The American Spectator

home
ADVERTISEMENT
Print Email
Text Size

The Spectacle Blog

Walk on the Bright Side

Temperamental contrarian that I am, I’m trying hard to find something nice to say about the Harriet Miers nomination. It isn’t easy! But here’s my first stab:

1. She’s not that unqualified, when compared to other non-judge Supreme Court nominees. Compare her resume to those of Pierce Butler or Lewis Powell, for example.

2. She’s a member of an evangelical church, and she advocated changing the ABA’s official stance on abortion (they’re for it). You don’t have to be pro-life to be anti-Roe, but it’s very unusual to find pro-lifers who are pro-Roe. (It is theoretically possible, I suppose, for a person to think that abortion should be illegal but that Roe was correctly decided, or at least sacrosanct on stare decisis grounds. This hypothetical person, who would presumably be a vocal proponent of a Human Life Amendment, is not someone I’ve ever met.)

The big problem is that there are important issues apart from just abortion to worry about in contemporary jurisprudence — and someone like Miers, who hasn’t worked on constitutional law much, probably hasn’t thought much about those issues. So I’m not completely sanguine, but I’m trying.

topics:
Abortion, Constitution, Law, Supreme Court

View all comments (2) |

sidnee | 12.10.09 @ 12:37AM

cheap adidas shoes
cheap nike dunk sb shoes

Related Blog Posts

More Blog Posts by John Tabin

http://spectator.org/blog/2005/10/03/walk-on-the-bright-side

ADVERTISEMENT

SPONSORED LINKS

FLASHBACK TO: 1995

Clip of the Day

Most Popular Articles

The Liberal Union Behind the IRS

Jeffrey Lord | 5.16.13

My Generation’s Disease

Benjamin Brophy | 5.17.13

Not Ready for Primetime Players

Daniel J. Flynn | 5.17.13

Pick Obama's Brain

Paul Kengor | 5.16.13

Assessing a Week of Scandal

Matt Purple | 5.17.13

Pray and Grow Rich

Christopher Orlet | 5.16.13

From Bimbos to Benghazi

Jeffrey Lord | 5.9.13

Oops, Maybe Government is Tyrannical

Marta H. Mossburg | 5.17.13

ADVERTISEMENT