The hype is always better than the real thing.
Boston’s Big Dig sounded like a half-decent project in the
beginning. Approved in 1982 with a price tag $2.6 billion, it was
completed, however, more or less, in 2005 at a price of $22
billion.
“More or less” because concrete panels loosened and crashed
from the ceiling of a connector tunnel in 2006, the first full
year of operation, killing 38-year-old car passenger Milena Del
Valle, a mother of three. The family was awarded $28
million.
Medicare, similarly, was optimistically projected in 1967
to have an annual price tag of $12 billion by 1990. The actual
1990 cost? $98 billion.
Just the parking lot at the Kennedy Center (not the center
itself or its whole shebang of theaters, lounges, offices,
restaurants, etc.) had a cost estimate in 1998 of $28 million,
reports Reason magazine in its March 2010 issue. The actual cost
of the parking lot, completed in 2003? $88 million.
These estimates and actual costs aren’t even close, with
final prices running eight and ten times off. But it works, just
like fishing — camouflage the hooks with the right feathers and
bangles and a striped bass thinks he’s at the Ole Minnie
Buffet.
Now we’re getting the biggest hype yet, the idea that Obama
and his various czarinas and central planners have the expertise
to re-work a sixth of the U.S. economy so that we’ll somehow end
up with universal health coverage, 30 million more people
insured, and all done in a way that produces lower costs and
higher quality while not adding a dime to the federal
deficit.
It’s like everyone gets a shiny new Mercedes and somehow,
simultaneously, the sticker price goes down, the quality goes up,
and there’s no red ink.
Plus they’re saying that billions can be cut from Medicare
without cutting anything that seniors are getting from
Medicare.
I get the feeling that we haven’t learned much from our
previous grand experiments. The list of failures in long.
During World War II, Franklin D. Roosevelt distorted the
free market by implementing wage and price controls in order to
prevent “profiteering” and fight inflation. Employers, in order
to attract labor, switched from giving raises to providing health
insurance.
Today, we’re paying a high price in the global arena for
that government-created market distortion that produced the
ongoing employer-based health system that consistently harms the
ability of U.S. firms to compete against companies from countries
that spread the costs of healthcare more broadly.
General Motors reports that healthcare costs add between
$1,500 and $2,000 to the sticker price of every vehicle it makes.
Bottom line, America’s employer-based healthcare is selling
Hondas and killing Detroit.
On January 8, 1964, President Lyndon Johnson delivered his
first State of the Union address, calling for an “all-out war on
human poverty,” with special focus on black poverty and inner
city revitalization. The following year, Sen. Daniel Moynihan
sounded the alarm about the breakdown of the black family in his
book The Negro Family: The Case for National Action. At
the time, 1965, the black illegitimacy rate was 26
percent.
Today, $10 trillion later in federal spending on
anti-poverty programs, the illegitimacy rate among blacks is 70
percent.
Most recently, seeking universal and equitable housing, the
Carter and Clinton administrations passed legislation, with
well-intended consequences, of course, that forced banks to make
loans in lower income areas and to unqualified borrowers. The
result was a massive expansion of high-risk subprime loans, a
real estate bubble, a worldwide distribution of toxic assets, and
the subsequent housing crash, financial panic and bank
collapses.
And now, next up on the politicians’ fix-it list —
healthcare. Just say No.
MOS was 71331| 3.2.10 @ 1:36PM
While this posting takes you to a more interesting website than do the Chinese machine tool postings I've complained about earlier, it has absolutely nothing to do with discussing Prof Reiland's article. Will the webmaster please delete it?
Webmaster| 3.2.10 @ 5:53PM
Dude, I'm in the middle of something right now! I can't be deleting posts at the same time that I'm looking at fashion models in cheap, sexy lingerie. What am I, some multi-tasking machine? I'm just a country web-master, Jim, I mean, MOS was 71331.
Now, as soon as I clean my screen, get a cup of coffee and finish orderering my machine tool parts (thanks, poster!) from China, I'll look at this annoying post of yours.
Actually, the lingerie is connected via 6 degrees of connection to Mr. Reiland, albeit in a scenario involving Kevin Bacon in some kind of weird position.
Mr. Baiter, Spectator.org Webmaster
Alan Brooks| 3.2.10 @ 5:49PM
Frank Zappa, of all people, got it just so:
"the schools system is pure shit,
only thing matters is money, real estate, and labor control;
Communism is the best way to control labor.
But you can't complain because the world doesn't owe you anything; when you get angry you think the world owes you something-- but it doesn't.
But God gives you a sense of humor so you can laugh at the whole thing."
Charity in Truth| 3.2.10 @ 6:35AM
Silence never hurts the oppressor.
Keep saying NO:
Capitol Switchboard 202 224 3121
www.house.gov
www.senate.gov
Howard| 3.2.10 @ 7:35AM
It seems inevitable that whenever government is involved, things cost more and take longer to perform. And for our liberal friends the answer, is of course, more government.
Copyleft| 3.2.10 @ 8:35AM
Yeah, what has "collectivism" ever achieved, other than
*The 40-hour workweek
*Child-labor laws
*Workplace health and safety
*Cleaner air and water
*The Internet
*Rural electric service
*National highways
*The Centers for Disease Control
*Social Security
*Medicare
...and all that other unpopular, useless stuff? LOL!
Keep swinging, you're bound to get a hit someday.
dave| 3.2.10 @ 8:51AM
Yeah Copyleft, ALL of which could have been done better, and more efficiently, by the private sector - that's the point. There is no such thing as a "public good."
Baloney Guy| 3.2.10 @ 9:07AM
Copyleft: 40,000 or more people die each year on the nation's highways. Are you saying that's a success?
Vietnam Vet| 3.2.10 @ 11:00AM
Amen to that. There were about 58,000 US deaths in Vietnam over 11 years. That is 7.6 times the deaths on US roads per year than in Vietnam. 13,000 per year due to alcohol - double the yearly rate in Vietnam. Why does not Govt do something useful like put these people away for a very long time. Where is Hanoi Jane when you need her!
Dan Hirsch| 3.2.10 @ 10:38AM
"Copy left" What a funny name. Does this mean you just copy whatever you see on the left? It seems like it.
I'm not sure how collectivism got you the forty hour work week. It 's not law. Unions have negotiated a 40 hour work week and in most cases, where they have they eventually ended up losing jobs to more productive overseas workers.
Child labor laws were duly enacted by duly elected representatives. That's not the result of collectivism.
Workplace health and safety. If you have ever worked in a private business you would know that your workforce is a crucial part of your business. Having your people think you don't care about their health and safety causes them to leave, costing your business money. This has been obvious in every workplace I've been in the since the sixties. Profit promotes safety more than collectivism. Did Upton Sinclair have a committee when he wrote "The Jungle". I think not.
Cleaner air and water has come through those pesky duly elected representatives, their duly enacted legislation, and President NIXON's EPA. I don't recall the AFL-CIO, the Teamsters, or the UMW striking for reduced pollution. Do you?
Didn't Vice President Al Gore invent the Internet? Surely the VP with his carbon credit trading combine isn't a collectivist. He looks more like Mr. Potter from "It's a Wonderful Life."
By your "National highways" I believe you refer to the Interstate Highway system called for initially by President Eisenhower. Again duly enacted by the duly elected.
The Center for Disease control, again duly - duly. And are they so bright? Weren't we going to be digging mass graves for the victims of West Nile, oops, I mean swine, oops I mean H1N1 scares?
Social security and Medicare, both broke and again duly - duly.
Copy left, do you know anything that's true?
Please quiet until you have some true facts, you make me uncomfortable making such a fool of yourself!
Copyleft| 3.2.10 @ 10:54AM
Ahh, I see Dan is playing the "redefinition" game. If it was successful, it couldn't have come about from collectivism... because collectivism is always a failure!
In his example, anything created by government isn't collectivism at all! What do you say, Spectators? Is Dan's new definition a good one?
