment

Occam's Tool| 10.5.11 @ 5:33PM

Folks: Take a look at how New Zealand screens immigrants. Adopt a very similar policy here. Build Southern Fence and back up.

I was a New Zealand Permanent Resident on my way to Citizenship when my wife and I said "enough" to NZ's constant rain and crappy food. (I was also being recruited to run for MP from Rotorua from the National Party when I got Citizenship) They do a FINE job of vetting. Clint, for example, would not be allowed to join as literacy is required.

Clint| 10.5.11 @ 6:59PM

Tool Job wouldn't be allowed in as a moral degenerate.

btims| 10.5.11 @ 5:34PM

As a 20 yr veteran of software development (what used to be called programming), I can assure you that H-1B visa workers (mostly from India and China), nine times out of ten, are merely ordinary low to mid-level professionals. Some are good, some not so good, just like native born Americans.

And again, most use the "guest worker" visa to immediately start to petition for an immigrant visa to stay forever and immediately start bringing twenty of their closet relatives to our shores.

It's mostly unnecessary. It had some use in the late 1990's, right before the "year 2000" scare but today it's just another immigration scam - abused by nearly all.

tomq| 10.5.11 @ 5:36PM

All immigration into the USA should be reduced for the next 10 years at least.

We are not obligated to accept half of Mexico and half of the world. High immigration is a function of big government, of liberalism.

RND| 10.5.11 @ 11:19PM

Just about a little over a month into the new school year....

It would be so refreshing to hear honest small town and public school official reveal the incredible hoops they are having to dive through to accomodate the school-aged children now here from Somalia, Ethopia, Ghana, Nigeria, Liberia....

Whump. Don't look, your town just 85 minutes outside of Atlanta has been selected as THE place for new U.S. immigrant arrivals. 1,400 of them.

Doesn't sound like much? That represents a 18% overnight increase in your town's population.

Kids often with just one parent. No language skills either in the child or parent. The parent is inaccessible in the day because she's up early on a long bus ride into her menial job in Atlanta -- and home late at night.

Kid and his siblings who two months ago were in Africa are on their own. Latch key.

This occurs all the time in U.S. communities and goes without notice. Unreported. No attention given to this. Why?

Mike| 10.5.11 @ 5:38PM

You may be right. However, it seems to me that arguing the point with stats that have been skewed due to immigration policy weakens the argument considerably. The immigration stats only reveal what our historical policy has been (which has favored family ties), not who would immigrate in the absence of significant barriers.

rssg| 10.5.11 @ 6:43PM

Endless LEGAL immigration is really more of a problem then illegal immigration - bad as it is.

What is the purpose of ballooning the US population to half a billion? The political class, both parties, want this. Why?

America doesn't belong to Americans anymore. It's probably too late.

Bob K.| 10.5.11 @ 7:15PM

Because the replacement birthrate to sustain the Social Programs needed for an aging society is not big enough. Abortion is only one of the reasons for this. Our women don't want to have children and our men don't want to raise families.

That is why the political class wants immigration and that is why they won't talk about it either.

Kipling wrote about it in 1919:

"On the first Feminian Sandstones we were promised the Fuller life

(Which started by loving our neighbor and ended by loving his wife)

Till our women had no more children and the men lost reason and faith,

And the Gods of the Copybook Headings said: 'The Wages of Sin is Death.' "

WJ| 10.5.11 @ 9:08PM

The new people aren't going to continue to fund SS for old white people. It just won't happen. Using that argument is illogical.

Pelligrino| 10.5.11 @ 11:07PM

Bob K. is correct. Fully correct. This is why you see anything but Europeans as you walk through European streets in France, Belgium, Germany, Austria, Spain, parts of Greece and Italy. Ditto for the major cities of Britain.

All those people have been willfully granted entry in this vain hope that they will somehow peaceably assimilate, educate their kids well, spend money, and buffer the emptying tax coffers against collapse.

The Eurozone argument heard in Berlin, Madrid, Paris, Rome, and Brussels: "These people from Eastern Europe, North Africa, Sub-Saharan Africa, the MidEast, Asia buy cars, too. Even if used. And they need petrol to fill the tanks. And they need apartments, food, clothes, shoes. This bolsters our flagging economies even if it is just at the discount stores and groceries.

We do not procreate; they do. Thus, the doors are open to them -- by hook or by crook.

No, in all honesty we don't like them in the least and we don't want them. We destest them. But our welfare state collapses without them.

They are ill-educated and don't esteem education, tend to be lazy, tend toward too much crime. They lack the intelligence to even learn our language correctly. But.... But they make babies."

Those are the words you would hear -- very quietly spoken and only in private, in confidence -- in all the Eurozone capitals by the elites who run the show.

Brittanicus| 10.5.11 @ 9:22PM

NOT JUST FARMERS, AGRICULTURE? IT IS EVERY AMERICAN BUSINESS? SHAME ON YOU!

Pay Farm labor a decent living wage, with health care and education for their family, instead of dumping the illegal labor costs on the taxpayer. Then you will find people desperate for a job, any job will come forward to work the fields. Farmers and giant agricultural consortium’s have been underpaying illegal labor forever and along with all the special subsidies, the same as most business owners. It has been proofed that it only cost a few more cents to the consumer, for vegetable and fruit if labor for the agrarian community pay fair wages for the work done. My grandfather picked apples in Washington State as did other family members. To make ends meet after World War Two, my distant relatives in the English countryside, picked strawberries for the local farmers. Make it a national policy to implement the E-Verify bill (H.R. 2885), identifiable as the “Legal Workforce Act”. Contact your own local Senator or Representative and insist as a voter to your federal politician at 202-224-3121.

