After two weeks of shock and awe, Syria’s opposition remains
intact. Will Assad’s army do likewise?
(Page 2 of 2)
More ominously for the regime, it has finally witnessed
jihad declared against it by radical Islamists, including al Qaeda.
The religious and sectarian dimensions of the conflict are clearly
escalating. A goodexample of the
latest trendis a video, purportedly from
Homs, that shows Free Syrian Army soldiers with members of
al-Qa’ida.
February 17, 2012. Some rebel groups in Homs
fly their and al Qaeda’s flags together.
In the background, alongside the banners of the Free
Syrian Army, there are the familiar black flags of al Qaeda’s Iraqi
branch, with the black background and white Arabic script,
featuring the Shahadah on top and a circular logo bearing the words
“Allah, Rasul Mohammed.” The black background indicates the
Islamist militants’ mindset: they are fighting in Dar al-Harb
against an infidel regime. This point is corroborated by the fact
that they identify the Free Syrian Army with the “mumineen”
(“believers”).
In the Missile East, failure to trumpet one’s strength can
have severe consequences. You cannot promise to come down with an
iron fist and then fail to deliver. By now even roosters in Homs
are no longer impressed with Bashar’s artillery. If there is still
some of this iron fist we haven’t seen until today, Assad Junior
had better show it now. Otherwise, the chickens may soon come Homs
to roost for his regime.
February 17, 2012. The chickens in Homs are no
longer impressed.
Aymenn Jawad Al-Tamimi is a Shillman-Ginsburg Fellow at the Middle East Forum, and a student at Brasenose College, Oxford University. His website is http://www.aymennjawad.org.
About the Author
Oskar Svadkovsky is a computer networking professional based in Tel Aviv, and the owner of the Happy Arab News Service blog. He graduated in Indian and Chinese Studies at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem.
Mr jaw ad & co seem very desperate to encourage bashar al
Assad. And malign the opposition. I can't say how long it will take
but this regimes days are numbered. The minorities should throw in
their lot with the sunnies and help to shape a future Syria. They
will gain nothing from this torturing regime. Mr jawad's articles
are cleverly disguised islamophobia . The Muslim people will work
out democracy etc.. Within their own sociohistorical parameters.
Why that gets people here into a tizzy fit is not always clear. The
use of outlier terrorist movements to besmirch Muslims is a well
worn tactic. The hegemony of Israel seems to play a big part in
this demonisation.
The Wahbi sect of Saudia Arabia is the most radical group
around. It is the main home of terrorism in the Muslim world. With
friends like Saudia Arabia and Israel the USA doesn't need any
enemies. Let Syria figure out it's future by itself. Every time we
stick our fingers in the neighborhood, they get burnt.
You disapoint JackinWi. I though the Jooooos were the main
source of terrorism in the middle east. I tune in nice and early
for my daily does of blood libel and I have to hear JackinWI blame
arabs for terrorism???
The supporters of the rebels are Al Queda and Saudi Arabia. The
biggest losers if Assad falls will be the Christian minority in the
country which is protected by the dictator. It will be the same as
in Iraq when Saddam fell the USA did not protect the Christians
there and they were forced to flee.
Sean that is absolutely correct. The Christians were ethnically
cleansed from Iraq (their ancestoral homeland since pre-Islamic
times) and the occupying United States government did nothing to
protect them even though it was their toppling of Saddam Hussein
who made the conditions ripe for such an anti-Christian pogrom. To
Assad's credit he gave the Iraqi Christians refuge, something the
United States did not do.
I know what Wahhabists will do if they take power in Syria. I
support Assad 100% and Russia, China and even Iran are completely
right to support Assad as well. If Assad goes Alawites, Druze and
Christians will all be in a precarious position just as Coptic
Christians have found themselves in Egypt.
Dr.Ron Paul,
“The President also defended his unconstitutional intervention in
Libya,
authorized not by the United States Congress but by the United
Nations,
and announced new plans to pressure Syria and force the leader of
that
country to step down.
“Our military is already dangerously extended, and this
administration
wants to expand our involvement. When will our bombing in Libya
end? Is
President Obama seriously considering military action against
Syria? We
are facing $2 trillion dollar deficits, and the American taxpayer
cannot
afford any of it.
“Our military’s purpose is to defend our country, not to police
the
Middle East.
“As the President prepares to send even more support to Egypt,
we should
be reminded that it was our foreign aid that helped Mubarak retain
power
to repress his people in the first place. Now we have to deal with
the
consequences of those decisions, yet we keep repeating the same
mistakes.
“I am not the only one who can see the absurdities of our
foreign
policy. We give $3 billion to Israel and $12 billion to her
enemies.
Most Americans know that makes no sense.
“We need to come to our senses, trade with our friends in the
Middle
East (both Arab and Israeli), clean up our own economic mess so we
set a
good example, and allow them to work out their own conflicts.”
The Tea Party Rebellion Heads To A Brokered Convention.
You Wouldn't Know Real Conservatism If It Hit Ya With A 2x4,Real
Loser.
Read George Washington's Farewell Address, Thomas Jefferson's
First Inaugural Address, The Old Right And Get Back To Us.
" George Will, "Today, we have a very different kind of foreign
policy. It’s called Wilsonian. And the premise of the Bush Doctrine
is that America must spread democracy, because our national
security depends upon it. And America can spread democracy. It
knows how. It can engage in national building. This is conservative
or not?"
William F. Buckley, " It’s not at all conservative. It’s
anything but conservative. It’s not conservative at all, inasmuch
as conservatism doesn’t invite unnecessary challenges. It insists
on coming to terms with the world as it is …”
The Tea Party Rebellion Heads To A Brokered Convention.
Ron Paul's foreign policy is traditional conservatism at its
best. Also Ron Paul is a social conservative he just doesn't
believe the government needs to dictate what happends in your
bedroom as long as its two consenting adults. Ron Paul has been
consistantly pro-life.
May the current situation in Syria linger for a very long
time.
Every day that passes decreases the number of Syrians who will
live to face the Israel Defence Forces as soldiers on the Golan. I
think the present and future Syrian army must be down by about 2
combat battallions by now.
Choices, choices. Do we support the Muslim Brotherhood led
rebels, or the bloodthirsty, Iranian proxy dictator?
As far as I'm concerned, we should "support" neither.
And don't forget that those nice "rebels" in Homs are relieving
their stress themselves killing Christians.
Because this is all about Oil. (And the Neo-Cons influence, if
you agree with this columnist.)
There are other views on Syria from other parts of the world
that don't jibe with the ones we generally see from our Clinton run
state department and here at A.S. and in our own national
press.
Let's back the rebels. Like in Libya. Then they will overthrow
the brutal regime and replace it with DEMOCRACY1 The Syrian people
will establish good relations with neighbors, the people will be
free, trade will flourish, etc. Right?
I seem to recall that OUR MUSLIM, went to KINETIC ACTION against
a Country - Libya - that was NOT Aligned with IRAN, for a whole
Helluva lot less, than what's going on in Syria.
I think that about 150 Libyans had been killed by Khaddafi. That
was enough for Hussein to Lead from behind in a Campaign of
Kineticism against Moammar.
How many DEAD in Syria? How many THOUSANDS?
Anybody care to explain the SELECTIVITY in Hamas' Deliverer's
definition of what precipitates a Kinetic Non War Response, and
what does not?
Senators McCain and Graham want to arm the rebels, they never
learn either side of this conflict is poison to the US. The media
has stopped reporting on what is happening on the ground in Egypt
and Libya, I would bet most Americans have no idea 19 Americans are
being held in Egypt and face trials...thanks Barack.
