The American Spectator : One Day

Text Size

One Day

By James Bowman on 8.29.11 @ 6:02AM

Anne Hathaway's Yorkshire accent has all of Britain up in arms.

How hard could it be for a former scholar of Winchester College to remember the legend associated with the patron saint of Winchester cathedral?

St Swithun's day if thou dost rain, 
For forty days it will remain; 
St Swithun's day if thou be fair, 
For forty days 'twill rain nae mare [sic].

Dexter (Jim Sturgess), the scholar aforementioned, is the principal male character in One Day and he has a vague recollection that there is such a legend. Also that it is somehow associated with the weather. More than that, however, he cannot say when he meets Emma (Anne Hathaway) on St. Swithun's day (July 15th), 1988, after a night of revelry ensuing upon their graduation from Edinburgh University. I'm only guessing here, mind you, but I think that David Nicholls, adapting his own best-selling novel for the screen, and director Lone Scherfig (An Education, Italian for Beginners) were thinking that Dexter would be more charming for forgetting (he is also drunk) than he would be for remembering. Bad call. At any rate, I don't find him so, nor do I find him otherwise very prepossessing. In fact, he is little better than a lout, and by the time I saw him (inevitably) educated out of his loutishness, it was too late for me, at any rate, to feel much sympathy for him.

You may find it otherwise and therefore may enjoy One Day more than I did, but Dexter's charmlessness is only part of the reason I didn't much care for the picture myself. There is a formula for romantic tear-jerkers, and One Day constantly reminds you of the fact by not entirely sticking to the formula for no very good reason. By formula, that is, Miss Hathaway's character should be plain, or plainish (as she is in the novel) -- at least not the luminous beauty Miss Scherfig must have known Anne Hathaway to be when she cast her in the role of Emma. Likewise by formula Mr. Sturgess's character should be a likeable rogue and wastrel and not the boringly superficial sot, cokehead and celebrity-wannabe he is. Most importantly, the friendship between them has to be persuasive. We have to see what they see in each other. That's where the charm would come in, if Dexter had any, and where the interesting character foibles of Emma would tell, if she had any.

But both are nearly opaque as characters. Emma is supposed to have poetic ambitions, but we hear almost nothing of her poetry -- or even of what she admires in others'poetry -- or her prose either when she turns out to be a (naturally successful) writer of fiction. Clearly, she is meant to be pining for Dexter for more than a decade, but Anne Hathaway doesn't really do pining. Or even smothered longing. I don't so much mind her poor Yorkshire accent, which seems to have all of Britain up in arms. I just assumed that she was meant to be affecting the classless, regionless version of mockney (with lapses into both received and regional pronunciation that also seem authentic) that was so popular among the young in the 1990s. But her more general rootlessness seems to go with an emotional affectlessness that make the film's big moments quite surprising and rather incomprehensible when they come.

One result is that when she abandons her perfect French lover, Jean Pierre (Sébastien Dupuis), for Dexter at his lowest ebb we can only wonder what she is thinking. Or smoking, perhaps, since Jean Pierre is a jazz musician. She sees very clearly what a bum Dexter is but doesn't allow us to see anything in her that would explain her fatal attachment to such a bum. Nor is Dexter's own emotional trajectory any more comprehensible. After ageing out of a job hosting what the film calls "car-crash television" with all the sex and drugs supposed to go with it, he apparently lacks any emotional or intellectual hinterland which could account for his lingering attachment to this budding literary superstar as not only his preferred shoulder to cry on but the woman finally to de-bimbify his hectic love-life.

Actually, it's Romola Garai who gets that job anyway, before she grows as bored with the presumptively reformed Dex as we already are with the pre-reformation model -- which is another example of the film's pointless departure from formula. So Emma is the love of his life but she's also picked up on the rebound? There's a modern romance for you! For some, perhaps, these deficiencies will be compensated for by the heart-tugging ending, although that would be pretty emotionally manipulative even if everything else about the movie were perfect. Which it very much is not. Nor can the gimmicky device of tracing the relationship between Dex and Emma through 20-plus years of St. Swithun's days make up for the failure to turn them into characters we are able to care very much about.

