House Democrats just narrowly passed their health care
legislation, by a margin of 220 to 215, with 39 Democrats voting
against it, and just one Republican -- Louisiana's Joseph Cao --
voting in favor. Obviously, this is an historic victory for
Democrats as it's the first time that a health care bill of this
magnitude has made it this far. Passing it in the House gives it
momentum going into the Senate. And also, in a larger sense,
Democrats have proven once again that no matter how messy the
daily grind may look, they've eventually been able to use their
overwhelming majority to keep moving the health care ball down
field.
With that said, tonight's victory of a mere five votes, came at a
tremendous cost for the House leadership and may eventually help
doom the entire effort. In order to get over the top, Democrats
had to agree to pass an amendment that would bar taxpayer funding
for abortion. The measure is strongly opposed by pro-choicers,
and Planned Parenthood has
vowed to fight it. While pro-choice Democrats voted for the
bill tonight to keep the process moving forward, they did so
under the assumption that they could strip it from the bill once
the House goes into negotiations with the Senate. If the measure
gets stripped, suddenly there's a risk of pro-life Democrats
dropping their support of the final bill. And considering that
the measure only passed by five votes, Nancy Pelosi cannot afford
to shed more than a handful of members. Also keep in mind that
because 64 Democrats voted in favor of the Stupak anti-abortion
amendment, it means that should it get stripped from the bill,
Republicans will be on firm ground arguing that the remaining
legislation allows taxpayer funding for abortion. Yet if Pelosi
maintains the pro-life language, it's hard to see how staunch
pro-choicers support the final bill, and suddenly you could see
defections of liberals.
And of course, all of this assumes that some sort of bill passes
the Senate. Yet if it was this heavy of a lift in the House --
where it's supposed to be easy for the majority party to ram
things through -- it suddenly looks like a daunting task to get
to 60 votes in the Senate. So, clearly, this was a step forward
for Democrats. But tonight's victory could prove Pyrrhic.
…tweets into comments for your WordPress blog. Topsy Plugin – WordPress Shortened Links Linking to the spectator.org page http://bit.ly/32CNtL info 3 tweets retweet The American Spectator : AmSpecBlog : Pelosi's Pyrrhic Victory? spectator.org/blog/2009/11/07/pelosis-pyrrhic-victory – view page – cached House Democrats just narrowly passed their health care legislation, by a margin of 220 to…
Adam Smith| 11.8.09 @ 12:08AM
Get ready for the real Great Depression:
New CBO estismates out today:
Senator Gregg: Updated CBO Estimate of House Bill Pulls Back the
Curtain on Majority’s Intent to Grow Government by $3 Trillion
Senator Judd Gregg (R-NH), ranking member of the Senate Budget
Committee today commented on the Congressional Budget Office’s
(CBO) more detailed cost estimate of the manager’s amendment to
the House health reform bill.
Senator Gregg stated, “The CBO estimate released last night
finally sheds light on the smoke and mirrors game the majority
has been playing with the cost of their health care reform
proposal. Over the first 10 years, this legislation builds in
gross new spending of $1.7 trillion – and most of the new
spending doesn’t even start until 2014. Once that spending is
fully phased in, the House Democratic bill rings up at more than
$3 trillion over ten years.
“Additionally, this bill cuts critical Medicare and Medicaid
funding by $628 billion, accounts for nearly $1.2 trillion in tax
and fee increases and will explode the scope of government by
putting the nation’s health care system in the hands of
Washington bureaucrats. The $3 trillion price tag defies common
sense – we simply cannot add all this new spending to the
government rolls and claim to control the deficit."
Great news! A new 3.25 (including the doctors bribe added back
in) trillion scam to unify the Democrat/Big Government/Big Union
trifecta.
I listened to Michael Steele mostly get walked over by Geraldo
after the vote.
The constitutionality of the bill never came up.
Plenty of race baiting did though. Sad when the African American
GOP chair can not make effective points against a race baiting
tabloid hack and walking freak show.
Not real pleased tonight with the opposition party.
Cap n Tax & Amnesty will be coming up next.
Where will the GOP be?
Revolution Now| 11.8.09 @ 12:28AM
REPEAT: This is a job for the military. They are out of control,
period. It is out of our hands now. We've been CHAVEZED!
Revolution Now| 11.8.09 @ 12:26AM
I'm sorry, historic??? You people amaze me. This is more than
just a 'throw the bums out' moment... Why is there not the
MILITARY in there arresting these criminals and traitors??? This
is a communist coup and not one more penny should go to the IRS
from not one more citizen. We are being taken over from within.
