Research by the University of Alberta's Augustana Campus
contends that children's programming can carry underlying
political themes that may surprise parents. After analyzing 23
episodes of Thomas and Friends, a
show about a train, his friends and their adventures on a
fictional island, political scientist Shauna Wilton
was able to identify themes that didn't seem
constructive for youngsters.
"While the show conveys a number of positive political values
such as tolerance, listening, communicating with others and
contributing to the community, it also represents a
conservative political ideology that punishes
individual initiative, opposes critique and change, and
relegates females to supportive
roles," said Wilton, an assistant professor in
the Department of Social Sciences at Augustana Campus.
The Thomas and Friends TV series is shown in 130 countries
around the world. Wilton noted storylines in several episodes
that divided the characters into different social
classes and punished those who tried to gain
individual power. "Any change is seen as disrupting the natural
order of things." As well, of 49 main characters
listed in the show, only eight were female,
reflecting a general trend among children's programming, Wilton
said. (Emphasis added.)
Coming soon to a PBS station near you: "Barney Is Gay
(That's Why Dinosaurs Are Extinct)," and "Let's Deport Dora the
Explorer."
LOL, Gay extinct Barney & Deported Dora, very funny. You
definately get the laugh of the day award for that!
Liberal Reader| 12.10.09 @ 12:50AM
McCain --
Popular culture -- driven entirely by the free market that
creates it -- is a seething, corrupt sewer. One watches music
videos and most television programs and films and wonders how
stupid, vapid, and morally insane a culture can actually be
before it collapses into a debased chaotic wreckage. America is
fast becoming a suburb casino of Hollywood, and it can only end
in tears. 2 and a half million people are in prison in this
country, and the public schools are -- as you point out --
groaning with mediocrity.
Your critique here seems mighty thin. Maybe this political
scientist is a little off-track, but I hardly see this as a good
example of what is wrong with education or entertainment designed
for children.
At any rate, I hardly see how the relentless privatization of the
country can cure any of this. The new "conservative" agenda seems
to have a vision of America in which everyone is locked behind
closed doors, armed to the teeth, watching Glenn Beck blubber and
weep on cable television.
What can save this country is a revitalization of the civic
spirit. Great public works, a massive increase in spending on
education (together with a massive increase of standards for
teachers and students), and a campaign to improve civility and
respect for the law -- before people wind up in front of judges
to receive their sentences.
"Great public works, a massive increase in spending on
education…"
Sure, that should work, because throwing money at our problems
has always worked so well in the past.
Terry Baker| 2.8.10 @ 9:05AM
Throwing money at the problem of "World War II" was what finally
ended the Great Depression?
Throwing money from the bottom of society to the top of society
has been our main direction since...care to guess if there's any
change to be expected from this except what we now see?
JohnD| 12.10.09 @ 8:06AM
I noticed what they say above myself when I used to watch it with
my son, who has now outgrown Thomas and moved on to other
pursuits.
Thomas the Tank Engine does reinforce many principles we
conservatives hold dear, like respect for authority, order, hard
work, and self-discipline, but in many cases it is more
monarchist. Sir Topham Hatt, runs the railway with an iron fist,
and tolerates absolutely NO challenge to his authority.
I used to tell my son as we watched Thomas, "If I worked for Sir
Topham Hatt and he talked to me the way he talks to Thomas and
the other engines, I'd punch him right in his fat face." My son
used to laugh at that.
Thomas| 12.10.09 @ 9:43AM
First a disclaimer. I am no relation to any character in the
television show.
Having watched this series with my youngest child for quite a
while, I can safely say that all of this is a load of piffle.
People put on their preconception specs, project their personal
prejudices into the show and see what they want to see.
The social science professor stated the following, "it also
represents a conservative political ideology that punishes
individual initiative, opposes critique and change, and relegates
females to supportive roles,". Perhaps this is true of
Conservatives in Canada, but it is hardly the case in the US.
This is simply another example of an academic, very likely
liberal and most definitely female found exactly what she knew
deep down in her heart that she would find in this show; an evil
Conservative message that stressed, hard work, cooperation,
respect for authority and responsibility for ones own actions.
Evil thrives in the most unlikely places.
Now the most important thing to realize is that Thomas the Tank
Engine is a British television production from a series of books
written by a British writer. So I guess it's conservative message
is aimed at the former British Commonwealth, eh?
Motown Mike| 12.10.09 @ 9:56AM
As a conservative, a train buff, and an academic, I think this
revelation about Thomas et al. is great! It gives me a new
research idea. Watch for my book:
"The Political Lives of Steam Locomotives."
First premise is that steam locomotives are like big government:
a lot smoke, fire, huffing and puffing, but more than 90% of the
energy goes up the smokestack. Yet, they are always good at
railroading you.
Jocon307| 12.10.09 @ 12:23AM
LOL, Gay extinct Barney & Deported Dora, very funny. You definately get the laugh of the day award for that!
Liberal Reader| 12.10.09 @ 12:50AM
McCain --
Popular culture -- driven entirely by the free market that creates it -- is a seething, corrupt sewer. One watches music videos and most television programs and films and wonders how stupid, vapid, and morally insane a culture can actually be before it collapses into a debased chaotic wreckage. America is fast becoming a suburb casino of Hollywood, and it can only end in tears. 2 and a half million people are in prison in this country, and the public schools are -- as you point out -- groaning with mediocrity.
Your critique here seems mighty thin. Maybe this political scientist is a little off-track, but I hardly see this as a good example of what is wrong with education or entertainment designed for children.
At any rate, I hardly see how the relentless privatization of the country can cure any of this. The new "conservative" agenda seems to have a vision of America in which everyone is locked behind closed doors, armed to the teeth, watching Glenn Beck blubber and weep on cable television.
What can save this country is a revitalization of the civic spirit. Great public works, a massive increase in spending on education (together with a massive increase of standards for teachers and students), and a campaign to improve civility and respect for the law -- before people wind up in front of judges to receive their sentences.
Dai Alanye| 12.10.09 @ 6:00AM
"Great public works, a massive increase in spending on education…"
Sure, that should work, because throwing money at our problems has always worked so well in the past.
Terry Baker| 2.8.10 @ 9:05AM
Throwing money at the problem of "World War II" was what finally ended the Great Depression?
Throwing money from the bottom of society to the top of society has been our main direction since...care to guess if there's any change to be expected from this except what we now see?
JohnD| 12.10.09 @ 8:06AM
I noticed what they say above myself when I used to watch it with my son, who has now outgrown Thomas and moved on to other pursuits.
Thomas the Tank Engine does reinforce many principles we conservatives hold dear, like respect for authority, order, hard work, and self-discipline, but in many cases it is more monarchist. Sir Topham Hatt, runs the railway with an iron fist, and tolerates absolutely NO challenge to his authority.
I used to tell my son as we watched Thomas, "If I worked for Sir Topham Hatt and he talked to me the way he talks to Thomas and the other engines, I'd punch him right in his fat face." My son used to laugh at that.
Thomas| 12.10.09 @ 9:43AM
First a disclaimer. I am no relation to any character in the television show.
Having watched this series with my youngest child for quite a while, I can safely say that all of this is a load of piffle. People put on their preconception specs, project their personal prejudices into the show and see what they want to see.
The social science professor stated the following, "it also represents a conservative political ideology that punishes individual initiative, opposes critique and change, and relegates females to supportive roles,". Perhaps this is true of Conservatives in Canada, but it is hardly the case in the US. This is simply another example of an academic, very likely liberal and most definitely female found exactly what she knew deep down in her heart that she would find in this show; an evil Conservative message that stressed, hard work, cooperation, respect for authority and responsibility for ones own actions. Evil thrives in the most unlikely places.
Now the most important thing to realize is that Thomas the Tank Engine is a British television production from a series of books written by a British writer. So I guess it's conservative message is aimed at the former British Commonwealth, eh?
Motown Mike| 12.10.09 @ 9:56AM
As a conservative, a train buff, and an academic, I think this revelation about Thomas et al. is great! It gives me a new research idea. Watch for my book:
"The Political Lives of Steam Locomotives."
First premise is that steam locomotives are like big government: a lot smoke, fire, huffing and puffing, but more than 90% of the energy goes up the smokestack. Yet, they are always good at railroading you.
china racking| 1.7.10 @ 1:24AM
http://www.racking-shelving.com
http://www.cold-store-equipment.com