There are good things about the movie. Patricia Clarkson as Dexter's mum is dying of cancer much more nobly than she was in Pieces of April (2003), and Ken Stott as his dad has some excellent pieces of advice for his wayward son, apart from seeming a much more interesting person. Rafe Spall as Emma's stop-gap boyfriend Ian has a little of the goofy loser's charm that we miss in Dexter, but he, too, is rather tiresome in the end, in addition to being so obviously not right for Emma. The chance to tap into the market for nostalgia by tying the story to the one we all know of the last couple of decades might or might not be a good thing, but it is almost completely missed anyway. And for what? For very little in the way of characterization and not even very many laughs. I have not St. Swithun's prognosticatory powers but I foresee a flopperoo -- which makes me sad for Miss Scherfig, who has shown signs of being a fine director.

About the Author

James Bowman, our movie and culture critic, is a resident scholar at the Ethics and Public Policy Center. He is the author of Honor: A History and Media Madness: The Corruption of Our Political Culture, both published by Encounter Books.

Letter to the Editor View all comments (9) | Leave a comment

Stuart Koehl| 8.29.11 @ 7:26AM

Consider it our revenge for all those English actors affecting bad American accents--particularly of the Southern or Texan variety.

Occam's Tool| 8.29.11 @ 4:19PM

Yeah-yuh.

Cosmo| 8.30.11 @ 3:24AM

This gets a 34% rating on Fresh Tomatoes...
If you want to see a good movie, try these:

Sholem Aleichem: Laughing in the Darkness 100%

Mendy Cahan, Bel Kaufman, Hillel Halkin, Sheldon Harnick
A riveting portrait of the great writer whose stories became the basis of the Broadway musical Fiddler on the Roof. Sholem Aleichem: Laughing in the Darkness tells the tale of the rebellious genius who created an entirely new literature. Plumbing the… More

The Interrupters 100%

Eddie Bocanegra, Ameena Matthews, Ricardo Williams, Tio Hardiman
The Interrupters tells the moving and surprising stories of three Violence Interrupters who try to protect their Chicago communities from the violence they once employed. From acclaimed director Steve James and bestselling author Alex Kotlowitz, this… More

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows - Part 297%

Daniel Radcliffe, Rupert Grint, Emma Watson, Helena Bonham Carter
Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows - Part 2, is the final adventure in the Harry Potter film series. The much-anticipated motion picture event is the second of two full-length parts. In the epic finale, the battle between the good and evil forces… More

Project Nim

Garry Harris, Stephanie Lafarge, Jenny Lee Wright, Laura Ann Petitto
From the team behind Man on Wire comes the story of Nim, the chimpanzee who in the 1970s became the focus of a landmark experiment which aimed to show that an ape could learn to communicate with language if raised and nurtured like a human child.… More

One Lucky Elephant

Where does an elephant go after a life in the circus? Sixteen years have passed since circus producer David Balding adopted Flora, the orphaned baby African elephant. As Flora approaches adulthood, he realizes that she is not happy performing.… More

The Guard

Brendan Gleeson, Don Cheadle, Liam Cunningham, David Wilmot
The Guard is a comedic fish-out-of-water tale of murder, blackmail, drug trafficking and rural police corruption. Two policemen must join forces to take on an international drug- smuggling gang - one, an unorthodox Irish policeman and the other, a… More

Le Rayon vert (The Green Ray)

Marie Rivière, Amira Chemakhi, Sylvie Richez, Maria Luisa Garcia
Summer (Le Rayon Vert) is the fifth of French director Eric Rohmer's Comedies et Proverbes movie cycle. Left out of everyone's Summer vacation plans, unhappy Parisian student Marie Riviere (Rohmer's star in all of the Comedies et Proverbes) accepts… More

Tales from the Golden Age

Alexandru Potocean, Teo Corban, Emanuel Pirvu, Avram Birau
The final 15 years of the Ceausescu regime were the worst in Romania's history. Nonetheless, the propaganda machine of that time referred without fail to that period as "the golden age"... Tales from the Golden Age adapts for screen the most popular… More

Point Blank

Gilles Lellouche, Roschdy Zem, Gérard Lanvin, Elena Anaya
Produced by Cyril Colbeau-Justin and Jean-Baptiste Dupont, Point Blank also stars Roschdy Zem, Gerard Lanvin and Elena Anaya. Gilles Lellouche plays Samuel, a nurse working at a hospital when his pregnant wife (Anaya) is kidnapped before his very… More

Crime After Crime

Deborah Peagler, Joshua Safran, Nadia Costa, Steve Cooley
Crime After Crime is the exclusive documentary film on the legal battle to free Debbie Peagler, a woman imprisoned for over a quarter century due to her connection to the murder of the man who abused her. She finds her only hope for freedom when two… More

Senna

Ayrton Senna, Reginaldo Leme, Richard Williams, John Bisignano
Spanning his years as a Formula One racing driver from 1984 to his untimely death a decade later, Senna explores the life and work of the triple world champion, his physical and spiritual achievements on the track, his quest for perfection and the… More

Love Exposure

Takahiro Nishijima, Hikari Mitsushima, Sakura Ando, Makiko Watanabe
Tokyo teen Yu Honda (Takahiro Nishijima) is the traumatized son of a widower-cum-Catholic priest (Atsuro Watabe), who begins a sexual liaison with parishioner Kaori (Makiko Watanabe). When Dad's affair comes to a halt, he begins admonishing his son… More

Midnight in Paris

Owen Wilson, Marion Cotillard, Rachel McAdams, Kathy Bates
This is a romantic comedy set in Paris about a family that goes there because of business, and two young people who are engaged to be married in the fall have experiences there that change their lives. It's about a young man's great love for a city,… More

Beats, Rhymes and Life: The Travels of A Tribe Called Quest

Q-Tip, Phife Dawg, Ali Shaheed Muhammad, Jarobi White
A documentary film directed by Michael Rapaport about one of the most influential and groundbreaking musical groups in hip-hop history. Having released five gold and platinum selling albums within eight years, A Tribe Called Quest has been one of the… More

Tabloid

Joyce McKinney, Jackson Shaw, Peter Tory, Troy Williams
Thirty years before the antics of Lindsay Lohan and Britney Spears were regular gossip fodder, Miss Wyoming Joyce McKinney made her mark as a tabloid staple ne plus ultra. Morris follows the salacious adventures of this beauty queen with an IQ of 168… More

MIKE HARRIS| 8.29.11 @ 8:39AM

Eee, bai gum, lad. Appen that their 'athaway mare's a reet southern softie. Nair bin north o' Sheffield, ah'll be bound. Bet she's nair tekken 'er clogs off after 'ard shift in't pit, reet reddy fer 'er soak in a tin bath afront o' feer. Nair experience, y'ken?

sinanju| 8.29.11 @ 10:41AM

Apropos accents, I'd like to give honorable mention to Lisa Eichhorn who did a few movie parts early on, then settled into a long and steady career in TV and made-for-TV roles that continues to this day.

She co-starred opposite the pre-"American Gigolo" Richard Gere in the forgotten classic "Yanks" (1979) about the U.S. "occupation" of wartime Britain ("overpaid, oversexed and over here"). From recently reading the user reviews of the movie on IMDB.com it seems her Lancashire accent was so convincing that many natives of Northern England thought she was one of their own for decades.

As for the movie in question? Well, after reading your review, if we get to see Anne and Romola's naughty bits, I might be persuaded, otherwise...

loulou| 8.29.11 @ 1:53PM

Why waste space writing about a stupid romcom?

heredress| 8.30.11 @ 12:13AM

I like her, the sexy lips. few scandal of her, so i will support her for a long time

Jack| 8.30.11 @ 4:24AM

Laughing in the Darkness tells the tale of the rebellious genius who created an entirely new literature. Plumbing the… More
best oakley sunglasses
http://www.wholesalehatsshop.com
Thanks

Jack| 8.30.11 @ 4:27AM

Sholem Aleichem: Laughing in the Darkness tells the tale of the rebellious genius who created an entirely new literature. Plumbing the… More
ray ban aviator sunglasses
http://www.topbrandsbags.com