I am shocked at how this is being allowed. They have no right to
do this, it's unconstitutional and they SHOULD PAY DEARLY for it
by being ARRESTED and thrown in JAIL for high crimes and
TREASON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
And why the hell would any Republican vote for the amendment to
ban abortions when they knew that would pave the way for blue
dogs to vote for the whole bill????????????????
I'm stunned what has happened in our country.
I'm gearing up for the resistance..... who knows what they will
do next?
Real American| 11.8.09 @ 12:41AM
Liberals won't defect on the final bill even with the Stupek
amendment still in there. This bill represents liberal utopia:
complete control over health care in American, control over hte
daily lives of Americans and the ability, every 2 years, to
campaign on the promise of giving away more health benefits to
the newly addicted slaves of government. They won't give that up
just to murder a few babies. Eventually, we'll all be covered
under this bankrupt scheme and abortion will find a way to get
paid for somehow.
…percent. Cao will be the first Vietnamese-American to serve in Congress and won as a Republican in a district that … From: AnonymousViet Views: 3067 5 ratings Time: 04:44 More in Education Pelosi's Pyrrhic Victory? … care legislation, by a margin of 220 to 215, with 39 Democrats voting against it, and just one Republican — Louisiana's Joseph Cao — voting in favor. … Breaking: It…
…Oh I wish they would do that! Big Government - Here we go again: Rostenkowski Health Care and the original town hall protest IowaHawk - America Take Can Pride In This Historic, Inspirational Disaster The American Spectator - Pelosi’s Pyrrhic Victory? Okay, now go read and if you are so inclined, fall to your knees and say a prayer pleading for help and guidance in saving our great Republic. The video below gives…
…care reform legislation offered by Democrats. Rep. Anh "Joseph" Cao, the Louisiana Republican who … From: jiramyblog89 Views: 0 0 ratings Time: 00:50 More in News & Politics Pelosi's Pyrrhic Victory? … care legislation, by a margin of 220 to 215, with 39 Democrats voting against it, and just one Republican — Louisiana's Joseph Cao — voting in favor. … House Votes…
Adjoran| 11.8.09 @ 4:29AM
I only wish it were so simple. It is not.
These Democrats will vote for the conference bill when it comes
up, knowing they can point to this amendment vote to confuse and
deceive their constituents. Unfortunately, in America there is no
requirement that a voter demonstrate any basic competence or
knowledge. It shows.
Mere threats and coercion having failed to bring wandering
Democrats back into the flock, Pelosi resorted to guile and
convinced them they will be able to hide behind the amendment
vote. Perhaps they will, perhaps they will not, but the
determinant factor is that they apparently now believe her.
Opposing her on the reconciliation bill will be almost impossible
for them now.
Add to their number the at-risk Democrats representing
traditionally Republican districts who understand they risk
losing their seats with a pro-Obamacare vote BUT equally feel at
risk with an anti-Obamacare vote due to the passions of the left.
Most of these were NEVER "blue dogs" at all, at least in the
original sense of the term - Democrats who were moderately
conservative and insisted on their positions on fiscal discipline
and national security. All those old dogs either retired, lost,
or came around to the Party Line.
Those who claim the "blue dog" mantle these days are just as
liberal as most of their Democratic colleagues, but represent
more conservative districts where the mere term "blue dog" helps
their image.
…care reform legislation offered by Democrats. Rep. Anh "Joseph" Cao, the Louisiana Republican who … From: jiramyblog89 Views: 0 0 ratings Time: 00:50 More in News & Politics Pelosi's Pyrrhic Victory? … care legislation, by a margin of 220 to 215, with 39 Democrats voting against it, and just one Republican — Louisiana's Joseph Cao — voting in favor. … House Votes…
…Jahvid Best hurts neck Jahvid best jumps about 5 feet in the air and hurts his neck really bad. Keep him in your prayers From: Brazel55 Views: 346 13 ratings Time: 00:31 More in Entertainment Pelosi's Pyrrhic Victory? … care legislation, by a margin of 220 to 215, with 39 Democrats voting against it, and just one Republican — Louisiana's Joseph Cao — voting in favor. … Stupak Pitts…
Texasbelle| 11.8.09 @ 5:08AM
I like a comment I saw on another site. If the Republicans had
passed a bill that most American's opposed in the dead of night
on a weekend, right in the middle of the aftermath of an attack
on our troops at Ft. Hood, would the media have called it
"historic?" I doubt it. Hadn't really thought of that before, but
it's true.