Just another attempt at an Islamic regime change. If Assad
cracks, he will be lucky to escape with his life (and the national
treasure). That may be problematical, what with the ability to
trace funds in international banking. No Islamic regime leader
leaves office except by assassination or exile. The Syrians will
then install another tyrant. He may even be elected.
We should stand aside, and recognize whomever grabs the brass ring.
Going in on these things on the pretext of saving civilian lives is
just plain silly. Since when has that ever been the job of America?
America has never gone to war for that purpose. Otherwise, where
were we in Cambodia, China, Angola, Congo, South Africa,. . . .? It
is only a pretext to do whatever the reigning party wants to do. At
least we had the excuse of revenge when we went into Afghanistan
and Iraq, even if we had no valid reason (at least no sane reason)
to stay as long as we have, and waste lives and treasure trying to
impose Jeffersonian democracy.
Leave Syria for the Syrians (and the Iranians).
Just another attempt at an Islamic regime change. If Assad
cracks, he will be lucky to escape with his life (and the national
treasure). That may be problematical, what with the ability to
trace funds in international banking. No Islamic regime leader
leaves office except by assassination or exile. The Syrians will
then install another tyrant. He may even be elected.
We should stand aside, and recognize whomever grabs the brass ring.
Going in on these things on the pretext of saving civilian lives is
just plain silly. Since when has that ever been the job of America?
America has never gone to war for that purpose. Otherwise, where
were we in Cambodia, China, Angola, Congo, South Africa,. . . .? It
is only a pretext to do whatever the reigning party wants to do. At
least we had the excuse of revenge when we went into Afghanistan
and Iraq, even if we had no valid reason (at least no sane reason)
to stay as long as we have, and waste lives and treasure trying to
impose Jeffersonian democracy.
Leave Syria for the Syrians (and the Iranians).
Just another attempt at an Islamic regime change. If Assad
cracks, he will be lucky to escape with his life (and the national
treasure). That may be problematical, what with the ability to
trace funds in international banking. No Islamic regime leader
leaves office except by assassination or exile. The Syrians will
then install another tyrant. He may even be elected.
We should stand aside, and recognize whomever grabs the brass ring.
Going in on these things on the pretext of saving civilian lives is
just plain silly. Since when has that ever been the job of America?
America has never gone to war for that purpose. Otherwise, where
were we in Cambodia, China, Angola, Congo, South Africa,. . . .? It
is only a pretext to do whatever the reigning party wants to do. At
least we had the excuse of revenge when we went into Afghanistan
and Iraq, even if we had no valid reason (at least no sane reason)
to stay as long as we have, and waste lives and treasure trying to
impose Jeffersonian democracy.
Leave Syria for the Syrians (and the Iranians).
Before the West buys into the corporate media propaganda
machines I beg them to ponder this. There is grafitti on the walls
of Homs with this ominous message from the Syrian Opposition.
"Christians to Beiruit and Alawites to the Wall". Now if that isn't
suggesting that the Sunni (and increasingly Islamist) opposition is
not planning massive ethnic cleansing of Syria's religious
minorities (who are backing Assad an Alawite) than I don't know
what does.
The debacle of this president’s administration is both a cause
and a symptom of the decline of American values. Unless Congress
impeaches him, that decline will go on unchecked. An eminent jurist
surveys the damage and assesses the chances for the recovery of our
culture.
The American Christmas, like the songs that celebrate it,
makes room for everybody under the rainbow. Is that why so
many people seem to be hostile to it?
John786| 2.21.12 @ 7:30AM
Mr jaw ad & co seem very desperate to encourage bashar al Assad. And malign the opposition. I can't say how long it will take but this regimes days are numbered. The minorities should throw in their lot with the sunnies and help to shape a future Syria. They will gain nothing from this torturing regime. Mr jawad's articles are cleverly disguised islamophobia . The Muslim people will work out democracy etc.. Within their own sociohistorical parameters. Why that gets people here into a tizzy fit is not always clear. The use of outlier terrorist movements to besmirch Muslims is a well worn tactic. The hegemony of Israel seems to play a big part in this demonisation.
Alan Brooks| 2.21.12 @ 7:43AM
Yes, but Assad will go into exile- a pleasant one.
He has connections and wont end up on the desert floor with blood on his snout, as Gaddhafi did.
A smooth operator.
albert constantine jr| 2.21.12 @ 6:14PM
...and don't forget, as an opthamologist, he could be coming soon to a Lenscrafters at your local mall.
Alan Brooks| 2.21.12 @ 9:47PM
"he could be coming soon to a Lenscrafters at your local mall."
He is interested in blinding us, not correcting out vision.
Jack in Wi.| 2.21.12 @ 7:44AM
The Wahbi sect of Saudia Arabia is the most radical group around. It is the main home of terrorism in the Muslim world. With friends like Saudia Arabia and Israel the USA doesn't need any enemies. Let Syria figure out it's future by itself. Every time we stick our fingers in the neighborhood, they get burnt.
Bobloblaw| 2.21.12 @ 8:04AM
You disapoint JackinWi. I though the Jooooos were the main source of terrorism in the middle east. I tune in nice and early for my daily does of blood libel and I have to hear JackinWI blame arabs for terrorism???
Sean| 2.21.12 @ 2:49PM
The supporters of the rebels are Al Queda and Saudi Arabia. The biggest losers if Assad falls will be the Christian minority in the country which is protected by the dictator. It will be the same as in Iraq when Saddam fell the USA did not protect the Christians there and they were forced to flee.
Dmitry Aleksandrovich| 2.23.12 @ 2:53AM
Sean that is absolutely correct. The Christians were ethnically cleansed from Iraq (their ancestoral homeland since pre-Islamic times) and the occupying United States government did nothing to protect them even though it was their toppling of Saddam Hussein who made the conditions ripe for such an anti-Christian pogrom. To Assad's credit he gave the Iraqi Christians refuge, something the United States did not do.
Bobloblaw| 2.21.12 @ 8:05AM
""The Muslim people will work out democracy etc.""
Democracy Islamic style:
Two muslim men voting to rape the muslim woman.
John786| 2.21.12 @ 9:43AM
Racist. How do I know? I just read your words.
albert constantine jr| 2.21.12 @ 6:13PM
Wouldn't that remark be religionist?
Dmitry Aleksandrovich| 2.23.12 @ 2:50AM
I know what Wahhabists will do if they take power in Syria. I support Assad 100% and Russia, China and even Iran are completely right to support Assad as well. If Assad goes Alawites, Druze and Christians will all be in a precarious position just as Coptic Christians have found themselves in Egypt.
Clint| 2.21.12 @ 8:22AM
Dr.Ron Paul,
“The President also defended his unconstitutional intervention in Libya,
authorized not by the United States Congress but by the United Nations,
and announced new plans to pressure Syria and force the leader of that
country to step down.
“Our military is already dangerously extended, and this administration
wants to expand our involvement. When will our bombing in Libya end? Is
President Obama seriously considering military action against Syria? We
are facing $2 trillion dollar deficits, and the American taxpayer cannot
afford any of it.
“Our military’s purpose is to defend our country, not to police the
Middle East.
“As the President prepares to send even more support to Egypt, we should
be reminded that it was our foreign aid that helped Mubarak retain power
to repress his people in the first place. Now we have to deal with the
consequences of those decisions, yet we keep repeating the same mistakes.
“I am not the only one who can see the absurdities of our foreign
policy. We give $3 billion to Israel and $12 billion to her enemies.
Most Americans know that makes no sense.
“We need to come to our senses, trade with our friends in the Middle
East (both Arab and Israeli), clean up our own economic mess so we set a
good example, and allow them to work out their own conflicts.”
The Tea Party Rebellion Heads To A Brokered Convention.
Dick Nome | 2.21.12 @ 1:56PM
Rube Paul is an f'ing liberal. Ron Paul on Social Conservatism: 'I Think It's a Losing Position'
Romney/ Paul , two peas in a pod.
Clint| 2.21.12 @ 7:29PM
You Wouldn't Know Real Conservatism If It Hit Ya With A 2x4,Real Loser.
Read George Washington's Farewell Address, Thomas Jefferson's First Inaugural Address, The Old Right And Get Back To Us.
" George Will, "Today, we have a very different kind of foreign policy. It’s called Wilsonian. And the premise of the Bush Doctrine is that America must spread democracy, because our national security depends upon it. And America can spread democracy. It knows how. It can engage in national building. This is conservative or not?"
William F. Buckley, " It’s not at all conservative. It’s anything but conservative. It’s not conservative at all, inasmuch as conservatism doesn’t invite unnecessary challenges. It insists on coming to terms with the world as it is …”
The Tea Party Rebellion Heads To A Brokered Convention.
Dmitry Aleksandrovich| 2.23.12 @ 2:56AM
Ron Paul's foreign policy is traditional conservatism at its best. Also Ron Paul is a social conservative he just doesn't believe the government needs to dictate what happends in your bedroom as long as its two consenting adults. Ron Paul has been consistantly pro-life.
Paul Kotik| 2.21.12 @ 8:23AM
May the current situation in Syria linger for a very long time.
Every day that passes decreases the number of Syrians who will live to face the Israel Defence Forces as soldiers on the Golan. I think the present and future Syrian army must be down by about 2 combat battallions by now.
Keep it up, rebels. Keep it up, Bashar.
It's a shame both sides can't lose.
Harry the Horrible| 2.21.12 @ 8:48AM
Choices, choices. Do we support the Muslim Brotherhood led rebels, or the bloodthirsty, Iranian proxy dictator?
As far as I'm concerned, we should "support" neither.
And don't forget that those nice "rebels" in Homs are relieving their stress themselves killing Christians.
Bob K.| 2.21.12 @ 9:06AM
This is what is currently going on. Two Iranian warships were granted clearance through the Suez Canal by Egypt and are now in port in Syria.
http://atimes.com/atimes/Middle_East/NB22Ak02.html
Because this is all about Oil. (And the Neo-Cons influence, if you agree with this columnist.)
There are other views on Syria from other parts of the world that don't jibe with the ones we generally see from our Clinton run state department and here at A.S. and in our own national press.
http://atimes.com/atimes/Middle_East/NB22Ak04.html
richard ryan| 2.21.12 @ 9:07AM
Let's back the rebels. Like in Libya. Then they will overthrow the brutal regime and replace it with DEMOCRACY1 The Syrian people will establish good relations with neighbors, the people will be free, trade will flourish, etc. Right?
Timothy L. Pennell| 2.21.12 @ 10:53AM
I seem to recall that OUR MUSLIM, went to KINETIC ACTION against a Country - Libya - that was NOT Aligned with IRAN, for a whole Helluva lot less, than what's going on in Syria.
I think that about 150 Libyans had been killed by Khaddafi. That was enough for Hussein to Lead from behind in a Campaign of Kineticism against Moammar.
How many DEAD in Syria? How many THOUSANDS?
Anybody care to explain the SELECTIVITY in Hamas' Deliverer's definition of what precipitates a Kinetic Non War Response, and what does not?
Anyone?
Indy| 2.21.12 @ 9:08AM
Senators McCain and Graham want to arm the rebels, they never learn either side of this conflict is poison to the US. The media has stopped reporting on what is happening on the ground in Egypt and Libya, I would bet most Americans have no idea 19 Americans are being held in Egypt and face trials...thanks Barack.
Citizen Jerry| 2.21.12 @ 10:53AM
In all truthfulness, Bashir needs a grenade in his shorts.
