-
The Mexican Kleptocracy: July 1989
April 19, 2013 | 0 comments
-
The Mexican Kleptocracy
April 19, 2013 | 3 comments
-
Black Plight: In Conflict With Unions
April 6, 2013 | 0 comments
-
An Assist from the Press
March 16, 2013 | 0 comments
-
Capitol Ideas
March 1, 2013 | 0 comments
Capitol Ideas
Poets Galore and Subsidized Poets
Anyone still remember Elizabeth Alexander’s performance at the Obama inaugural?
(Page 3 of 3)
Today, in consequence, everything is undistinguished. How can anyone plow through those thousand volumes a year? The good will be buried beneath the ever-rising snowdrifts from the grant- and tenure-seekers. (Academic philosophy is subject to the same adverse forces, I believe. If there is good philosophy coming out of the academy, as is quite possible, we will be hard pressed to discover it.)
THERE IS ONE SOLUTION: Cut off all the subsidies. Let poetry be restored to the marketplace. