The American Spectator

home
ADVERTISEMENT
Political Hay
Print Email
Text Size

Political Hay

Past Presidential Punditry

How earlier presidents might have been treated like Mitt Romney.

As it becomes more and more evident that Mitt Romney will be the Republican presidential nominee, a strange thing is happening; strange as in outlandish, but not surprising. For the past year or so, the liberal media has been panting for his nomination as if they were in his employ. He couldn’t have hired more efficient hit men to belittle his rivals or besmirch their reputations. But, as we have seen many times before, this honeymoon is about to come to an abrupt end when they will turn on him faster than warm mayonnaise.

This of course will be explained away by noting that Romney will be “running to the right” in the general election, and will thus be transformed from a smooth and articulate business executive into a numbskulled, knuckle-dragging Neanderthal. And without fail, he will be labeled with the most damning words in the liberal lexicon: incurious and un-nuanced. He will be subjected to various and sundry spelling and geography tests by the same folks who got the vapors over Dan Quayle’s “potatoe,” yet batted nary an eyelash over Barack Obama’s “57 states.” Yes, you can bet that the keyboards of these paragons of journalism will be working overtime reworking their Mitt bios.

Which caused me to wonder: what if today’s leading lights of liberal punditry were to describe some our first presidents and apply their poison pens thusly? Come to think of it, the following blurbs can probably already be found right in your children’s history books.

George Washington: A Southern aristocrat who was born to the purple yet cloaked himself in the same false humility as his namesakes in the Bush family, he was purported to be so honest as to have confessed to chopping down a cherry tree, and so athletic that he threw a silver dollar across the Potomac River. Yet our sources have revealed that it was his starving slaves who ravaged the tree, while the tossing of currency was an apocryphal example of his noted profligacy.

While he was famous for promoting his own extreme religious views, as a general he launched a unilateral and unprovoked sneak attack against German immigrants sold into military service by their greedy princes, on their holiest day of the year.

Best Attribute: Was said to be a prolific dancer and an able horseman.

Most outrageous quote: “The very atmosphere of firearms anywhere and everywhere restrains evil interference — they deserve a place of honor with all that’s good.”

John Adams: Was primarily known as the author of the Alien and Sedition Acts; the most nefarious legislation the nation had ever known until surpassed by the even more restrictive Patriot Act of 2001. Was admitted to the bar after graduating Harvard, although there is no record of his having published anything in the Law Review. His most famous case was the acquittal of three soldiers who gunned down an unarmed African American community organizer.

Was also notable for having appointed John Marshall as Chief Justice of the U.S. Supreme Court, who, in the famous case, Marbury v. Madison, somehow decided that the Courts should be able to decide the constitutionality of laws passed by Congress. This decision has, of course, subsequently been disclaimed by more qualified Constitutional experts.

Best Attribute: Although he was self-admittedly “obnoxious and disliked,” it was nonetheless rumored that most of his pre-presidential decisions were made by his wife.

Most outrageous quote: “We have no government armed with power capable of contending with human passions unbridled by morality and religion… Our Constitution is designed only for a moral and religious people. It is wholly inadequate for any other.”

Thomas Jefferson: Best known as the author of the Declaration of Independence through which he established the separation of Church and State. And although he was a notorious enemy of a strong federal government, he nonetheless expanded U.S. power by seizing nearly one million square miles of land that was rightfully the property of Native Americans, via the so-called Louisiana Purchase.

Best Attribute: His record of speaking against slavery while owning hundreds of slaves himself, was greatly mitigated by his marriage to his household slave Sally Hemings, with whom he had six children; subsequently freeing all of them and providing for them in his will.

Most outrageous quote: “But with respect to future debt; would it not be wise and just for that nation to declare in the constitution they are forming that neither the legislature, nor the nation itself can validly contract more debt, than they may pay within their own age, or within the term of 19 years?”

Note: All biographical content is the responsibility of the anonymous authors, although any inaccuracies may well be accounted for on next week’s New York Times Corrections page.

About the Author

Lisa Fabrizio is a columnist who hails from Connecticut (mailbox@lisafab.com).

Letter to the Editor View all comments (11) |

River | 4.18.12 @ 8:25AM

Very funny! Well done! They would have ripped Lincoln to shreds, too.

Jack in Wi.| 4.18.12 @ 8:38AM

Lincoln and a lot of early presidents were ripped to shreds by the very partisan press of their days. The election of Lincoln ended up in the country dividing into a brutal civil war. Jefferson was attacked and so was Adams father and son. Jackson and his wife were both attacked. We could go down the whole list and find some personal attack or violent political attack on most presidential candidates.

The problem with Romney is that his seen asa guy who talks double and triple talk out of both sides of his mouth. He is also seen as a politician who has the backbone of a jellyfish. Then he seen as a very rich man who really can't see the problems of the poor and middle class. I guess that's the way I seee him as well. I am done voting for the lesser evil. With Romney's constant warmongering, I have doubts who the lesser evil is.

Mac Jehoff| 4.18.12 @ 9:30AM

History according to Jack is not based on facts, but twisted to suit his own egomaniacal rants. Fromage for brains.

Reality1| 4.18.12 @ 5:53PM

What part of his history do you consider non-factual?

Crassus| 4.18.12 @ 2:52PM

Back at you, Jack. Enough with these evil neocons.

Reality1| 4.18.12 @ 9:06AM

'Then he seen as a very rich man who really can't see the problems of the poor and middle class. I guess that's the way I seee him as well. I am done voting for the lesser evil. With Romney's constant warmongering, I have doubts who the lesser evil is." Try this: instead of resorting to accepting the mainstream characterizations of Romney, do a little background reading and research. Ruminate on what you discover for a week or so and THEN make a decision about who you believe Romney to be. And, just for future reference, your premise about not being able to see the problems of...... If that statement were true in reality, no person could help any other person unless they lived/experienced the same exact life as the one they sought to help. Dangerous thinking.

Clint| 4.18.12 @ 10:20AM

The RINO-CINO Ruling Elites' Flunkie Stooges Are Once Again Attempting To Sell Us Their RINO-CINO Specter-McCain "Lesser Evil" Crap Sandwich, AsThey Look Down On Us, As "Useful Dupes".

Romney Is McCain Redux.

Teflon93| 4.18.12 @ 7:09PM

I must have missed where they implemented socialized medicine and gay marriage.

therealguyfaux| 4.18.12 @ 7:15PM

James Buchanan= reputed to have been gay;
Franklin Pierce= reputed to have been an alcoholic;
Theodore Roosevelt= neurotic overcompensator for having lived a pampered childhood, by being a macho stereotype;
Woodrow Wilson= racist; kept his true medical condition secret after a stroke;
Franklin Roosevelt= with connivance of the media, never shown being wheeled around in his wheelchair, to avoid stories about his physical strength, or lack thereof, to be able to carry out his presidential schedule;
Ronald Reagan= blind as a bat, which is why when he was drafted he ended up making VD training films in Hollywood instead of fighting overseas.

Oh, past presidents have had plenty of things about them the Media could have seized upon, as far as whether they were "Presidential timber," either before office or in office, if the Media had really wanted to do so, and it seems nowadays we want them to. If Jesus H. Christ Almighty were running for President, they'd bring out the episode with the money-changers in the Temple as to whether He had sufficient self-control, and they'd bring up the fact that at 30 years old, He was still living with His mother and His girlfriend was a sinful woman with mental problems (cf. casting out the demons from the Magdalene).

albert constantine jr.| 4.18.12 @ 9:37PM

...not to mention his propensity for substance abuse (constantly changing water into wine), hanging out with tax collectors and other nefarious types in a sandal-wearing gang called either "The Apostles" or "The Disciples", and his arrest at a wild Seder Party (arranged by a police informant) in which a public servant was injured (ear sliced off but treated at the scene)...

More Articles by Lisa Fabrizio

More Articles From Political Hay

http://spectator.org/archives/2012/04/18/past-presidential-punditry

ADVERTISEMENT

The Spectacle Blog

Morning Round-Up 5-23

Patrick Ryan | 10:06AM

Morning Round-Up 5-23

Patrick Ryan | 10:06AM

Sorry, You Can’t Delegate Responsibility

Ray V. Hartwell, III | 9:10AM

Issa Recovers

Ross Kaminsky | 5.22.13

The Religion of Peace Strikes London Again

Aaron Goldstein | 5.22.13

SPONSORED LINKS

FLASHBACK TO: 1995

Clip of the Day

ADVERTISEMENT