There's an old story about three libertarians -- a historian, a
philosopher, and an economist -- discussing how much they all
admire Murray Rothbard. (I'm forgetting some of the details, but I
think the economist was David
Friedman.) The historian says he loves Rothbard on philosophy
and economics, but that his understanding of history falls short.
The philosopher says that, though he loves most of Rothbard's work,
he has some problems with Rothbard's philosophical writings. The
economist adds that, truth be told, he's not a big fan of
Rothbard's economic writings.
There's been a multi-blog debate going on over Jeffery Hart's
essay on
American conservatism in yesterday's Wall Street
Journal, and it's gone something like that. Hart gets so many
things not-quite-right that the critiques of his essay make up a
sort of mini-course in conservative political thought. Happily,
Marc Comtois has collected most of them in one place.
topics:
Economics, Conservatism