Dan Hirsch| 3.2.10 @ 10:58AM
Funnily named one, I see no facts in your response, only your redefining the facts I presented.
Just a couple of demonstrable facts would help you so much.
Copyleft| 3.2.10 @ 12:14PM
I've already provided the facts, Dan, which you've attempted to define away, using the curious technique of declaring that "anything done through government doesn't count as collectivism."
So the question now facing you is this: What DOES count as collectivism? Has any ever occurred throughout the history of America?
NavyBrat | 3.2.10 @ 1:12PM
"Has any ever occurred throughout the history of America?"
Why yes. The first attempt at collectivism damn near starved everyone in the Mass. Bay Colony during the first year or so. Of course, they saw the error of their ways & changed their system. We know this because they didn't all starve to death in the vain attempt to perpetuate the "collective."
fbom| 3.2.10 @ 11:05AM
Ah - the straw man commeth - deflect the conversation to 'ignore the man behind the curtin'.
Dan Hirsch| 3.2.10 @ 11:22AM
Mr. or Ms. "fbom,"
You also have a funny name. Can you not say what you say and take the chance to identify yourself?
Do you like to think you are behind the curtain?
Does that meaningless remark work at cocktail parties for you? Just what in the Sam Hill are you trying to say? Don't mumble and mutter, out with it. Did collectivism build internets, interstates, workplace safety, Medicare, and Social Security or didn't it?
How about a meaningful statement of your own opinion? Do you have one? Do you know it? Well?
Please don't assail my facts in this post, I have only asked questions.
fbom| 3.2.10 @ 12:24PM
Any fool can ask a question. Can you answer them without using another question? Or this is an eduction in Zen?
Ryan| 3.2.10 @ 11:15AM
How is he wrong?
Brubaker| 3.2.10 @ 12:04PM
Copyleft,
I see that you are, like all leftists, incapable of debating the facts. Instead, when the conversation doesn't go your way, you immediately revert to form and attempt to denigrate those with whom you disagree.
Dan Hirsch demonstrably is correct, and that clearly is more than you can handle. Better luck next time.
Tom| 3.2.10 @ 12:09PM
Dan,
If all it takes is a vote of our duly elected representatives to ensure something is not collectivism then the entire premise of this article is incorrect. Each and every example of wasteful inefficient spending mentioned by Mr. Reiland was voted for by duly elected representatives.
Federal law DOES specifically address the 40 hour work week. And it was largely driven by union interests. As were many workplace laws. Whether this is a good or bad thing is debatable but the historical record is clear.
Copyleft| 3.2.10 @ 12:16PM
Thank you, Tom. I'm surprised it took so long for someone to point out how desperate Dan's dodge had become.
Sorry, Dan, but you don't get to wave away all the benefits and successes of collectivism by saying "Oh, but that was GOVERNMENT--that doesn't count." It's a dodge, and even your fellow government-haters can't get behind you on that one.
Tom| 3.2.10 @ 12:16PM
I would debate whether some of the items you listed are indeed the product of collectivism but the more importants questions were they succesful, are they the proper role of the federal government, and could they have been better addressed by the private sector. In the context of this article using Social Security and Medicare as examples of successful collectivism borders on the silly since each program demonstrates the Mr. Reiland's central point: cost projections of government programs are consistently incorrect.
Copyleft| 3.2.10 @ 12:17PM
And THAT's a fair point, Tom. Yes, government waste and lack of accountability is a serious problem that deserves serious attention.
Whining that "collectivism is just a record of failure" isn't serious, and it deserves only ridicule.
Margie| 3.2.10 @ 5:49PM
Are you a product of the Universities, or were you just programmed from birth?
ben| 3.2.10 @ 6:16PM
Collectivism is oppression.
Any collective forces the individual to admonish their interests in pursuit of the "greater good". The problem with this is WHO gets to decide what is in the greater good? In a popular system like a democracy the majority decide what's in the greater good. But as Thomas Jefferson said, "A democracy is simply mob rule where 51% of the people can vote away the rights of the other 49%". All authoritarian societies enact their collectivism for the greater good as defined by the rulers. In either popular or authoritarian systems the average person is coersed into behaviors or actions others wish them to engage in - this is tyranny and oppression.
Our system of governance was designed on the principal of individual freedom as freedom can only exist individually. Our federal gov't was not designed as, nor intended to be a democracy, but thanks to the 16th and 17th amendments that's just what we've become. Our federal gov't was to be a constitutional republic, governed by the rule of law as laid out in the supreme law of this land the US Constitution. The representation of democracies was to be held strictly at the state level where the competition between the states for businesses, people and taxes served as the greatest check and balance on majority whims and state authority.
Any gov't must work collectively when dealing with such large populations, it is unrealistic to assume we can possibly govern any other way. This is why the constitution specifically limited the power of the federal government, and why state constitutions were written as well – to protect minority rights from majority whims.
The fact is, everyone one of us is in the minority in some way, whether it be ability, ambition, belief, etc. because everyone one of us is different. There is a vast diversity among humans. A diversity far greater than our races, genders, sexual orientations etc., as this diversity is manifest within these p-c segregations. A collective ignores this diversity and assumes we are all the same. This assumption of non-diversity is why collectives have never worked and why they never will.
The collectivist assumes they know better , and wishes to enact their better on others many times to “help” them. But no one, not even Einstein can know more about me than me, just as no one not even I can know more about you than you. The only thoughts we have, beliefs we hold, and needs we can recognize are our own. Therefore the only “greater good” any of us can define is our own. To force those thoughts, beliefs and needs onto others is to impose tyranny. I may wish to help others, but first I must recognize that I have no knowledge of or authority over anyone else. So the best I can do is offer my advice or assistance, leaving those I wish to help free to take or leave it. Any imposition of my advice or assistance is tyranny and can only be rationalized by assuming I know more about you than you do. My “greater good” may be anathema to yours, but in a collective one of us must win out. How do we decide who’s tyranny is best? Rather than decide who's tyranny we should enact for whatever reason, our founders wrote a system of governance that disabled the majority's and gov'ts ability to make those choices for us.
“The policy of the Amercian government is to keep its citizens free, neither restraining nor aiding them in their pursuits.” – Thomas Jefferson.
Bilwick| 3.3.10 @ 4:03PM
"Copyleft" is one of those people who, if by some happenstance they read ROAD TO SERFDOM, would interpret not as a warning, but a blueprint. "All right--a road to serfdom! That sounds great! How do we do that? Is it paved with yellow bricks!'
PoliticalRectum| 3.4.10 @ 2:47AM
collective you were born. do you know your real fathers name? you sure? didn't Al Gore invent all that stuff?
Pingback| 3.2.10 @ 9:18AM
Fishing Video Help » American Collectivism: A Record of Failure - Spectator.org links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Bill Hussein O'Stalin| 3.2.10 @ 9:23AM
Ironically, at a time when the nation's private sector job pool is shrinking, the number of government jobs continues to accelerate, particularly at the federal level, and mostly under Barack Obama.
While the President talks of establishing a commission on cutting the deficits he continues to expand the scope and size of government making his calls for a deficit commission nothing but a shell game.
Senator Bunning is getting excoriated by liberal media for his stand against further spending without cutting other spending but if you read the comments that follow many of those articles, many in the public are supportive of Senator Bunning's stand against more spending without corresponding cuts in federal spending.
That's precisely what PAYGO which was recently passed by the Congress was supposed to achieve. Instead it was just another shell game used to raise the debt ceiling while the collectivists planned all along to continue spending.
Senator Bayh, a Democrat, who recently announced his retirement, stated, "If I created one job in the private sector, it would be one more job then was created by the Stimulus."
One of the funded items in the budget gives 1,250,000 to a university professor to study how electric eels move.
In the meantime here's some educational reading for you.
Government work is one sector of our economy that is booming (besides pawnshops and bankruptcy lawyers). Rich Lowry noted the paradox: We suffer, and government workers prosper.
For most Americans, the Great Recession has been an occasion to hold on for dear life. For public employees, it's been an occasion to let the good times roll.
The percentage of federal civil servants making more than $100,000 a year jumped from 14 percent to 19 percent during the first year and a half of the recession, according to USA Today. At the beginning of the downturn, the Transportation Department had one person making $170,000 or more a year; now it has 1,690 making that.
The New York Times reports that state and local governments have added a net 110,000 jobs since the beginning of the recession, while the private sector has lost 6.9 million. The gap between total compensation of public and private workers has only widened during the downturn, according to USA Today. In 2008, benefits for public employees grew at a rate three times that of private employees.
Bill Hussein O'Stalin| 3.2.10 @ 9:25AM
Link to above italicized text.
http://www.americanthinker.com.....emplo.html
Becky| 3.2.10 @ 9:34AM
There is a proper role for government. If the things they do within constitutional parameters were as bad as the ones they do outside those parameters, we would be living in an unstable country. Come to think of it, the Post Office is mandated by the constitution, and they seem to have trouble making it work.
Anything in copyleft's list that is any good, came out of national security needs. Social Security and Medicare are not healthy institutions, and precisely the point of the article.
Pingback| 3.2.10 @ 10:47AM
Obama’s Budget Parlor Tricks: Been There, Done That | NewsReal Blog links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.2.10 @ 11:02AM
Half the Service at Twice the Price « The Republican Heretic links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Richard| 3.2.10 @ 11:26AM
The problem is that a few engineer for a society these few cannot possibly understand. No few people can understand the myriad of social and economic interactions continually happening. Hence reality humbles the plans of every leftist using government to implement his scheme. How could it be otherwise? But the newly coined leftist believes will get it right this time!
The greatest evil results from men attempting to become God.
PoliticalRectum| 3.4.10 @ 2:43AM
people are so stupid. SO stupid. long as it isn't their money, voting for your own paycheck.....
stop believing that the right does not care about things. we slapped down slavery didn't we? Ask Byrd of Ole man Gore.. Al's dad, known racist types but they>> changed>>yuk yuk..
Cris Worth| 3.2.10 @ 12:26PM
Johnson fought two wars, War on Poverty - lost, costing trillions and counting, War on Vietnam -lost, costing billions and killing/maiming millions. He raided the Social Security trust fund - now bankrupt, to pay for both wars. Truman said Johnson did more damage to the Presidency than all presidents before him combined. ALL THE WAY WITH LBJ.
Pingback| 3.2.10 @ 9:17PM
The American Spectator : American Collectivism: A Record of Failure Mobile links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Gary Hartpence| 3.2.10 @ 10:03PM
Let's ask Oldefarte.
Pingback| 3.2.10 @ 10:41PM
The American Spectator : American Collectivism: A Record of Failure Blog links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.3.10 @ 6:23AM
Hershey Bears Down Bridgeport Sound Tigers, 6-3 – Minor League … | Hershey Bears AHL links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.3.10 @ 11:51AM
Hello world! Introduction « Bizop Review links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.3.10 @ 2:21PM
Fresh Bilge » American Collectivism links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Ralph Novy| 3.3.10 @ 4:39PM
"illegitimacy rate"?
Your credibility became "illegitimate" as soon as you thoughtlessly deployed that phrase.
Learn.
Ralph
Thaddeus Romansky| 3.3.10 @ 6:01PM
I was curious if the dollar amounts quoted in the article had all been adjusted to reflect real values of the dollar? Take for example this statement, "Medicare, similarly, was optimistically projected in 1967 to have an annual price tag of $12 billion by 1990. The actual 1990 cost? $98 billion." In order for us to evaluate statement readers need to know that the figures being used are either in 1967 dollars, 1990 dollars, or 2010 dollars, right?
This would also make a difference in judging the veracity of Mr. Reiland's thesis would it not?
I am not asking this question with an answer already in mind. I really want to know so I can make up my mind.
Busbar Processor Machine | 3.4.10 @ 8:08AM
Fivestar Tools,Manufacture Busbar Processor Machine,With busbar cutting tool,bending tool and punching tool.
Pingback| 3.4.10 @ 11:21AM
The Global Economy Unravels links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.24.10 @ 9:54PM
Big Fun Over In Twogtown - nampion.com links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Bario| 5.10.10 @ 4:47AM
I was curious if the dollar amounts quoted in the article had all been adjusted to reflect real values of the dollar? Take for example this statement, "Medicare, similarly, was optimistically projected in 1967 to have an annual price tag of $12 billion by 1990. The actual 1990 cost? $98 billion." In order for us to evaluate statement readers need to know that the figures being used are either in 1967 dollars, 1990 dollars, or 2010 dollars, right? download the back-up plan and download furry vengeance
MKV to iPad | 11.15.10 @ 8:39AM
MKV to iPad is the best solution to sharing MKV files on iPad. As we know, the newly developed iPad can only surport MP4 format, so if you want to play MKV video on iPad, you have to convert MKV to iPad with an additional software.My personal recommendation is to use this MKV to iPad Converter. The biggest difference between this all-in-one MKV to iPad and other similar ones is that it can not onvert general video format to iPad, but can also convert HD video to iPad for sharing high-defination video everywhere mobile movie theater.
سوريا | 6.25.11 @ 12:18AM
thank yuou vere nice
http://www.soryh.com
سوريا | 6.25.11 @ 12:54AM
http://www.soryh.com
choy | 10.24.11 @ 9:33AM
thank you so much for this site. very informational
yanyan | 10.11.11 @ 5:04PM
I am very interested for this post. Its really give me lots of pleasure. I choose this article very much. So lots of thanks for this post.zoloft lawsuits
balcuizar62| 10.13.11 @ 1:46AM
wow, awesome post, I was wondering how to cure acne naturally. and found your blog by being, many useful stuff here, now i have got some idea. bookmarked and also signed up your rss. keep us updated.
yaz class action
ruth| 10.17.11 @ 11:42AM
The work itself is already rewarding. I am sure they will have more to employ later. Good luck for the team!
silver spot price
ruth| 10.17.11 @ 1:36PM
You got a really useful blog I have been here reading for about an hour. I am a newbie and your success is very much an inspiration for me.
mesothelioma lawsuit
fiance visa| 10.18.11 @ 2:26AM
Wow this site was totally unique from the other .It has a different content that anyone could look for something great.It want to visit this site for more interesting detail to have on.I will look forward to this guys..
fiance visa
creamer| 10.19.11 @ 10:59PM
It proved to be very useful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here!
Actos Lawyers
abominable putridity| 11.5.11 @ 9:41AM
Very great post. I just discovered your blog and wanted to tell you that I've really enjoyed surfing around your blog content. Thanks so much.
L Tod Schlosser
HAPPY| 11.8.11 @ 7:29PM
Well with your permission allow me to grab your RSS feed to keep updated with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please keep up the rewarding work.
filipina women
Craige| 11.13.11 @ 7:37PM
It is a great post and a great idea. Always I wanted to jazz up the icons on my websites a little. It has some important idea. This is very nice post!
paxil lawsuit
bogol| 11.16.11 @ 2:23PM
I got lucky and found your site from a random Google search. Fortunately for me, this topic just happens to be something that I've been trying to find more info on for research purpose.
Actos Lawyers
bogol| 12.1.11 @ 3:11PM
The blog was absolutely fantastic! Lot of great information which can be helpful in some or the other way. Keep updating the blog, looking forward for more contents...Great job, keep it up..
mesothelioma lawsuit
inah0911| 12.7.11 @ 7:07AM
probably this blog is awesome and people love this to to read and discover for what they need and when i discover your blog i feel like i need to share this blog immediately thanks.
foreclosure califorina
IMYI| 12.15.11 @ 10:35PM
An fascinating dialogue is value comment. I think that it's best to write more on this subject, it might not be a taboo subject but typically individuals are not enough to talk on such topics. To the next. Cheers
Medtronic Infuse Lawsuit