Just when you hope the Republican politicians understand the
urgent need to resist more wasteful spending, they lead the
charge to put more money into the most inflated part of the
economy, the housing market.
Seeking to jump-start the housing market, the Senate added new
tax relief for homebuyers to its $900 billion economic stimulus
bill yesterday as the legislation moved toward a final vote.
The amendment, offered by Sen.
Johnny Isakson (R-Ga.), represents a significant victory
for Republicans. GOP lawmakers have complained that the package
includes few of their priorities for easing the economic
crisis, including more help for the housing sector, which has
been devastated by foreclosures and the frozen credit market.
The Isakson provision would offer a tax credit of up to $15,000
for any home bought as a primary residence, for one year after
the stimulus bill is signed into law. It would add $19 billion
to the plan.
The best that can be said is that this isn't as stupid or costly
as Sen. Mitch McConnell's proposal for Uncle Sam to hand out a
four percent mortgage to anyone who wants--which would
have run a couple hundred billion dollars annually--and
Sen. John McCain's truly nutty, and even more
expensive, idea for the federal government to buy up every
bad mortgage in America at face value.
The housing market bubble burst. It cannot be
reinflated. The bust will be painful, but dumping more
money into the market in an attempt to inflate prices will only
slow the adjustment process. The pain is unfortunate, even
tragic for some people, but inevitable.
No one in their right mind will buy a house today, while Congress
is debating how much money they're going to give someone who buys
a house after legislation is signed. That's the same thing that's
been happening to lending. Until banks know what "the deal" is,
they will sit tight.
The more we talk; the more we freeze. overnment ruins everything
it touches.
…the cost was estimated at $18.5 billion, but has now been recalculated by the Congressional Budget Office at about $35.5 billion. As Doug Bandow notes, though, Isakson’s tax credit is an atrocious idea for a more important reason than it’s cost: The housing market bubble burst. It cannot be reinflated. The bust will be painful, but dumping more money into the market in an attempt to inflate prices will only…
sre| 2.11.09 @ 9:26AM
The process itself is destructive.
No one in their right mind will buy a house today, while Congress is debating how much money they're going to give someone who buys a house after legislation is signed. That's the same thing that's been happening to lending. Until banks know what "the deal" is, they will sit tight.
The more we talk; the more we freeze. overnment ruins everything it touches.
Pingback| 2.11.09 @ 2:20PM
Below The Beltway » Blog Archive » Dumb Republican Ideas links to this page. Here’s an excerpt: