The American Spectator

home
ADVERTISEMENT
Eminentoes
Print Email
Text Size

Eminentoes

John J. "Jack" McConnell: Lifetime Job for Tobacco and Lead Paint Litigator?

The Senate Judiciary Committee today will consider the nomination of a dubious litigator to serve as a federal district judge in Rhode Island.

The Senate Judiciary Committee today will consider Jack McConnell's nomination to be a federal district judge in Rhode Island. Given his underwhelming qualifications for that job, including an unimpressive ABA evaluation and his role in some of the more abusive litigation of the last 20 years, there are good reasons to question McConnell's qualifications for a lifetime job as a federal judge.

Rhode Island's senators, Jack Reed and Sheldon Whitehouse, say McConnell has "a brilliant legal mind" and the "experience, intellect, and temperament" to be a good judge, but the ABA isn't so sure. In fact, nobody on the ABA committee that evaluated McConnell's qualifications saw him as "well qualified," a substantial majority rated him merely "qualified," and a minority considered him "unqualified."

As for Reed and Whitehouse, it's probably no surprise that they have nice things to say about a major campaign contributor. McConnell gave $8,800 to Reed's 2008 re-election effort, $8,400 to Whitehouse's 2006 campaign, and another $3,500 since then to Whitehouse's PAC. And, it's not just his home-state senators; McConnell and his wife have contributed some $700,000 to Democratic campaigns over the past two decades, including the campaign of President Obama.       

As for McConnell's legal qualifications, one of his claims to fame is the role that he played in negotiating the master settlement between the states and the tobacco companies in 1998. The litigation was unsightly for several reasons, being marred by opportunism, greed, and disrespect for the rule of law.

Cronyism, too: The state attorneys general gave very lucrative contracts to former law partners and other supporters. State officials and their lawyers fought about the fees that the lawyers would be paid in Kansas, Texas, Maryland and other states; the lawyers in several states received compensation substantially out of line with the risk they took on and the amount of work they did. In Maryland, Peter Angelos, the state's hired gun, demanded a payment that would have given him $30,000 per hour, but later settled for less. States changed their laws to retroactively take away the defenses of the tobacco companies and smooth the path to a larger recovery.

Finally, the states used the proceeds of the litigation for anything but tobacco cessation programs; Rhode Island took its multi-year income stream of $1.19 billion and securitized it, accepting a one-time payment of $600 million that it spent in just three fiscal years to make up budget shortfalls and pay capital and operating expenses.

Another of McConnell's claims to fame is the lead paint litigation in Rhode Island and Wisconsin. In Rhode Island, McConnell's law firm shopped a lawsuit against the former makers of lead paint to Whitehouse, when the latter was that state's Attorney General. Whitehouse's successor ratified a decision that Whitehouse made and contracted out the state's power to sue in the public interest to McConnell's law firm. In the lawsuit, which McConnell considers one of his most significant, the state sought an order directing the companies to abate lead pigment in all buildings in Rhode Island that were accessible to children on the ground that the buildings were a "public nuisance."

The Rhode Island Supreme Court recognized that lead poisoning was a serious public health problem, but declined to play the role of the legislature and create a new cause of action to address it, as McConnell's lawsuit wanted it to do.

McConnell did better in Wisconsin, where another Obama administration nominee for a judgeship, Louis "Loophole Louie" Butler, was less averse to playing legislator. In a decision that Butler wrote, the Wisconsin Supreme Court held that a minor who complained of lead poisoning but could not identify the specific type of white lead carbonate that he ingested could still establish causation by showing that the defendant manufacturers produced or marketed white lead carbonate for use during the time the house was in existence. As one dissenter explained, the relaxed causation standard meant that the defendants could now be held liable "for a product they may or may not have produced, which may or may not have caused the plaintiff's injuries, based on conduct that may have occurred over 100 years ago when some of the defendants were not even part of the relevant market."

In the tobacco and lead paint litigation, McConnell encouraged courts to try to solve social problems by imposing massive damages on entire industries. The federal courts are not the place for such legal engineering. The members of the Judiciary Committee should make certain that McConnell understands the role of a federal district court judge before giving him a lifetime job on the bench.

About the Author

Jack Park is an attorney with the Atlanta law firm Strickland Brockington Lewis LLP.

Letter to the Editor View all comments (53) | Leave a comment

Pingback| 5.13.10 @ 6:13AM

Twitter Trackbacks for The American Spectator : John J. "Jack" McConnell: Lifetime J links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…spectator.org Topsy Retweet Button Add Topsy Retweet Button to your Blog or Web Site. WordPress  Web Sites 2 tweets tweet 2 All 0 Influential The American Spectator : John J. "Jack" McConnell: Lifetime Job for Tobacco and Lead Paint Litigator? spectator.org/archives/2010/05/13/john-j-jack-mcconnell-lifetime – view page – cached John J. "Jack" McConnell: Lifetime Job for Tobacco…

David| 5.13.10 @ 3:13PM

Now is the time for repubs to start opposing liberal judge nominees: at the district court and appellate court levels. They make a huge mistake by waiting until libs are nominated to the Supreme Court.

First, the dems always claim that the repubs voted for them for the district or appellate court and now oppose them for the supreme court. If they are not supreme court material, then repubs had no business voting to confirm them to the lower courts.

Last, the vast majority of cases never make it to the supreme court, or to the appellate courts for that matter. Liberal judges wreak havoc at the district court and appellate court levels.

It is time for repubs to start stopping them from ever becoming federal judges - like the dems did to Miguel Estrada and several other Bush nominees.

Pingback| 5.13.10 @ 5:24PM

Legacy of a Lonesome Death | Mother Jones | Washington County NY Real Estate links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…beginning his sentence, so he could bring in his tobacco crop. .. Go here to see the original: Legacy of a Lonesome Death | Mother Jones Related Blogs on Tobacco The American Spectator : John J. "Jack" McConnell: Lifetime Job … 'Safe' ciggies as hazardous as tobacco ipwars.com » Blog Archive » Tobacco and trade marks seminar Related Posts Odds And Ends Grafik to Cohost Event with…

Pingback| 5.13.10 @ 6:41PM

Big Scam On Campus: Local job-training course raises questions–and alarms links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…| iPhone App Reviews | iTouch | iPad Applications Key Factors Tһаt Define A Gοοԁ Affiliate Program | Survey4us Tһе American Spectator : John J. "Jack" McConnell: Lifetime Job fοr Tobacco аחԁ Lead Paint Litigator? Obama Drug Policy: Nο Surprises, Lots οf Alarms – Hit & Rυח : Reason Magazine Fringe Northwest Passage…

Pingback| 5.13.10 @ 8:32PM

Ab Circle Pro – As Seen On TV Ab Treadmill | Ab Circle Pro links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Ball – Lose Belly Fat Exercise For Beginners « pink high tops boots Common Sense Fitness Tips For Women | Discount Exercise Equipment The American Spectator : John J. "Jack" McConnell: Lifetime Job for Tobacco and Lead Paint Litigator? A lifetime burning in every moment : Maud Newton Not Just A Night Of A Lifetime. | NewDietHealth.com The Hundreds : Blog» Blog Archive »…

Pingback| 5.13.10 @ 8:37PM

How can i convince my mom to let me do martial arts? | chinese martial arts links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Supplies Geared Towards Different Styles and … A little knowledge is a dangerous thing Staringfrog.com – Articles and Information » Martial Arts … The American Spectator : John J. "Jack" McConnell: Lifetime Job … Once In A Life Time | Saying Images Plain Dudes – Yesteryear vs Today – Which was better – PlainDudesRadio Were laughing at you lil dudes complaining…

Pingback| 5.14.10 @ 2:12AM

“70-80% of smokers want to quit smoking” says Sajeela on NDTV | How Do Smokers Quit links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Forecasting 2010 Movie Sales – Deadline.com Whats the code to play myspace videos automatically.? of Myspace … Dynamic scaling of figure width « Latex Matters The American Spectator : John J. "Jack" McConnell: Lifetime Job … Quit Smoking CDs Really Work | Snipsly Top 10 Wedding Dance Videos on YouTube | Services For Seo pillow case dress instructions chest width 'Rollercoaster…

