The American Spectator

home
ADVERTISEMENT
Print Email
Text Size

The Spectacle Blog

Attacking David Keene

There’s only one redeeming thing about this video, and it’s the look on John Fund’s face as he walks past hyperbolic documentary filmmaker John Ziegler. Ziegler spends much of his time in this video chasing after the American Conservative Union’s David Keene.

This is pretty awful stuff. I think Quin Hillyer had a sufficiently Burkean respect when he said he felt that Keene should have an opportunity to explain the Fedex/UPS situation, which Keene did. If you wanted more, the man’s pretty accessible. To then accuse to the man’s face in a web video, repeatedly, that he sells out for money, and then be shocked the man walks away, is good dramatic affectation, but makes me roll my eyes.

There’s a certain amount of courtesy you extend in an interview. When you repeatedly ask a question and you get the same answer, you may be upset that the person isn’t giving you what you want, but you don’t then chase them around a hotel, badgering them. You do that if you’re Michael Moore, you do that if you’re an actor on Punk’d. Let’s not say that this interview was done in good faith — if Mr. Ziegler was so inclined, he could have asked for clarification on the explanations already offered by Keene, rather than oversimplify it by saying Keene’s opinions are for sale. Even if you buy that indelicate phrasing, what say you bring it up more thoughtfully?

In this, Ziegler makes a mess of what can be legitimate complaints about the Fedex/UPS brouhaha, Keene’s support of Specter, or about how CPAC is run. I say “can be” because as presented here, they’re dishonest. He squanders an opportunity to have a productive discussion about it, and provokes a man into a fit. 

Sample questions:
  • “A lot of people have expressed concerns about the possibility of CPAC being run in a pay-for-play fashion. How are you guarding against this?”
  • “Person A should not have been granted a spot given these examples of not being a proper conservative. What were the considerations that allowed this person to appear nonetheless?”
  • “You said in your response to the accusations of selling out to FedEx the following […]. But yet there was still this point you did not address…”
Keene was taken aback by the approach chosen, and responded accordingly. That makes for some great T.V., some disappointment about the man’s willingness to express his own anger, and didn’t come out looking very good either. Announcing from the dais that Ziegler was being objected was, of course, asking for more drama.

But my general sense of things is to take the line from Buckley. Conservatism isn’t one giant comment board in which everyone can flame to their heart’s content. This isn’t about “dissent,” this is about people acting in good faith because we’re trying to do the same thing. 

That’s not to discount Ed Morrissey’s point over at HotAir:

And quite frankly, after spending several hundred dollars to attend an event just to be told that dissent is “the heighth of rudeness” and that bloggers should shut up and defer to their movement elders was just a little too much too take.

I won’t return to events sponsored by the same organizations in the future. The big problem with the conservative movement has been its self-appointed leaders telling others to shut up and follow in lockstep, and I don’t think any so-called movement leaders taking that approach have the first foggy clue about what the New Media and Tax Parties mean.

I know what he’s saying, because there are a bunch of organizations that haven’t yet caught on to the fact that the ground is shifting. But given that many of these “self-appointed leaders” are so clueless, doesn’t that mean they are less important, or will be soon enough? Why waste time?

The big problem is not the self-appointed leaders, although they are problematic. It’s more the willingness of conservatives to allow these self-appointed leaders to call the shots. And that is finally changing too.

View all comments (23) |

Pingback| 10.20.09 @ 8:57AM

Twitter Trackbacks for The American Spectator : AmSpecBlog : Attacking David Keene [ links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Linking to the spectator.org page http://bit.ly/p1UJU info Add Topsy to Your Blog Turn tweets into comments for your WordPress blog. Topsy Plugin for WordPress   2 tweets Tweet The American Spectator : AmSpecBlog : Attacking David Keene spectator.org/blog/2009/10/20/attacking-david-keene – view page – cached There's only one redeeming thing about this video, and it's the look on John Fund's face as he…

Pingback| 10.20.09 @ 9:31AM

Hot Air » Blog Archive » A few final thoughts on Ziegler, Keene, ACU links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

About Home Vault Green Room TEST About Advertise A few final thoughts on Ziegler, Keene, ACU posted at 9:30 am on October 20, 2009 by Ed Morrissey Share on Facebook | printer-friendly Both Dan Riehl and J. Peter Freire criticize John Ziegler for his conduct at Western CPAC this morning on their respective blogs.  Both are fine bloggers, and I’d encourage people to read their posts, in order to get a rounded…

RJ | 10.20.09 @ 11:41AM

What part of the video shows John Fund? I must have missed that part...

Tman | 10.20.09 @ 12:41PM

The problem here is that Keene obviously knows that he's guilty in the pay-for-play scandal, and refuses to admit the truth to Zeigler. The entire episode would've ended a lot sooner had this not been the case. If Keene did not have anything to do with the pay-for-play system he would've said so and Zeigler would've moved on. Clearly he did not do so, and Zeigler to his credit continued to ask the question.

I understand that civility and respective disagreement are a better path, but the contempt shown by the party leaders at this point shows that they are part of the problem, not the solution.

The are getting treated the way in which they deserve to be treated.

