In praising Samuel Alito, Ilya Somin is a bit unfair to Antonin Scalia. Scalia takes a pretty expansive view of First Amendment protections, after all; he was in the majority in the flag-burning cases (which I mentioned here). Scalia has said of one of the flag-burners, "I would have been delighted to throw Mr. Johnson in jail. Unfortunately, as I understand the First Amendment, I couldn't do it." And Raich notwithstanding, Scalia's been pretty good on federalism; while I'd like to believe that Alito would, like Thomas, be even better, I'm not sure that Rybar, by itself, tells us that.
Share this Article
Like this Article
Print this ArticlePrint Article