The American Spectator

home
ADVERTISEMENT
Reader Mail
Print Email
Text Size

Reader Mail

Presidents and Generals

MacArthur and McChrystal. Clark and Ridgeway. Algerian and French birthrates. Sean Penn and Hugo Chavez. Ben Stein and BP, and more!

(Page 4 of 4)

The wages of the media not vetting an unknown presidential candidate is Obama.
— James

BAD POLITICS, BAD MOVIES
Re: Robert P. Kirchhoefer’s Hugo Boss:

The only thing that makes sense is that Chavez bad-mouthed our president in our country, and these latter-day hippies, some of whom worshipped Manson, love “a cause.” Aside from that, these overpaid, under-talented trolls, whose only ideas for films these days seem to be comic-book heroes, need to be considered for the frauds they truly are, and not seeing their sub-standard movies, is a good start. I recommend foreign films, many of which actually have a theme, and are well-acted to boot! I don’t think the American version of Girl With the Dragon Tattoo with Brad Pitt as a Swedish journalist, will come close to the Swedish film.
— Bob Mandraccia

POWER OF NEGOTIATION
Re: Ben Stein’s Our Caudillo President:

“Of course, every President tries “jawboning” to restrain steel company price increases or something similar..”

Not every action requires a law, or government intervention. That’s the power of negotiation for voluntary cooperation toward a common, win-win objective. Win for BP: concerns are allayed that, when it stops making business sense for BP to continue spending money on the project, it will just cash in its chips and go home. BP gets to demonstrate its commitment to doing right by those damaged by the spill. Win for the public: There will be enough money, administered by an independent party, to pay claims of damages. In the long run, BP’s decisions are good for all but those of its investors interested in short term gains.
— Jim

As usual, Mr. Stein cuts through the emotional fog of an issue and sees the long-term Constitutional consequences of political imprudence and folly. What has happened to adherence to the Constitution? It is not a document from which one can selectively cherry-pick or ignore as it suits one’s whims. It applies to all in all cases and for all time.

I hear and see both liberals and conservatives applauding Obama’s shakedown of BP, and with BP transferring assets, it might prove the only way to protect Gulf environs’ chances for timely compensation, but Obama’s rapid fire extra-constitutional actions are frightening. I would rather see the Gulf of Mexico turned into a sludge pond than see the Constitution destroyed.
— Mike Steele
Midway, Georgia

BLISS
Re: Ron Ross’s Ignorance Is Liberal Bliss:

Absolutely brilliant!
— Bob Stange

Page: ‹ First   2 34

Letter to the Editor View all comments (4) |

Quartermaster| 6.25.10 @ 7:25PM

Santore needs to get out more. Mac's reputation has been well know for many years. The reputation that Santore and his ilk wish to create, that's recent and getting around a bit. So far his own memoirs, and William Manchester's biography have been around for quite a while, and Manchester, who hated MacArthur, ended up writing a fair and balanced book about the man, and doing a good job to boot.

"Braying" something left does constantly. MacArthur had no need to do so. he also had no need to be arrogant. His actions spoke loudly, and well. He served his country, under harsh conditions when Truman couldn't make up his mind what to do, until he fell in with the Kansas City political machine.

While Truman was withing his rights to relieve MacArthur, he was wrong to refuse support sufficient to win in Korea. Truman betrayed the men on the ground by refusing that support, and by tolerating Soviet agents who passed everything they could get from Korea onto Moscow.

That, Mr. Santore, is why MacArthur keeps winning, and history judges the failed Haberdasher and National Guard Arty Captain as a failure.

More Articles From Reader Mail

http://spectator.org/archives/2010/06/25/loquacious-generals

ADVERTISEMENT

SPONSORED LINKS

FLASHBACK TO: 1995

Clip of the Day

ADVERTISEMENT