Dustoff| 2.21.12 @ 12:35PM
Shall we not forget, both Hillary & O-dumber. Said Assad was thier guy and he could work with them (reformer)
Jezzzzz.
Mike w| 2.21.12 @ 8:02PM
I presume that you hate Christian since they will slaughtered just as they were in Egypt and Iraq after the regime change.
cicero| 2.21.12 @ 12:58PM
Just another attempt at an Islamic regime change. If Assad cracks, he will be lucky to escape with his life (and the national treasure). That may be problematical, what with the ability to trace funds in international banking. No Islamic regime leader leaves office except by assassination or exile. The Syrians will then install another tyrant. He may even be elected.
We should stand aside, and recognize whomever grabs the brass ring. Going in on these things on the pretext of saving civilian lives is just plain silly. Since when has that ever been the job of America? America has never gone to war for that purpose. Otherwise, where were we in Cambodia, China, Angola, Congo, South Africa,. . . .? It is only a pretext to do whatever the reigning party wants to do. At least we had the excuse of revenge when we went into Afghanistan and Iraq, even if we had no valid reason (at least no sane reason) to stay as long as we have, and waste lives and treasure trying to impose Jeffersonian democracy.
Leave Syria for the Syrians (and the Iranians).
cicero| 2.21.12 @ 12:58PM
Just another attempt at an Islamic regime change. If Assad cracks, he will be lucky to escape with his life (and the national treasure). That may be problematical, what with the ability to trace funds in international banking. No Islamic regime leader leaves office except by assassination or exile. The Syrians will then install another tyrant. He may even be elected.
We should stand aside, and recognize whomever grabs the brass ring. Going in on these things on the pretext of saving civilian lives is just plain silly. Since when has that ever been the job of America? America has never gone to war for that purpose. Otherwise, where were we in Cambodia, China, Angola, Congo, South Africa,. . . .? It is only a pretext to do whatever the reigning party wants to do. At least we had the excuse of revenge when we went into Afghanistan and Iraq, even if we had no valid reason (at least no sane reason) to stay as long as we have, and waste lives and treasure trying to impose Jeffersonian democracy.
Leave Syria for the Syrians (and the Iranians).
cicero| 2.21.12 @ 12:58PM
Just another attempt at an Islamic regime change. If Assad cracks, he will be lucky to escape with his life (and the national treasure). That may be problematical, what with the ability to trace funds in international banking. No Islamic regime leader leaves office except by assassination or exile. The Syrians will then install another tyrant. He may even be elected.
We should stand aside, and recognize whomever grabs the brass ring. Going in on these things on the pretext of saving civilian lives is just plain silly. Since when has that ever been the job of America? America has never gone to war for that purpose. Otherwise, where were we in Cambodia, China, Angola, Congo, South Africa,. . . .? It is only a pretext to do whatever the reigning party wants to do. At least we had the excuse of revenge when we went into Afghanistan and Iraq, even if we had no valid reason (at least no sane reason) to stay as long as we have, and waste lives and treasure trying to impose Jeffersonian democracy.
Leave Syria for the Syrians (and the Iranians).
Paul Kotik| 2.21.12 @ 4:37PM
We should provide low-cost, low-risk help to whichever side appears to be losing at any given time.
Leveut| 2.21.12 @ 9:51PM
Aymenn Jawad Al-Tamimi's columns are always very interesting.
Dmitry Aleksandrovich| 2.23.12 @ 2:47AM
Before the West buys into the corporate media propaganda machines I beg them to ponder this. There is grafitti on the walls of Homs with this ominous message from the Syrian Opposition. "Christians to Beiruit and Alawites to the Wall". Now if that isn't suggesting that the Sunni (and increasingly Islamist) opposition is not planning massive ethnic cleansing of Syria's religious minorities (who are backing Assad an Alawite) than I don't know what does.