- Home
- About Us
- Contributors
- Departments
- Topics
- Back Issues
- Weekly Archives
- AmSpecBlog
- Subscribe
- Newsletter
- Advertise
- Donate
- Contact Us
- Daily Digest
- Templeton Essays
AmSpecBlog
Rorschach as Objectivist?
Note: If you haven't read Watchmen or seen the movie, skip this post. There are spoilers, and you won't know what I'm talking about anyway.
Brian Doherty writes at Reason that Rorschach is "probably the most vivid and well-thought-out Objectivist hero that Rand didn’t create." It's true that Steve Ditko created The Question as an Objectivist hero, and that Alan Moore based Rorschach on The Question. But it's a little silly to think of Rorschach as a Randian given how much Moore, a leftist, deviates in his portrayal from how Randians actually think. In one scene Rorschach menacingly scolds Moloch for having illegal medication; Randians are generally libertarian on drugs, and wouldn't get indignant about a violation of prescription drug laws. Rorschach's attitudes toward sex also don't quite fit for an Objectivist; Rand herself had convoluted and sometimes contradictory ideas about sexual morality that some of her followers may defend, but there's nothing Randian about Rorschach's repulsion at fornication per se.
The political landscape of Watchmen really doesn't allow for philosophical subtlety. The right-wingers are all grotesque caricatures. The New Frontiersman at one point runs an item from the "crank file" addressed to "The Jewnited States of America." Moore has actually refered to Rorschach in interviews as a "very fascist character" (which indicates that Moore doesn't really understand fascism, either). This is defensible in a comic book, especially in Watchmen, where the twist at the end is that the good lefty turns out to be the villain and the crazy righty turns out to be the only one who stands up for the truth. In a way, Rorschach is both too simple and too interesting to really be thought of as an Objectivist hero.
Comments
Leave a Comment
Pingback| 3.9.09 @ 3:21PM
Rorschach as Objectivist? — But As For Me links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Michael Kotschi| 3.9.09 @ 9:43PM
Actually a stronger influence on the Rorschach is probably another Ditko character, Mr A. And Alan Moore actually claims to be an Anarchist/Occultist more than a simple lefty. Get your facts straight.
TooTicky| 3.11.09 @ 5:11AM
In a way it's not just Alan Moore's dislike of objectivists. He feels that objectivists are generally hypocritical and as such, made Rorschach a hugely hypocritical character. (An example being how he supported Truman's bombing of Hiroshima and at the end of the story...)
I don't think things like Rorschach's opinions on sex and drugs really make him any less objectivist just because it branches out from the traditional libertarian objectivist viewpoints. In the grand scheme of things, those topics are somewhat petty, too political and not philosophical.
And not all the conservatives are played out as caricatures. Hollis Mason, one of the book's only voices of reason, is implied to be somewhat conservative. You just notice the more exaggerated characters more easily.
Money| 3.20.09 @ 11:10PM
You also forgot to mention Rorschach's views on money. Objectivist's would not want someone to be rich off of deceit, but they would love it if someone was rich because they worked hard and never exploited anyone. So I think that should have been pointed out when writing the character.
rusli zainal sang visioner| 8.29.09 @ 1:19AM
nice share, great article, very usefull for us...thank you
Stop Dreaming Start Action |
kenali dan kunjungi objek wisata di pandeglang
would love it if| 10.23.09 @ 6:10AM
James Hoggan talked about the impact he hopes the book will have in an October 20 interview with Amy Goodman on the radio program Democracy Now!: new books releases
tour| 11.11.09 @ 7:11AM
tour comedy Larry David Fights 3 Kids for a Lemonade they gave him and asks them to give him back his $1 that he paid for that lemonade.
Curb Your Enthusiasm
fghfgdf| 11.11.09 @ 7:37AM
tour comedy After losing his pants, Larry David steals some pants from a shopping magazine triggering the alarm for stolen goods from and then walks away as if nothing happened. Curb Your Enthusiasm
dfdf| 11.11.09 @ 7:48AM
After trying to cover up for the panties that Ted Danson's wife found in their car, Larry Blows Up the Underwear Cover by making weird body gestures in front of suspicious Virginia Curb Your Enthusiasm