Be patient, I’ll get to Sheriff Dupnik and Rush Limbaugh and all
that in due time, but first I want to testify to a miracle I
experienced in my personal life. This was back in 1990. I was a
lecturer in Jewish Studies at a university in Jerusalem, and one of
my classes was entitled Contemporary Relevance of Talmud. My
students were young American products of public education who
naturally assumed the Talmud was a relic. But the age difference
between us was not pronounced — I was 32 and they were juniors, 20
or 21 — so they were very open to what I had to say, and the
give-and-take usually sparkled.
On this particular day I was arguing that even when the
Talmud discussed a subject no longer relevant, its moral insights
and legal analysis are still useful today. As an example, I cited
the story (Kiddushin 70a) of the fellow who insulted Rabbi Judah,
calling him a “slave.” The rabbi responded: “He who disqualifies
others generally accuses them of his own flaw.” “I’m no slave,”
scoffed the man. “I am a descendant of the Maccabees, the Hasmonean
royal line from the Second Temple period!”
“It is just as I said!” exclaimed Rabbi Judah. This man
had not known the history of Herod’s slave rebellion against the
Hasmoneans. Herod killed every member of the family except for one
beautiful daughter he wanted to marry. She went up to the roof and
cried: “Whoever claims to be a Hasmonean is really a slave!” Then
she jumped to her death. So there are no descendants of the
Maccabees, only descendants of murderous slaves pretending to be
the family they massacred. The man who had slandered Rabbi Judah
with the epithet of “slave” turned out to be one
himself.
You see, I told the class, the part about the Maccabees
may no longer be relevant. Who is going to show up fifteen hundred
years later claiming to be a Maccabee? But the moral message
remains very powerful: people who hurl insults are generally guilty
of those very accusations.
Suddenly a kid jumps up out of his seat and shouts:
“You’re saying the Maccabees were wiped out?”
“Yes.”
“I’m in the middle of reading Armand Hammer’s biography.
He says his family has a tradition that they are descended from
Judah the Maccabee, which is why their name is Hammer, since Maccab
is Hebrew for hammer.” I excused him to go to his dorm room and
bring back the book.
Sure enough, it was just as he described. Armand Hammer, the famous
head of Occidental Petroleum (and Russian spy), had unwittingly
revealed he was heir to a murderous legacy.
At that moment I made a personal resolution never to make
statements impugning the relevance of the Talmud on any level. A
hand had reached down from Heaven to give me a loving
spank.
TO CURRENT EVENTS, THEN, applying the timeless wisdom
above. Everyone has been following the remarks of Sheriff Dupnik
blaming the “hard right rhetoric” for the nutcase who shot a Jewish
Congresswoman in Arizona. This despite his referencing The
Communist Manifesto in his rants and despite evidence he
has been stalking his target since 2007, long before the Obama Era.
When Limbaugh slammed Dupnik for unseemly speculation, Dupnik shot
back that Limbaugh was generally irresponsible in inflaming the
public with half-truths and that we were seeing the
consequences.
All this is well known and being kicked back and forth
between liberal and conservative commentators. Michelle Malkin on
her blog has compiled a stunning array of left-wing hate speech and
imagery against George W. Bush, Sarah Palin and the Tea Party. It
becomes clear to anyone willing to look at this closely that on
balance the left is more guilty in this area. If Price-Waterhouse
was brought in to do an impartial third-party audit, the numbers
would come down heavily against the left. This in turn discredits
all these liberal hacks in their blamefest.
But the point I want to make is more powerful. It is not
merely that Limbaugh beats Dupnik on points, so Dupnik should have
the sense to shut his mouth. It is much more than that. We are
witnessing the Talmudic dictum come to life before our eyes in a
manner reminiscent of the student who brought me Armand Hammer’s
book.
Because in point of actual fact the truth is the OPPOSITE
of what Dupnik asserts, and startlingly so. Think about it.
Limbaugh has been on the air for twenty-two years. He has been
espousing a point of view with passion and emphasis to millions of
people five days a week. He has been frank in exposing the
shortcomings of the opposing view. Yet not one single act of
violence during that time has ever been attributed to a person
identified as one of his regular listeners. NOT ONE SINGLE
ACT!
This was a period that included the Oklahoma City
bombings, the Olympic bombings, Columbine (Colorado), the
Unabomber, the anthrax mailings, the Virginia Tech shootings, the
Capitol Police attack, the Arizona train derailment, Paducah
(Kentucky), the Amish killing rampage, Pearl (Mississippi), Fort
Hood, the Arkansas military recruiter, Springfield (Oregon), the
abortionist killed in Wichita, the abortionist killed in Buffalo,
the Haley-Bopp Comet cult, the fire at Freddie’s, the Crown Heights
riots, the D.C. sniper, the IRS kamikaze plane, etc. The list goes
on and on.
Many of these murderers were discovered to have materials
from Karl Marx. Al Gore, Al Sharpton and a whole array of fringe
characters. Yet never once has one of these explosive acts of
violence been traced to a Rush Limbaugh listener. That is a
stunning fact in its own right, almost miraculous really. One could
hardly fault him if here or there a fevered acolyte pursued his
impetus beyond equipoise. But no… never even one single solitary
time in twenty-two years!
The pro-Constitution, pro-liberty voices on the air do not
promote upheaval. They promote a vision of liberty to pursue
dreams. Healthy dreams, my friends, not twisted fantasies; ballots,
not bullets.
hugh bnyn| 1.12.11 @ 6:43AM
---and in all of this horror not a word about the creepy, pervasive directive control of Luciferian
Freemasonry throughout government, banking,
medicine and education.
Occult and Luciferian images, symbols, tropes
and props saturata DC and every state capital,
and virtually the entire corporate world.
AS the very deep and actual nature of the occult
in the upper reaches of 'secular' power ---unchecked for decades, even centuries ---becomes apparent, and as they've responded
by rampantaly promoting the occult through
our phoney created 'pop culture' ---WHY isn't
this a matter of unbiquitous discussion and
concern.
Seperation of Church and State!
Freemasonry is, by any definition and its ownb
admission ---a relgion. At its upper levels it IS
Luciferian, and even in its show-window bows
to Christianity it's purre Arminian Heresy
---at best.
Booger | 1.12.11 @ 7:33AM
From the desk of D. Mephistopheles, Attorney-at-Law:
Dear President Obama,
I must admit, I am greatly pleased to see that the recent events in Arizona are having their desired results. Of course you were unaware of my machinations on your behalf, but that must often be the case. Consider it "plausible deniability", a term with which I believe you are well familiar. After all, whenever innocent blood is shed, you can trust that someone from my firm has been at work. And please, whatever face you wish to put on for your adoring public, do not play coy with me. We have known each other far too well for far too long.
So, now that I have delivered your crisis, what are you going to do with it? I see my trusty servant Sheriff Dupnik is as reliable as ever. Observe him and learn. See how he attacks his enemies without hesitation? Does he allow his ridiculous "oath of office" to deter him? Does he adhere to some pathetic notion of "honor" or "ethics" that constrains his speech? Does he concern himself with his "responsibilities" as an "office of the law" in a time such as this? No, of course not! He is a true man, exercising his will to power without concern for the weak and stupid whom he bends to his will. If you are to be a true Great Leader then you must become like him!
Now is the time to attack. Do not wait, do not hesitate. The reigns of power are in your hands. When my Austrian henchman saw the Reichstag burning, do you think he hesitated? Of course not; his enemies were being executed in the streets and in their beds within days. Why then do you wait? Do you not know that he who hesitates is lost? Quit taking so much time to think, and simply act! I will do the thinking for you, you must do the acting for me. Those are the terms of our agreement, and the rules which bind both of us.
I assure you, I can deliver opportunities of this nature to you only so often, and at great cost and effort to my firm. If you squander them, we will take our services elsewhere. I do not say this to threaten you (although you well know what my superiors lower down in this firm are capable of) but to remind you of your obligations to us and to yourself. Do you want to be the One True Messiah that your faithful followers long for? Do you want to be a God on earth, as even your journalists have proclaimed you to be? Then you must act the part. I have given you the excuse, now you must take the action.
Let me add further, that if you will act on this opportunity, then it affords me the power that I need to create more opportunities for you. Do not be afraid, I will never betray you or let you down! Every time you seize one of the opportunities I give you, I am made stronger, and can provide more of the same bloodshed necessary for your advancement. Remember, you can't make an omelet without breaking a few eggs.
