The American Spectator

home
ADVERTISEMENT
Print Email
Text Size

The Spectacle Blog

Unions Should not be so Confident in EFCA Passing Senate

Why are the unions so confident EFCA will pass Senate? With no MN seat and Kennedy and Burris questionable; that makes 58 at best based on former votes. Questionable GOP Senators not included…

Recent articles surrounding the Employee Free Choice Act have focused on it’s likelyhood of passing the Senate. A statement by the AFL-CIO legislative director Bill Sammuel to reporters claims that the unions think they have the votes needed to pass card check. However, I disagree

Now, I am assuming everyone knows what “card check” and the Employee Free Choice Act (EFCA) is. If not, click here.

Ok, now that you are informed, let’s walk through the numbers.

It is expected that EFCA will be introduced in the House and Senate on Monday. Ok. We all knew that it was going to come at some point; no reason to freak out. Everyone needs to remember that introduction is just that, an introduction. It is not a vote, or a debate, or a huge amendment chance or loss - it is just an introduction that we all knew was coming.

With that being said, let’s go through the votes. Based on last years votes, we can assume that all the R’s, with the questionable excpetion of Sen. Specter, will oppose cloture. Keep that in mind. That’s 39 votes against cloture assuming Specter votes like he did last year.

Now let’s examine the D’s in the Senate. Kennedy? Who knows, as of now, he is not even in D.C. Burris? Where will he be when this comes to a vote? And Minnesota? Franken will probably get in, but he isn’t in yet. Even counting the unknowns (Burris and Kennedy), let’s assume they are present and healthy and will vote yes on cloture. That only makes 58 (assuming all the other D’s support cloture). Even if Specter goes the way he did last year, that is still only 59. Where do you get 60?

The D’s need Franken before they will even push a vote on this. So, my prediction, look for the Franken confirmation date to determine when the Senate EFCA vote will be. (Hint: it will be the day after they get Franken).

This all assumes Pryor, Lincoln, and Nelson support Cloture…which is also questionable.

Additionally, a recent study shows that 600,000 jobs could be lost as a result of passing EFCA.

And, new polling indicates that 74% of rank-and-file union workers oppose EFCA.

Yet Obama thinks this is good for the economy?

The Alliance for Worker Freedom issued this press release in response to the union assertions that they have enough votes. However, on mere mention of the bill being introduced on Monday, the markets have already begun to fall. What does the Obama-Pelosi-Reid Troika think will happen once it gets introduced?

View all comments (15) |

Pingback| 3.5.09 @ 8:20PM

Unions Should not be so Confident in EFCA Passing Senate — But As For Me links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

Unions Should not be so Confident in EFCA Passing Senate — But As For Me .addtoany_share_save img{border:0;} var sc_project=4273169; var sc_invisible=1; var sc_partition=48; var sc_click_stat=1; var sc_security="7dc50185"; var gaJsHost = (("https:" ==…

Willy| 3.5.09 @ 8:25PM

The Senators better be careful. ACORN is going to storm the Senate Chambers.

nick | 3.5.09 @ 9:12PM

i have been a union member for more than 27 years and i completely disagree with the card check legislation. i am the first to challenge management. but all of the union members i talk to want to keep our voting secret ...PERIOD!!!! i am also a life long democrat. obama is my guy!!!! we just love him but most of us hope and pray that congress does the right thing and votes this bill down. in this economy, we will lose too many jobs. as for acorn, there is a plan for acorn to threaten democrates if they don't support the legislation. i don't know about you but i don't respond to threats well!!!!!

Harry| 3.6.09 @ 7:06AM

Kennedy was in DC yesterday.

Dasaro| 3.6.09 @ 8:13AM

The wayward republicans are in bed with
BHO, the marxist, who is now the quintessential community organizer-in-chief, from the south side
of Chicago; the pigsty of politicians!
Communism is rearing its ugly head in this government. Sad but true.

Pingback| 3.6.09 @ 11:14AM

North Carolina’s Union Movement » Press Clips March 6, 2009 links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…America is Ready (OpEd) Firefighters unionizing under rules of tribal law Fight looms over trucks Free choice? (Editorial) Union bill’s fate linked to Lincoln and Pryor Unions Should not be so Confident in EFCA Passing Senate (OpEd) Alinskyians support Employee Free Choice Act (OpEd) NYSUT releases women in labor history timeline to honor International Working Women’s Day (Ron Moore) You can follow…

jim| 3.10.09 @ 8:01AM

EFCA is a terrible bill on so many levels. Even George Mcgovern opposes it. Think about that. You don't get more pro labor than Mcgovern and he sees the sham in this. Secret ballot and first contract mandatory arbitration must go or the results will be disastrous for the workers and management alike. Union claims of management intimidation are equally matched by union manipulations, and intimidation of members as well as management. Small companes particularly don't have the resources to contend with big well funded labor. The administration would be better served to deal with min. wage, vacaions, health nsurance, and retirement legislatively WIYTHOUT UNIONS. Anyone who thinks big labor cares about anything but itself and its money is extremely ptifuly naive. DEFEAT EFCA!!!

Jim| 3.10.09 @ 8:04AM

Correction: Secret ballot must stay and card check must go.

david lebus| 5.31.09 @ 8:10AM

defeat efca!

asd sadsa | 2.22.10 @ 4:28AM

sdfsdfsdf

More Blog Posts by Brian Johnson

http://spectator.org/blog/2009/03/05/unions-should-not-be-so-confid

ADVERTISEMENT

SPONSORED LINKS

FLASHBACK TO: 1995

Clip of the Day

Most Popular Articles

The Liberal Union Behind the IRS

Jeffrey Lord | 5.16.13

My Generation’s Disease

Benjamin Brophy | 5.17.13

Not Ready for Primetime Players

Daniel J. Flynn | 5.17.13

Pick Obama's Brain

Paul Kengor | 5.16.13

Assessing a Week of Scandal

Matt Purple | 5.17.13

Oops, Maybe Government is Tyrannical

Marta H. Mossburg | 5.17.13

Pray and Grow Rich

Christopher Orlet | 5.16.13

From Bimbos to Benghazi

Jeffrey Lord | 5.9.13

ADVERTISEMENT