…care reform legislation offered by Democrats. Rep. Anh "Joseph" Cao, the Louisiana Republican who … From: jiramyblog89 Views: 0 0 ratings Time: 00:50 More in News & Politics Pelosi's Pyrrhic Victory? … care legislation, by a margin of 220 to 215, with 39 Democrats voting against it, and just one Republican — Louisiana's Joseph Cao — voting in favor. … House Votes…
…House 220 – 215 with 1 Republican vote One courageous Republican Representative Joseph Cao of Louisiana voted for the bill. Thirty-nine Blue Dog Democrats voted against the bill. … Pelosi's Pyrrhic Victory? … care legislation, by a margin of 220 to 215, with 39 Democrats voting against it, and just one Republican — Louisiana's Joseph Cao — voting in favor. … Stupak Pitts…
Pecos Pete| 11.8.09 @ 6:53AM
The work against "national health care" legislation must now move
to the Senate.
What will the House take up next? Gun control? Illegal
immigration reform (i.e., amnesty for anyone in the USA
illegally)?
…soldiers endure for the country are “what sacrifice really is,” as opposed to “casting a vote that might lose an election for you,” said Rep. Robert Andrews, D-N.J. Well, there you are then. More. Philip Klein, AmSpec: Pelosi's Pyrrhic Victory More. PatrickRuffini Cao would have been with us if his vote would have made a difference. Don't focus on Cao. Focus on Snowe, Lincoln, Liebs, Nelson. More. kathrynlopez…
bluecollarbytes| 11.8.09 @ 8:01AM
I expect the courts to play cleanup in any Health Care takeover
that prohibits abortion funding.
Democrats voted for healthcare collectivization last night, and
all that word implies. My reading of the bill sets buying
healthcare insurance as a precondition for living in this
country. This bill presupposes a citizen has an expense from
their date of birth, just for existing. Unlike taxes, which
confiscate part of an individuals effort, this bill implies that
an individual is indebted to the state just for being born. With
taxes you have a choice not to work. With car insurance mandates
you can avoid them by not driving. Conceptually the bill, on the
anniversary of the Eastern European freedom from the Soviet Era,
moves the bondage from east, to west. Sweet land of liberty,
indeed.
For reference as to the success of recent U.S. attempts at
collectivization, ask this: What was the benefit from the last
trillion-dollar debacle, the so called stimulus? Thought so.
As for history, what do you suppose are the lies agreed upon this
morning?
One thing is reasonably certain, Phillip Klein is probably too
optimistic about the possible long term defeat of this bill.
Unless the grass roots efforts get better and polls start showing
seats being threatened in both the house and the senate.
Finally, the abortion compromise is laugh out loud funny. Those
legislators that actually believe it will make it into the final
bill must be either stupid, or -------
…offer enough socialism. All is not lost. Like cap-and-trade has been to date, Pelosicare will likely get bogged down in the Senate. There’s also reason to believe that the House coalition won’t be sustainable if it passes the Senate and returns following reconciliation. It is imperative we keep the pressure on. They must know that there will be costs for destroying American health care, economic…
Jim Hlavac| 11.8.09 @ 3:42PM
Pretty soon they will pretend to pay us and we will pretend to
work. The mathematics are unavoidable: you cannot take $20 from a
man, give him back $17, tell him how to spend it, and say that
you have helped him. It is a logical absurdity. Vote all, ALL,
out, now.
…54mm Figures My son really enjoys all types of army men and soldiers. Excellent, and very durable. Possibly related posts: (automatically generated) Related posts on American The American Spectator : AmSpecBlog : Pelosi's Pyrrhic Victory? The American Spectator : AmSpecBlog : Shadegg to Vote "Present" on … The American Spectator : AmSpecBlog : Government Takeover is a … */ Categories: Toys…
danny| 11.8.09 @ 7:56PM
they may get my money at tax time for this, but they are going to
have to bring a gun to do it. i've seen enough.