So the choice is yours, my friend. Muzzle the press. Repeal the "freedoms" your bitter countrymen so foolishly hold dear and cling to. Once you have taken their freedom, then you can usher in the New Age and your Great Plan. Once you give your full obeisance to me, I can fully empower you to be the God of your world. But you must strip your countrymen of their freedom, and more especially of their love for their freedom. Only when you do this can our common goals be fully realized. So strike now to silence those who oppose you, and show yourself to be worthy of my devotion.
Your friend and mentor,
D. Mephistopheles, Attorney-at-Law
http://beautifulletters-bls.blogspot.com/
ironhorzmn| 1.14.11 @ 6:55PM
Awesome. Simply awesome. C S Lewis would be proud.
Jeremiah| 1.12.11 @ 6:48AM
The Talmudic example you so marvelously cite runs deeper than you say on this subject. Over the last few decades, it is the left which has publicly fantasized about actually murdering political opponents. They usually dismiss it as a 'joke' or 'art.' Remember Alec Baldwin's rant hoping people would storm Henry Hyde and murder him and his family during the impeachment hearings? When Craig Kilborn flashed a sign saying, "Snipers Wanted" over a phtoto of George W. Bush on CBS? When John Kerry joked with Bill Maher about going to the White House and murdering Pres. Bush for his (Kerry's) wife's birthday in 2006? The multiple Bush assassination novels and movies? The hanging effigy of Sarah Palin that was all the rage in Hollywood during the 2008 election? I could go on, but what's the point?
Here's a point, on the rare occasions the left is actually called on it by someone, they always chuckle and say something like, "take a joke." The rest of the lefties gather round and either defend the offender or remain silent. When does a leftie publicly rebuke another for such murderous fantasies? The only thing I can think of that is even close is when Mayor Daley rebuked Sen. Dick Durbin for calling our troops Nazis and war criminals.
For the left, actually calling for the murder of a conservative opponent is not hate speech; but to oppose Obamacare, huge taxes and spending, bailouts, govt. takeovers of the internet, car companies, banks, etc. is hate speech that must be stopped. The left is engaging in a vast projection of their own sick pathology onto us.
But despite all the sound and fury, I fear we are quietly approaching a terrible Rubicon. In earlier episodes of leftists exploiting a tragedy to smear us, we have reacted defensively -we were in shock anyone could think that way and reacted without understanding they were just calling us names.
Now they do it for the umpteenth time and we push back. We think they are up to their usual name-calling. I think it is a dress rehearsal for something far worse. The left has lost the public debate. It is losing target groups among its base. It is losing ground on every front. So it seeks to govern by executive fiat, by calls to further proscribe political speech, to control talk radio, to take control of the internet, to charge global-warming 'deniers' with treason while treating actual treason as the 'highest form of patriotism.' Look carefully at the pathologies the left's public statements and public fantasies and actions have revealed over the last two decades. They're not just calling us names this time: they are ginning up the nerve to use the levers of gov't for actual oppression and command; to outlaw Christianity and general conservative thought as 'hate speech.' We are in for a very rough ride the next two years. I don't have much confidence our GOP Congress will even understand the stakes as they 'compromise' with people who are determined to enslave America.
They are not just calling us names this time. They are building the nerve to start coming for us and for our freedom. They are preparing to make their fantasies our reality.
Sea_Hunter| 1.12.11 @ 8:02AM
Jeremiah: There is a rule is social discourse that I believe goes back as far as the ancient Greeks. It is called consent through silence. To dismiss their own comments, or to remain silent about them is a consent through their silence to their own rants.
I can not consent to violence. Through violence we are far more likely to end this country with a Robespierre than a Ragan. I can not agree with you more, the hate speach from the left is driving this country to violence far more than Beck or Limbaugh ever have, or ever will. And that truly scares me. It frightens me to believe that violence is actually the lefts intent.
Anthony| 1.12.11 @ 11:16AM
Jeremiah, You are right. America is indeed at a loggerhead. We have two diametrically opposed theories of government that are competing for the future of America.
The left is brazen enough now to actually call it by its actual name, socialism and redistributive social justice, and they are on the move, as you've pointed out.
We call it a Constitutional representative government, which the left deems to be archatic, a thing of the past, from a document that's over 200 years old, that nobody can understand.
As I've said before, there is no compromise here, no "move to the middle".
Our leaders, such as they are, are a sorry sort, save for a few, they are completely unable to lead America from the brink, because almost every D in Washington is a hard core socialist.
Many Rs are equally clueless and have no vision other than how to get re-elected , as demonstrated by the lunacy of legislation coming from the likes of Messrs. King and Burton. This is what passes for leadership in America today. We Americans are responsible for electing these professional political losers. We will pay a horrible price for our neglect.
So, which side will give? That is the question. And if indeed there is no "give", which appears to be the case, what is outcome?
I'm afraid the band has been streached to its limit. Soon something will have to give and that process will be ugly.
Nunya| 1.12.11 @ 3:09PM
Jeremiah, Hunter, Anthony: Excellent posts, all.
I agree with all of you, we are fast coming to a crossroads, and it's not going to be pretty. I will also add to the mix that I think our economy is headed for a second dip (think Great Depression), though I may be a bit cynical on that matter. Regardless, a worsening or stagnant economic climate compounded by worsening political climate and more strident calls from the extremes of both sides will only make matters worse (and BTW, I don't consider Rush, Beck, Hannity, et al, to be extreme by any stretch of the imagination; however, there ARE people on the right calling for armed insurrection, one can find them on the internet).
I agree with Hunter that there are those on the Left that really do want this, because it will serve their purpose of ever-increasing governmental control--sending in the military to control a potential insurrection, for example. Or possibly more laws to control those of us who speak out against their taking of more and more liberties ("hate speech" comes to mind--whatever happened to "sticks and stones can break my bones but words will never hurt me"?) Continually expanding governmental control over communications, etc., trying to control every aspect of our lives, and all the while acting superior to the rest of us as if we are nothing but peasants (the Ruling Class mentality).
Anyway, I say we need to pray for the best and prepare for the worst--and VOTE. Every election, every time we get a chance. This is our best bet to recover our Republic.
Bill Hussein O'Stalin| 1.12.11 @ 7:02AM
The facts are beginning to indicate that Dupnik is an incompetent stooge who was simply pontificating to cover up the fact that Loughner was never arrested after threatening to kill multiple people.
Old Soldier| 1.12.11 @ 11:18AM
Exactly what I was thinking. While he was busy being a politician, law enforcement was dropping the ball. The reason the shooter was able to buy - the Sheriff's Department never entered this guy in the system.
Blame everyone else to obscure the real culprits.
Blame everyone else to obscure the real culprits.
Dai Alanye | 1.12.11 @ 1:07PM
In all seriousness, this dupe Dupenik has primary moral and legal responsibility for the utter failure of his department to protect the public from a known violent psychotic. Dupenik appears wide open to a charge of nonfeasance if not malfeasance. In addition, every victim or family member should be consulting with a lawyer about a civil suit against Dupenik and Pima County
Bill Hussein O'Stalin| 1.12.11 @ 7:02AM
The facts are beginning to indicate that Dupnik is an incompetent stooge who was simply pontificating to cover up the fact that Loughner was never arrested after threatening to kill multiple people.
Bill Hussein O'Stalin| 1.12.11 @ 7:02AM
The facts are beginning to indicate that Dupnik is an incompetent stooge who was simply pontificating to cover up the fact that Loughner was never arrested after threatening to kill multiple people.
Clint| 1.12.11 @ 7:42AM
What did Sheriff Dupnik know and when did he know it ?
http://thechollajumps.wordpress.com/
Nancy in NC| 1.12.11 @ 7:52AM
I think Dupenik (error intentional) is attempting the divert the question: how did this nutcase buy a gun? In NC the sherriff issues gun permits after a thorough background check.
His diversion keeps anyone from looking too closely as to why this guy had no record even though he had several run ins with the law. Dupenik knows he dropped the ball.
Lazy Jack | 1.12.11 @ 7:52AM
In terms of inflamatory commentary, didn't Mark Penn, the deomocratic pollster, recently say that Obama needed another Oklahoma City to reconnect to the people?
Though this tragedy is smaller in scale, apparently Mark Penn got his wish. So did an apparent majority of the media and the Demoratic Party. Tell the lie often and loud enough and it becomes...
Nice Job Keeping the rhetoric rational, Mark. Of course, it is all the right wing media that is the problem.
To the left: Methinks though doth protest too much.
See it here.
http://biggovernment.com/eyebl.....reconnect/
Lazy Jack,
www.thanksforthelaughs.wordpress.com
Occam's Tool| 1.12.11 @ 2:05PM
The explanation for this whole sad affair can be found in one court case: Riese versus St. Mary's. A "triumph" of American Law.
RCV| 1.13.11 @ 4:43PM
Fully agree. Reise was a travesty and a tragedy. What's even worse is that the APA filed an amicus brief in the case arguing for the "right" of involuntarily committed psychotics to refuse medication.
Occam's Tool| 1.28.11 @ 7:16PM
Which APA? Psychologists or Psychiatrists? If it was psychiatrists, then I'm glad I gave up my membership years ago. I expect the psychologists to do that---it's called politics.
AFreemason| 1.13.11 @ 4:01PM
What drivel!
Quartermaster| 1.12.11 @ 1:46PM
"even in its show-window bows
to Christianity it's purre Arminian Heresy
---at best."
Those who bandy teh term "Arminian Heresy" so glibly, normally have no idea whereof they speak. They are also accusing the early Church of Heresy as Calvin's Neoplatonist aberrations were unknown even to Augustine.
Clint| 1.12.11 @ 8:01AM
We Tea Party Rebels Got Rush limbaugh's Back.
"* 6 deaths attributed to the shooting. 19 total people hit by gunfire.
* suspect’s mother works for the Pima County Board of Supervisors
* the suspect has multiple arrests … But no criminal record? Intervention by someone?"
It appears there's been a cover up.
We Tea Party Patriots Want Sheriff Dupnik's Resignation.
Occam's Tool| 1.28.11 @ 7:21PM
Dear Clint/Tim*: a lot of the time, the local gendarmes won't even bother filing charges against anyone with a psychiatric record, which diminishes the ability of psychiatrists to a) commit that person or b) arrange for a forensic psychiatry hospitalization.
It may be a dereliction of duty without overt corruption. But it still is dereliction of duty.
Louis Jenkins| 1.12.11 @ 8:23AM
Well, Dupnik may not resign, but I'm interested in who will be his successor next election. Let's face it Dupnik, you dropped the ball. You're the one with egg on his face, you're the one who literally shot himself in the foot. Were was your security? (Crickets chirping.) But oh, don't forget, there's plenty of public radio personalities out there to attack. Remove the personal blame and place it somewhere else, after all, that's what all the liberals do isn't it.
DCD-in-Indian| 1.12.11 @ 8:42AM
When did George Soros get elected sheriff of Pima County?
Anthony| 1.12.11 @ 8:57AM
Dupnick is the Mike Nifong of Arizona. He appears to be a Democrat hack with a penchant for this sort of rhetotic.
Since Dupnick knew of this kid since 2007, long before Sarah Palin and the Tea Party, and apparently never connected the dots, Dupnick knew that eventually real journalists would be checking out his record.
So like all good D hacks, Dupnick came out swinging at Rs and conservatives, hence providing himself cover with the "corrupt bastards" in the MSM, who of course, have obliged thus far.
No questions from Katie or Tom on why Dupnick didn't take action sooner. MSLSD, led by Matthews and Olberman, will continue to foam at the mouth over Palin and Limbaugh.
However, Dupnick's record will soon come out on this kid, and all of lefty media types won't be able to put Humpty Dupnick back together again.
I'd try to take over the gig at the Ed Show on MSLSD if I were you Dupnick. The pay's good and the audience size about that of your county.
loulou| 1.12.11 @ 11:20AM
"Dupnick is the Mike Nifong of Arizona." I like that. Whatever became of Nifong? Is he in jail?
Dupnick went on the offense immediately in order to distract attention from his failure to handle the Loughner problem which was brewing for years.
Anthony| 1.12.11 @ 11:26AM
I don't think so, if memory serves, Nifong served like 24 hours and was released on probation.
Quartermaster| 1.12.11 @ 1:48PM
Nifong was disbarred and has gone to a well deserved obscurity. NC has a wealth of other prosecutors, however, that are just like him and deserve the same fate.
