The American Spectator

home
ADVERTISEMENT
Print Email
Text Size

The Spectacle Blog

If the Kids Only Had a Pet Byrd

Climate Depot’s Marc Morano points out a Beeville, Texas fourth-grader’s victory in the junior division of the 2010 National Science Fair with her project, “Disproving Global Warming.”

UPDATE 11:50 a.m. June 9: The below post was based upon a story that was learned to be a hoax — my apologies. — Paul Chesser

Climate Depot’s Marc Morano points out a Beeville, Texas fourth-grader’s victory in the junior division of the 2010 National Science Fair with her project, “Disproving Global Warming.” Defeating more than 50,000 contestants, Julisa Castillo’s research was reportedly judged by a National Science Foundation-chosen panel of judges that allegedly included Al Gore. Her conclusion: “There is not enough evidence to prove global warming is occurring.”

Beeville’s local newspaper reported on the competition Castillo faced at her own school:

Fourth-grader Kaleb Maguire proved that all tap water in Beeville was the same quality.

He took samples of water at 10 different sites across town and came to the conclusion that because the water originated at the same source — the city’s fresh water plant — the samples contained the same amount of alkalinity, pH and free chlorine.

Fourth-grader Amber Martinez concluded that worms subjected to music were more alert than those not.

And fourth-grader Sam Waters’ project was no doubt much enjoyed by his pet pooch, Lucky.

Sam wanted to know which meat his dog would like more. Turns out Lucky preferred chicken over both hotdogs and sausage.

Fifth-grader Savannah Gonzales found out that ants prefer cheese over sugar, but classmate Misty Nienhouse concluded that ants preferred sugar over cheese. Tessa Giannini’s science project also seemed to prove that ants preferred sugar over cheese, bread or anything else.

However, fourth-grader Faith Hernandez conducted a similar experiment and concluded ants preferred cheese over ham.

Yet, Jose Vivesos, a fourth-grader, concluded that ants prefer sugar water over anything else.

My question is, is any of this less worthy than the pork the National Science Foundation already wastes taxpayer money on?

topics:
Global Warming, Climate Change, Al Gore, Robert Byrd

View all comments (10) |

Bradley J. Fikes | 6.7.10 @ 10:11AM

This story is probably false and there is no independent confirmation from the National Science Fair. Castillo was not even a finalist. I give other here: http://j.mp/nsfno

Marc Morano | 6.7.10 @ 10:36AM

Reality Check: This story is accurate and was confirmed with local news source who reported on it. In fact, the editor knows the girls father.
Repeat, story is legit.
Thanks

Bradley J. Fikes | 6.7.10 @ 11:50AM

Marc,
Did you get independent confirmation from the National Science Fair? Is there a press release? If so, please post the link.

ed smith| 6.7.10 @ 1:16PM

Spell check: It's Beeville, TX, not Beesville.

Fact Checker| 6.8.10 @ 9:43AM

This is a hoax. See http://initforthegold.blogspot.....-low.html

Marc Morano | 6.8.10 @ 12:06PM

Update: 4th-Grade Skeptical Climate Science 'winner' revealed as hoax! - 'What sort of person would manipulate the emotions and expectations of a ten-year-old girl'

http://www.climatedepot.com/a/.....arold-girl

Fact Checker| 6.11.10 @ 8:35PM

The father has admitted authoring the hoax: http://www.mysoutex.com/view/f.....fair-hoax?

2gts | 6.12.11 @ 5:49PM

I'm not surprised the dad feels sorry about it, what an awful thing to do.

Bobby | 5.18.12 @ 3:36AM

Folks, this is hoax. End of the story.

Related Blog Posts

More Blog Posts by Paul Chesser

http://spectator.org/blog/2010/06/07/if-the-kids-only-had-a-pet-byr

ADVERTISEMENT

SPONSORED LINKS

FLASHBACK TO: 1995

Clip of the Day

Most Popular Articles

My Generation’s Disease

Benjamin Brophy | 5.17.13

The Liberal Union Behind the IRS

Jeffrey Lord | 5.16.13

Not Ready for Primetime Players

Daniel J. Flynn | 5.17.13

Assessing a Week of Scandal

Matt Purple | 5.17.13

Oops, Maybe Government is Tyrannical

Marta H. Mossburg | 5.17.13

The View From the Other Side

George H. Wittman | 5.17.13

From Bimbos to Benghazi

Jeffrey Lord | 5.9.13

USPS: Radical Surgery Needed

Peter Hannaford | 5.17.13

ADVERTISEMENT