…the politics and the romance. I've seen it three times and thoroughly enjoyed it all three times. Possibly related posts: (automatically generated) Related posts on American The American Spectator : AmSpecBlog : Pelosi's Pyrrhic Victory? The American Spectator : AmSpecBlog : Shadegg to Vote "Present" on … The American Spectator : AmSpecBlog : Government Takeover is a … Related posts on…
…Along The East Coast Zooming along at 80mph on the Lake Shore Ltd and I decide to write … Related posts on American The American Spectator : AmSpecBlog : Defending Cao The American Spectator : AmSpecBlog : Pelosi's Pyrrhic Victory? The American Spectator : AmSpecBlog : Shadegg to Vote "Present" on … Related posts on Anot Leistis į kelionę « Europos "Super Netto" Forex – Let Your…
Pingback| 11.7.09 @ 11:50PM
Twitter Trackbacks for The American Spectator : AmSpecBlog : Pelosi's Pyrrhic Victor links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Adam Smith| 11.8.09 @ 12:08AM
Get ready for the real Great Depression:
New CBO estismates out today:
Senator Gregg: Updated CBO Estimate of House Bill Pulls Back the Curtain on Majority’s Intent to Grow Government by $3 Trillion
Senator Judd Gregg (R-NH), ranking member of the Senate Budget Committee today commented on the Congressional Budget Office’s (CBO) more detailed cost estimate of the manager’s amendment to the House health reform bill.
Senator Gregg stated, “The CBO estimate released last night finally sheds light on the smoke and mirrors game the majority has been playing with the cost of their health care reform proposal. Over the first 10 years, this legislation builds in gross new spending of $1.7 trillion – and most of the new spending doesn’t even start until 2014. Once that spending is fully phased in, the House Democratic bill rings up at more than $3 trillion over ten years.
“Additionally, this bill cuts critical Medicare and Medicaid funding by $628 billion, accounts for nearly $1.2 trillion in tax and fee increases and will explode the scope of government by putting the nation’s health care system in the hands of Washington bureaucrats. The $3 trillion price tag defies common sense – we simply cannot add all this new spending to the government rolls and claim to control the deficit."
Great news! A new 3.25 (including the doctors bribe added back in) trillion scam to unify the Democrat/Big Government/Big Union trifecta.
I listened to Michael Steele mostly get walked over by Geraldo after the vote.
The constitutionality of the bill never came up.
Plenty of race baiting did though. Sad when the African American GOP chair can not make effective points against a race baiting tabloid hack and walking freak show.
Not real pleased tonight with the opposition party.
Cap n Tax & Amnesty will be coming up next.
Where will the GOP be?
Revolution Now| 11.8.09 @ 12:28AM
REPEAT: This is a job for the military. They are out of control, period. It is out of our hands now. We've been CHAVEZED!
Revolution Now| 11.8.09 @ 12:26AM
I'm sorry, historic??? You people amaze me. This is more than just a 'throw the bums out' moment... Why is there not the MILITARY in there arresting these criminals and traitors??? This is a communist coup and not one more penny should go to the IRS from not one more citizen. We are being taken over from within.
I am shocked at how this is being allowed. They have no right to do this, it's unconstitutional and they SHOULD PAY DEARLY for it by being ARRESTED and thrown in JAIL for high crimes and TREASON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
And why the hell would any Republican vote for the amendment to ban abortions when they knew that would pave the way for blue dogs to vote for the whole bill????????????????
I'm stunned what has happened in our country.
I'm gearing up for the resistance..... who knows what they will do next?
Real American| 11.8.09 @ 12:41AM
Liberals won't defect on the final bill even with the Stupek amendment still in there. This bill represents liberal utopia: complete control over health care in American, control over hte daily lives of Americans and the ability, every 2 years, to campaign on the promise of giving away more health benefits to the newly addicted slaves of government. They won't give that up just to murder a few babies. Eventually, we'll all be covered under this bankrupt scheme and abortion will find a way to get paid for somehow.
Pingback| 11.8.09 @ 1:34AM
Pelosi's Pyrrhic Victory? : Eye Opener News links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 11.8.09 @ 2:02AM
Stupak Amendment: Abortion Restriction Amendment Passes, Healthcare Reform Passes Ho links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 11.8.09 @ 3:31AM
Pelosi's Pyrrhic Victory? : Eye Opener News links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Adjoran| 11.8.09 @ 4:29AM
I only wish it were so simple. It is not.
These Democrats will vote for the conference bill when it comes up, knowing they can point to this amendment vote to confuse and deceive their constituents. Unfortunately, in America there is no requirement that a voter demonstrate any basic competence or knowledge. It shows.
Mere threats and coercion having failed to bring wandering Democrats back into the flock, Pelosi resorted to guile and convinced them they will be able to hide behind the amendment vote. Perhaps they will, perhaps they will not, but the determinant factor is that they apparently now believe her. Opposing her on the reconciliation bill will be almost impossible for them now.
Add to their number the at-risk Democrats representing traditionally Republican districts who understand they risk losing their seats with a pro-Obamacare vote BUT equally feel at risk with an anti-Obamacare vote due to the passions of the left. Most of these were NEVER "blue dogs" at all, at least in the original sense of the term - Democrats who were moderately conservative and insisted on their positions on fiscal discipline and national security. All those old dogs either retired, lost, or came around to the Party Line.
Those who claim the "blue dog" mantle these days are just as liberal as most of their Democratic colleagues, but represent more conservative districts where the mere term "blue dog" helps their image.
Pingback| 11.8.09 @ 4:31AM
Pelosi's Pyrrhic Victory? : Eye Opener News links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 11.8.09 @ 5:02AM
Pelosi's Pyrrhic Victory? : Eye Opener News links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Texasbelle| 11.8.09 @ 5:08AM
I like a comment I saw on another site. If the Republicans had passed a bill that most American's opposed in the dead of night on a weekend, right in the middle of the aftermath of an attack on our troops at Ft. Hood, would the media have called it "historic?" I doubt it. Hadn't really thought of that before, but it's true.
Pingback| 11.8.09 @ 5:31AM
Pelosi's Pyrrhic Victory? : Eye Opener News links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 11.8.09 @ 6:04AM
Health care reform passes in the House 220 – 215 with 1 Republican vote : Eye Opener links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pecos Pete| 11.8.09 @ 6:53AM
The work against "national health care" legislation must now move to the Senate.
What will the House take up next? Gun control? Illegal immigration reform (i.e., amnesty for anyone in the USA illegally)?
What more damage can the House do to us?
Pingback| 11.8.09 @ 7:42AM
Final Pelosi Bill Vote | Chicago Daily Observer links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
bluecollarbytes| 11.8.09 @ 8:01AM
I expect the courts to play cleanup in any Health Care takeover that prohibits abortion funding.
Lazy Jack| 11.8.09 @ 9:24AM
Democrats voted for healthcare collectivization last night, and all that word implies. My reading of the bill sets buying healthcare insurance as a precondition for living in this country. This bill presupposes a citizen has an expense from their date of birth, just for existing. Unlike taxes, which confiscate part of an individuals effort, this bill implies that an individual is indebted to the state just for being born. With taxes you have a choice not to work. With car insurance mandates you can avoid them by not driving. Conceptually the bill, on the anniversary of the Eastern European freedom from the Soviet Era, moves the bondage from east, to west. Sweet land of liberty, indeed.
For reference as to the success of recent U.S. attempts at collectivization, ask this: What was the benefit from the last trillion-dollar debacle, the so called stimulus? Thought so.
As for history, what do you suppose are the lies agreed upon this morning?
One thing is reasonably certain, Phillip Klein is probably too optimistic about the possible long term defeat of this bill. Unless the grass roots efforts get better and polls start showing seats being threatened in both the house and the senate.
Finally, the abortion compromise is laugh out loud funny. Those legislators that actually believe it will make it into the final bill must be either stupid, or -------
http://thanksforthelaughs.word.....ealthcare/
Richard Baker| 11.8.09 @ 10:01AM
Time for the George Washington Tyrant Removal method. Sic Semper Tyrannis.
The American Guardian| 11.8.09 @ 10:57AM
Unemployment is over 10% and Obama is worried about getting tax-payer funded abortions ???
martin j smith| 11.8.09 @ 11:19AM
Tea Parties,organize,get out the vote. Get the message out over and over again and vote again and again and again--that is a joke !!!
Pingback| 11.8.09 @ 11:59AM
It’s Bipartisan! : Conservative Compendium links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Jim Hlavac| 11.8.09 @ 3:42PM
Pretty soon they will pretend to pay us and we will pretend to work. The mathematics are unavoidable: you cannot take $20 from a man, give him back $17, tell him how to spend it, and say that you have helped him. It is a logical absurdity. Vote all, ALL, out, now.
Pingback| 11.8.09 @ 6:00PM
BMC D-Day Plastic Army Men Set: 34 Piece Set of British, American, and German Soldier links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
danny| 11.8.09 @ 7:56PM
they may get my money at tax time for this, but they are going to have to bring a gun to do it. i've seen enough.
Pingback| 11.8.09 @ 8:29PM
The Quiet American | eCheapPrice.com links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 11.9.09 @ 2:22AM
Fun Along The Road: American Tourist Attractions – Anot | Vocabulation links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
long| 11.10.09 @ 2:41AM
wholesale nike shoes
wholesale shoes
Trackback| 12.15.09 @ 9:56PM
credit repair nh, on credit repair nh, links to this page. Here’s an excerpt: