A dark forecast, with a guide to spotting rays of sunshine.
Election Day is here at last. Below you’ll find a guide to watching the results come in tonight, with my predictions and notes on what it means when I get things wrong. Let’s get the easy calls out of the way first:
Mitt Romney will easily win West Virginia, Kentucky, Tennessee, South Carolina, Georgia, Alabama, Mississippi, Louisiana, Arkansas, Missouri, Texas, Oklahoma, Kansas, Nebraska, North Dakota, South Dakota, Montana, Wyoming, Utah, Arizona, Idaho, Alaska, and Indiana (the last was won by Obama last cycle and several of the others were in play — there is no chance that Romney will do as poorly as John McCain did). President Obama will just as easily win Maine, Vermont, New York, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, New Jersey, Maryland, the District of Columbia, Illinois, New Mexico, Washington, Oregon, California, and Hawaii. This gives each candidate a floor of 191 electoral votes.
Democrats will easily hold Senate seats in California, Delaware, Maryland, Hawaii, Michigan, Minnesota, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Rhode Island, Washington, West Virginia, and, for most purposes, Vermont (socialist incumbent Bernie Sanders is an Independent but caucuses with Democrats). Republicans will easily hold Senate seats in Mississippi, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, and Wyoming.
Electoral vote calls are in bold, with O+x indicating that Obama will add x to his total and R+y indicating that Romney will add y to his total. Senate calls are in italics. All times are Eastern (note that some states span more than one time zone, and these are times when the last polls close; don’t use these times as a guide for when to vote, especially if you live in Florida outside the panhandle).
7:00 pm — Polls close in Indiana. Public opinion polling is difficult in Indiana due to strict regulations targeted at telemarketers, so there’s been relatively little of it; there’s some evidence that the race has moved against Richard Mourdock since his defense of banning abortion in the case of rape, but with so few polls it’s hardly a slam dunk. I’ll bet on the underdog in this one: Mourdock wins (Rep. hold). If I’m wrong: If Joe Donnelly wins, it will a triumph of a narrative of Republican extremism triggered by Todd Akin’s much, much more objectionable comments on the same topic. This narrative has been unfair to Mourdock, but then politics is often an unfair business.
Polls also close in Virginia. Jim Webb doesn’t seem to have found the Senate to his liking, and is retiring after just one term; polls show Democrat Tim Kaine slightly ahead of Republican George Allen in the race to replace him. Kaine will likely win (Dem. hold). The presidential race is a dead heat. I’ve been hearing troubling things about the quality of the GOP ground game in Virginia, so here begins a pessimistic theme: I’m guessing that, after a long night of counting, Obama will win Virginia (O+13). If I’m wrong: Romney’s hope of victory is probably contingent on winning Virginia, so if he pulls it out, a Romney victory remains in reach. And if Allen can beat Kaine in the Senate race, it could be excellent news for Romney, because it means we may be seeing a systemic pro-Democratic bias in state-level polls.
Such a systemic bias isn’t all that implausible; the polls are regularly turning out Democrat-heavy samples that raise questions about whether there’s a skew in the way they’re treating party identification. I’m less inclined than some observers to ignore the polling averages on this basis — party ID ratios that deviate from the norm are a good reason to ignore individual polls, but in this case almost all the polls are pointing in one direction. it’s certainly not impossible for pollsters to all be wrong at once, and there are colorable hypotheses as to why that might be happening in this cycle. For an extensive discussion of this, see this post by Ted Frank.
7:30 pm — Polls close in North Carolina, which Obama carried in 2008; a couple of pollsters show it close, but more of them show it as a relatively easy win for Romney, which it almost certainly is (R+15).
Polls also close in Ohio. In the Senate race, incumbent Democrat Sherrod Brown leads challenger Josh Mandel in every poll, sometimes quite comfortably, so expect him to win (Dem. hold). The presidential race is closer, but the latest polls all show a late break toward Obama. It’ll be tight, but I expect the president to win (O+18). If I’m wrong: The Senate race in Ohio, as in Virginia, may give evidence for or against the theory that the polls are understating Republican strength. If Brown isn’t beating Mandel comfortably, it’s good news for Romney. It’s even better news for Romney, of course, if he wins the state — though if Romney pulls it out in Virginia, he has paths to victory both going through Ohio and also going around it (more on that below).
8:00 pm — Polls close in DC and in sixteen states. Among them:
Maine. Moderate Republican Senator Olympia Snowe is retiring, the Independent former governor Angus King is a lock to replace her, and King will almost certainly caucus with the Democrats; put an asterisk on it if you like, but essentially that’s a Dem. gain.
Connecticut. Joe Lieberman is retiring, and while a month ago it looked like Republican Linda McMahon had a shot at replacing him, the polls are now breaking strongly toward Democrat Chris Murphy (Dem. hold).
Massachusetts. Elizabeth Warren looks poised to unseat Scott Brown (Dem. gain). If I’m wrong: It’ll be a huge coup for the UMass/Boston Herald poll, the only one showing Brown slightly ahead.
Missouri. Claire McCaskill looked like one of the most vulnerable Democrats in the Senate — until Todd Akin mused about “legitimate rape,” and then ignored Republicans begging him to step aside. Akin is a legitimate disaster, and the electorate has ways of shutting that down (Dem. hold). If I’m wrong: Large numbers of anti-McCaskill voters were embarrassed to admit to pollsters that they’d vote for Akin (actually quite possible).
Pennsylvania. For a while it looked like Republican Tom Smith was gaining enough to make this close, but now incumbent Democrat Bob Casey looks like he’ll win easily (Dem. hold). In the presidential race, Romney has made a push to expand the playing field into Pennsylvania and the Obama campaign has felt compelled to defend it, but the same thing has happened in previous cycles and the state always seems to stay just outside Republicans’ reach. I’d bet on that happening again (O+20). If I’m wrong: If Romney takes Pennsylvania, he’s probably going to win (and I was probably wrong about some of the pessimistic calls above). If Casey isn’t ahead as comfortably as expected, it could be another indicator of pro-Democratic sampling errors in the polls.
A man of faith in a godless age is hitting Americans where it hurts.
Mr. and Mrs. American Spectator Reader, let P.J. O’Rourke talk sense to your kids.
In Britain, defending your property can get you life.
The debacle of this president’s administration is both a cause and a symptom of the decline of American values. Unless Congress impeaches him, that decline will go on unchecked. An eminent jurist surveys the damage and assesses the chances for the recovery of our culture.
It won’t take long for conservatives to scratch this presidential wannabe off their 2008 scorecard.
The American Christmas, like the songs that celebrate it, makes room for everybody under the rainbow. Is that why so many people seem to be hostile to it?
Was the President done in by the economy, or by the politics of the economy?