This is just not about the farmers; it’s about meat packing plants, factories and manufacturing. Of course they don’t want to employ regular Americans-legal residents. It’s about any company owner—big or small—who wants to pay as little as possible, with no restrictions on as little they want to pay, for a person’s labor. They have violated this ‘Rule of Law’ because there have been no restrictions on prohibitions to stop them, until Lamar Smith’s H.R. 2885. Special interest groups and the radical open border activists, are currently trying to kill the federal ‘Secure Communities’ initiative. Any individual that is apprehended by the police will have their fingerprints forwarded to ICE, Homeland Security and the FBI for processing. Police data-bases can quickly assess who has been previously arrested, whether he/she is an illegal alien or not.

Learn the facts about illegal alien costs, statistics and business corruption at NumbersUSA, Judicial Watch and American Patrol. Make every Business, Company and workplace be committed to E-Verify or face harsh consequences. No business owner, no matter who he is, should think he is above the law. That also is a constant with political figures who own grape plantations in the bread basket of central California. This is not just for Farmers and agriculture but for every business owner, so that we can put every American worker in a job and stop catering to other counties impoverished. Go further and re-enact the "Bracero Project" of 1942 with rules and regulations, arranged so migrants from across the Southern border have easier access to specific jobs. The “Bracero Program” established why the plan proved immeasurably accepted among so many migrants, for whom seasonal labor in the US presented grand opportunities, despite some of the poor conditions they often were confronted with in the fields and camps.

Even under some poor situations they saved money, could buy consumer good, tools or an older vehicle, and returned home with new outlooks and a greater sense of self-respect.
In places as Mexico counselors studied these positive aspects of the economic and cultural effects of bracer project. If they are retained for employment the government must oversee they are treated correctly. They have to be issued a field workers visa that terminates at the end of harvesting and a mandatory return to their own country. Only through an employment office at entry ports can these people be hired and not through third parties or recruited by less than honest business enterprises. If they remain free of any major problems while employed in the U.S., they can renew their visas. As in Mexico—every person is tracked; all the farm and agricultural workers must be tracked, so they cannot decide to drop the job they are allocated to and disappear in the American job market. The "Bracero program" seemed to work very well, until it was dismantled in 1964. Through unfettered fraud millions of illegal aliens and their families have arrived here, after the 1986 Immigration Immigration Reform and Control Act (IRCA)

Eventually there was an increasing apprehension among businesses owners that the provisions within the guide lines of the program ensured the amplification of costs for the imported labor. This fair program mandated an assured level of wages, housing, food and Health care for the workers (to be paid for by the employers) that kept the standard of living above what many from across the border. Farmers and their associated Agrarian colleagues realized they could elevate their profits, by enjoying the extremely hard work in the fields, by hiring illegal aliens who are now exploited. Agriculture didn’t want to pay for the health care or schooling for their children and other benefits, as in the orderly federal “Bracero program.” They prefer the Taxpayers carry the weight of costs for the labor that they hire. Farmers already receive huge subsidies from the U.S. Government. Simple fact the farmers and all the growers of produce got greedy, for even larger profits.

A new fair migrant worker program will never, ever be possible under the entrenched GOP establishment and many in the Democratic ranks. Illegal Immigration will never end under the elitists Republicans or Democrats who really run the House and Senate. Americans can join forces and stop the overcrowded classroom full of the children of illegal parents. Stop the suffocation in the emergency rooms from foreign nationals crowding the waiting areas. Unable to locate a job; the only reasonable answer is to ‘Self Deport’ and will no longer steal jobs, approved by businesses that hire them. A very large majority of people that come here and fall into a financial backwash owing to the original sponsor, not able to support his immediate or her immediate family members. This becomes a burden to U.S. taxpayers who end up with the yoke of supporting these people through—CHAIN MIGRATION.

Many politicians have their own revenues in the illegal alien labor market. Only the TEA PARTY will stop the pollution that emanates from Washington and the Congress.

L A Stich| 10.6.11 @ 9:08AM

If you're not acquainted with Prof. Norm Matloff's work, you should be:

http://www.cs.ucdavis.edu/~matloff/h1b.html

He has the credentials--personal and professional--to debunk the "H1B" mania.

yisong| 10.25.11 @ 2:10AM

Roller bearing is composed of axial and radial two roller bearing assembly, bearings reduce
volume, simplifies the installation structure, thereby reducing the manufacturing cost.
http://www.1stbearing.com

Leave a Comment

N.B. We encourage readers to share and discuss their thoughtful and relevant comments about this Spectator article. Comments are routinely monitored and will be deleted if profane, bigoted, or grossly impolite. Please be respectful. (And don't feed the trolls!) Thank you.

More Blog Posts by W. James Antle, III

http://spectator.org/blog/2011/10/05/immigration-and-free-lunch

ADVERTISEMENT

SPONSORED LINKS

Special Feature

Better that we become a nation of choosers rather than beggars. Our symposium on choice from the May, 2012 issue:

A Time for Choosing

James Piereson

The Road from Serfdom

Stephen Moore and Peter Ferrara

FLASHBACK TO: 1984

Clip of the Day

Most Popular Articles

Meet the Flukes!

F. H. Buckley | 5.25.12

The Wisconsin Turning Point

Peter Ferrara | 5.23.12

In Search of Muhammad

Aymenn Jawad Al-Tamimi | 5.25.12

Age and Kyl

Quin Hillyer | 5.25.12

Follow Me

Jay D. Homnick | 5.25.12

A Test of National Honor

Hal G.P. Colebatch | 5.25.12

How About the Record of DOE Capital?

William Tucker | 5.25.12

The Great Debate

R. Emmett Tyrrell, Jr. | 5.24.12

ADVERTISEMENT