During a Sept. 20 interview
on ABC’s This Week, President Obama denied that the
individual mandate excise tax in the Baucus healthcare draft
was a tax, even though the draft language used the term “excise
tax” as a descriptive. In a memorable exchange, host George
Stephanopoulos read the dictionary definition of “tax” to the
President, who replied by saying, “George, the fact that you
looked up Merriam’s Dictionary, the definition of tax increase,
indicates to me that you’re stretching a little bit right
now.”
Now that we finally have the actual legislative language of
the 1,502-page Senate Finance healthcare bill (S.
1796), we can see on page 194 that the bill retained use
of the term “excise tax”:
Subtitle D-Shared Responsibility
PART I-INDIVIDUAL RESPONSIBILITY
SEC. 1301. EXCISE TAX ON INDIVIDUALS WITHOUT
ESSENTIAL HEALTH BENEFITS
COVERAGE
Pages 195-196 also contain the following terms:
“IMPOSITION OF TAX”
“INCLUSION WITH INCOME TAX RETURN”
“LIABILITY FOR TAX”
“AMOUNT OF TAX”
Additionally, the excise tax is one of several taxes in the bill
that break Obama’s “firm
pledge” not to raise “any
form” of taxes on families making less than $250,000 per
year.
Will the White House continue to claim the tax is not a
tax? Stay tuned.
Mick| 10.22.09 @ 9:33AM
An 'excise TAX' ...... IS.....a TAX....even if 'IS' means something else, TAX does NOT!
I guess the Havaad edumication just didn't take...