Pingback| 10.20.09 @ 1:01PM

Ziegler Makes Waves Left and Right - Caleb’s blog - RedState links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…of my article. As you might expect, there has been both support and criticism regarding Ziegler’s interview. I think by far the best analysis has come from Ed Morrissey, with J.P. Freire’s thoughtful post also well-worth reading. Ultimately I have to disagree with the critics. John Ziegler is a personality on the right for doing precisely what he did here. This is the very thing. The fact that this time…

Pingback| 10.20.09 @ 3:19PM

A few final thoughts on Ziegler, Keene, ACU | Legal-Sleaze.com links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…World A few final thoughts on Ziegler, Keene, ACU Written By: admin on October 20, 2009 No Comment Make FREE money reading your email, blogging, chatting! Follow us on Twitter Both Dan Riehl and J. [...] Read the rest » Go to Source Tags: Dan Riehl, raquo, Read, rest, Source Leave a Reply: Click here to cancel reply. Name (required) Mail (will not be published) (required) Website XHTML: You can use…

ChuckTX| 10.20.09 @ 4:30PM

How in the heck can you defend Keene and the others after how they acted during the interview and afterwards. Did you watch a different video?? This is why our party is in such a mess if we defend the clueless people at the top. Clean the our own house before taking on the dem's or we suffer till 2017..

red carolina| 10.20.09 @ 5:08PM

and Keene said Sarah was a whiner?????????? wow, why didn't he just answer John's questions? This is NO time for dodging the truth and I happen to trust John, even if he is hyperbolic at times. At least he's questioning the establishment -- besides, if Keene supported Specter, he's no friend of the conservative constituency -- PERIOD! Repub party doesn't need rebranding? it needs better leadership!!

Pingback| 10.21.09 @ 2:54AM

Ziegler Makes Waves Left and Right « Yuvablog links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…of my article. As you might expect, there has been both support and criticism regarding Ziegler’s interview. I think by far the best analysis has come from Ed Morrissey, with J.P. Freire’s thoughtful post also well-worth reading. Ultimately I have to disagree with the critics. John Ziegler is a personality on the right for doing precisely what he did here. This is the very thing. The fact that this time…

Pingback| 10.26.09 @ 11:04PM

Sarah Palin’s Attack Dog - Aquinas’s blog - RedState links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…is also true that others in the conservative camp weren’t asking these questions. But Ziegler goes out of his way to be offensive, rude, and unprofessional for seemingly no reason. Peter Freire puts it best in The American Spectator: “There’s a certain amount of courtesy you extend in an interview. When you repeatedly ask a question and you get the same answer, you may be upset that the person…

Pingback| 10.26.09 @ 11:05PM

Sarah Palin’s Attack Dog - Aquinas’s blog - RedState links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…is also true that others in the conservative camp weren’t asking these questions. But Ziegler goes out of his way to be offensive, rude, and unprofessional for seemingly no reason. Peter Freire puts it best in The American Spectator: “There’s a certain amount of courtesy you extend in an interview. When you repeatedly ask a question and you get the same answer, you may be upset that the person…

Pingback| 3.20.10 @ 11:18AM

Frum Owes Hannity an Apology | FrumForum links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…were that he wrongly conflated these two positions.) But as I pointed out to David in my Twitter feed earlier today, the charges against Keene really weren’t “ignored”; rather, they were found to be wanting and baseless. Nonetheless, David asked why conservatives were “ignoring” these charges. He suggested that perhaps conservatives were wrongly covering up for Hannity. “It’s not possible — is it? — that…

Pingback| 3.20.10 @ 4:11PM

Frum Owes Hannity an Apology | FrumForum links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…today, the charges against Keene really weren’t “ignored” by conservatives. They were, in fact, seriously analyzed and discussed by a bevy of conservative journalists and bloggers at the American Spectator, RedState, the Washington Times , Right-Wing News, and elsewhere. I think the allegations against Keene were unfair and wrong, though David, I know, disagrees. But regardless of whether the allegations…

ly958198158| 5.10.10 @ 3:47AM

Our splendid CompTIA Certification is sure to cause 70-270to your collection.

小黑小白1314| 5.13.10 @ 3:10AM

Therefore, the task for SY0-201
DDB Needham was to encourage consumers toN10-004 Exam
consider other aspects of train travel in order to change their attitudes and increase the likelihood that trains would be considered for travel in the west.

hasdress | 8.3.11 @ 10:51PM

Pretty! This was a really wonderful post.
mother of the bride dresses chicago
kleinfelds mother of the bride dresses

More Blog Posts by J.P. Freire

http://spectator.org/blog/2009/10/20/attacking-david-keene

ADVERTISEMENT

SPONSORED LINKS

FLASHBACK TO: 1995

Clip of the Day

Most Popular Articles

Obama and the IRS: The Smoking Gun?

Jeffrey Lord | 5.20.13

Time to Go for the Kill

Peter Ferrara | 5.22.13

From the Obama Ministry of Truth

Ben Stein | 5.21.13

IRS Union Chief Stonewalls

Jeffrey Lord | 5.21.13

Wimps Versus Barbarians

Thomas Sowell | 5.21.13

Damage Control for Dummies

Matt Purple | 5.22.13

Anyone Still Believe Me?

Aaron Goldstein | 5.21.13

ADVERTISEMENT