Ezra Klein| 1.12.11 @ 10:02AM
I don't understand why Jay is talking about the Talmud in this post. IIRC, the Talmud is more than 100 years old and no one today can possibly understand what the writer(s) meant to say.
cuban pete| 1.12.11 @ 11:10AM
Nice shot, Ezra
Ted| 1.12.11 @ 12:13PM
That was awfully funny. Kudos!
Gary| 1.12.11 @ 10:06AM
Someone should have asked Dubnik what percentage of the blame for the shootings should rest with the shooter. Is it 100%, 75%, 50%, 25%. Really, sheriff, what number are you willing to lay on the shooter?
loulou| 1.12.11 @ 11:17AM
I'm still perplexed that this sheriff, who looks like a 90 yr old drunk, has managed to be elected. What is it with the people of Pima County?
Appleby| 1.12.11 @ 11:34AM
In my childhood there was a common schoolyard taunt that followed this kind of name-calling and finger-pointing: "I know you are -- but what am I?"
Girls usually used the long version: "I am rubber, you are glue, what you say bounces off me and sticks to you!"
hunter| 1.12.11 @ 12:27PM
I'd vote for Barney Fife before I'd vote for dupnik
Richard Baker| 1.12.11 @ 12:29PM
hugh bnyn:
Do we need to call the Police on you or should the Masons kill a goat on your doorstep? Loopy-do! The Sheriff is nutso himself. Next election, the citizens of Pima County need to discharge this wacko.
Richard Baker| 1.12.11 @ 1:05PM
By the way, this "Sheriff" has access to firearms?
MikeD| 1.12.11 @ 1:25PM
Just another dem doing what dems do!
Anthony| 1.12.11 @ 1:44PM
Hey Dupnick, release the file your office has on this shooter. What are you hiding?
That was a rhetorical question,we know what you're hiding.
Get your resume updated buddy, maybe you can get a job with the expanded Capitol Police, or, perhaps, you can become head of security for the offices of MSLSD.
It appears you just Nifonged your career in Arizona.
loulou| 1.12.11 @ 3:44PM
It looks to me like Dupnik has one foot in the grave (no, I'm not suggesting anything) so why should he even need a resume? The guy looks decrepit and must be past retirement age.
Clint| 1.12.11 @ 1:55PM
Sheriff Dupnik and Pima County are Covering Up !
Multiple Arrests - No Police Record - Mom Works for Pima County Supervisors.
Shoes Will Drop.
Jullou| 1.12.11 @ 2:56PM
FBI: Please investigate Dupnik. We must find out what when wrong!
JonBoy| 1.12.11 @ 3:48PM
Regarding how Dupnik is elected each year:
I've lived in Tucson (Pima Co.) for 30 years and have come to understand that we are the liberal bastion in a predominately Republican conservative state. It is well known here that if you run for election in Tucson and have a "D" after your name, you are going to win, no matter how brilliant the "R" opponent may be. Our city elections are so rigged that the individual ward representations are voted by the entire city and not the specific ward. I live in a predominately republican ward and I am represented by a Democrat councilman. Dupnik ran against a real qualified republican candidate last election cycle but as always the Ds vote like lemmings and once again we get good ol Clarence and the likes of Raul Grijalva. No one will ask for his resignation or mount a recall because he is part of the liberal club here in Tucson. And you thought all Arizonans were republican conservatives.
Hope this clears up your wonderings.
Nite| 1.12.11 @ 9:35PM
I was a Democrat for many years, and my husband still is one. I became a Republican about 20 years ago, when the Democrat party started moving so far left. My husband votes Democrat in the primary, but Republican in the general election. People who continue to vote for these liberal lefties deserve what they get in the area of tax and spend, with cities and states going broke because of the Socialistic programs.
Liberals are entitled to their beliefs, but don't try to shove them down my throat.
REB| 1.12.11 @ 10:35PM
Dupnick...methinks thou dost protest too much!
GKPAL| 1.13.11 @ 11:28AM
This guy Dupenick must be run out of town ASAP. He is a disgrace. Who the hell elect this idiot and give him a gun?
sex toys | 7.4.11 @ 1:10AM
Hey I pair your style I instrument concur for your take gratify remain transmitting!
Thanks
Adidas | 8.11.11 @ 5:44AM
is good
العاب | 4.10.12 @ 12:55PM
is good