Pingback| 5.14.10 @ 6:58PM

Downtown businesses push back against liquor license limits | Business Suit links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…« WBAV – 101.9 Asian nations emerge from recession as stronger economic powe= rs … Araratbank signs agreement with EBRD on capital increase | Times.am The American Spectator : John J. "Jack" McConnell: Lifetime Job … Say Anything » Obama Accuses Republicans Of “Sitting On The … Mortgage Broker License » Blog Archive » Do you have a license … Lawmakers must fix…

Pingback| 5.14.10 @ 11:21PM

Is it possible to upgrade the lamp on a projector to a better lamp? | links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Kings Radio LMP ( 2010) | BanaMusic.Com Sony VPL-HW15 Projector Review Tһе Sony VPL-VW60 Black Pearl Projector: Aח Impressive Sony … Tһе American Spectator : John J. "Jack" McConnell: Lifetime Job … sonyalpharumors » Blog Archive » (SR5) First Sony A290 images! A lifetime burning іח еνеrу moment : Maud Newton Toshiba TBL4- LMP…

Pingback| 5.15.10 @ 1:20AM

I have fluoride stains on my teeth( the front two but mainly on the right one) will w links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Articles Tο More Tһаח 90 Categories Cаח Money Dashboard become tһе UK’s Mint.com? Tһе American Spectator : John J. "Jack" McConnell: Lifetime Job fοr Tobacco аחԁ Lead Paint Litigator? Boston Braces Fοr Anti-Smoking Tooth Fairy Fetish Porn іח Convenience Stores – Hit & Rυח : Reason…

Pingback| 5.15.10 @ 5:02AM

WorldOfPaidSurveys.com. | software blog links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…To Know Before … Best Paid Surveys – Locate The Best Paid Survey Sites Of 2010 … Get Paid To Take Online Surveys – Making Money With Paid Surveys … The American Spectator : John J. "Jack" McConnell: Lifetime Job … Retailers Embrace Online Surveys | Global Quality Marketing IT Help Desk Surveys and IT Customer Satisfaction Surveys Boost IT … Categories: survey software…

Pingback| 5.15.10 @ 12:27PM

I need a fast weight loss diet plan? | FatsControl.info links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Lose Weight Permanently? | Buy Weight Loss Here Staringfrog.com – Articles and Information » Do Diets Really Work? The American Spectator : John J. "Jack" McConnell: Lifetime Job … Quick Weight Loss Diets Makes You Fatter — My Weight Loss System The…

E| 5.15.10 @ 11:12PM

Jack McConnell would will be a terrific judge and Rhode Island would be lucky to have him. He's a man of great character, integrity and honesty.

jfdk| 7.1.10 @ 2:47AM

beijing massage

Leave a Comment

N.B. We encourage readers to share and discuss their thoughtful and relevant comments about this Spectator article. Comments are routinely monitored and will be deleted if profane, bigoted, or grossly impolite. Please be respectful. (And don't feed the trolls!) Thank you.

More Articles by Jack Park

More Articles From Eminentoes

http://spectator.org/archives/2010/05/13/john-j-jack-mcconnell-lifetime
ADVERTISEMENT

Clip of the Day

Most Popular Articles

Who Castrated Ann Coulter?

David Catron | 2.6.12

The Delousing of a Movement

R. Emmett Tyrrell, Jr. | 2.9.12

Justice Ginsburg Should Resign

William Tucker | 2.8.12

The Audacity of Obama's Secularism

George Neumayr | 2.7.12

Coulter Care

Peter Ferrara | 2.8.12

Thank Him, Santorum!

Jay D. Homnick | 2.8.12

Let Mrs. Obama Eat Red Velvet Cake

Aaron Goldstein | 2.7.12

ADVERTISEMENT