The American Spectator

home
ADVERTISEMENT
Print Email
Text Size

The Spectacle Blog

Amish Carrots, Corporate Sticks

Almost ten days ago the New York Times reported how Amish farmers are being encouraged by environmental bureaucrats and activist groups to clean up the way they farm.

Ten days ago the New York Times reported how Amish farmers are being encouraged by environmental bureaucrats and activist groups to clean up the way they farm:

For now, [EPA]’s strategy is to approach each farmer individually in collaboration with state and local conservation officials and suggest improvements like fences to prevent livestock from drifting toward streams, buffers that reduce runoff and pits to keep manure stored safely.

“These are real people with their own histories and their own needs and their own culture,” said John Hanger, the secretary of environmental protection in Pennsylvania. “It’s about treating people right, and in order to treat people right, you’ve got to be able to start where they are at.”

Yesterday the Lancaster Intelligencer-Journal followed with their own story:

(Environmental group) PennFuture said it chose the 45 farmers invited to a June 30 luncheon at the township building based on high nitrate levels where streams were sampled and the location of farms that slope toward the streams.

The group hopes the farmers will take advantage of offers to have consultants do free on-farm assessments so they know what might be needed to comply with state and federal laws.

How kind that environmentalists and eco-crats want to play nice over tea-and-crumpets with the “small people” in Amish country. But I wonder how green pressure groups or the powers within Big Regulation would treat them if they conducted business as a large corporation — maybe it would sound like this:

  • “All other industries in Pennsylvania are responsible for the waste they generate and Longbeard Agriculture should be no exception.”
  • We cannot let Sen. Rightwinger be the roadblock that prevents our state forests from receiving the protection they deserve. We cannot let him protect Longbeard Agriculture from paying their fair share for the public costs associated with their agriculture.”
  • It could not be more clear that we need to stop investing in a cow-pie generating economy and kickstart a beef-free revolution.”

You get the picture. But since the Amish are a small group with no money, they are due all respect and should be met “where they are at.”

Everyone else can go to hell.

topics:
Environmentalism, Environmental Protection Agency

View all comments (9) |

Taxpayer| 6.17.10 @ 5:31PM

Wrong. The Amish are a small group with a LOT of money. They just don't flash it around nor squander it.

LiveFreeOrDie| 6.17.10 @ 6:01PM

I would consider the Amish a worthy opponent and so have the "eco-crats" for two reasons, defense and defense. Their worth is largely in CASH and in property they inhabit. Both of those are very hard to get at legally (ie fines, lawsuits)
They are practically immune to the kind of public affairs attacks that work so well on business. Anyone who messes with the Amish will come out looking like a jerk with nothing to show for the effort.

Taxpayer| 6.18.10 @ 1:41PM

Actually, the Amish are not totally removed from the modern world when it comes to investing their money. I had an Amish landlord. He was in charge of investing his clan's money, mostly for retirement funds. Back in the 80s, his clan was majority owner of an electric company in Florida! I kid you not! This guy jetted around on a private jet to supervise the myriad holdings of his clan. And he was the fairest, most decent businessman I have ever met.

So even if the eco-crats take off the kid gloves and try to play nasty with the Amish, I'm not worried because they've got their own people, like my old landlord, to defend their interests.

Tim*| 6.17.10 @ 8:12PM

That's Right Taxpayer.

" No dream comes true until you wake up and go to work ."

peter | 6.17.10 @ 11:37PM

why did you delete my replies ?

Peter B. Nelson| 6.18.10 @ 2:55PM

Longbeard Agriculture? Let's extend the analogy: as lawn-chemical runoff is a major pollutant, let's corporatize Lancaster County's English homeowners and regulate Poloshirt Lawncare just like other industries. Imagine the possibilities!

Even as satire, I find the concept terrifying. Would you really defend corporations by corporatizing citizens?

Related Blog Posts

More Blog Posts by Paul Chesser

http://spectator.org/blog/2010/06/17/amish-carrots-corporate-sticks

ADVERTISEMENT

SPONSORED LINKS

FLASHBACK TO: 1995

Clip of the Day

Most Popular Articles

Obama and the IRS: The Smoking Gun?

Jeffrey Lord | 5.20.13

The Inoperative Jay Carney

Jeffrey Lord | 5.23.13

Holding AWOL Obama Accountable

Betsy McCaughey | 5.23.13

Obama's Imbroglios

R. Emmett Tyrrell, Jr. | 5.23.13

Lerner's Plea

Ray V. Hartwell | 5.23.13

Laying Down My Pen

Quin Hillyer | 5.23.13

Time to Go for the Kill

Peter Ferrara | 5.22.13

ADVERTISEMENT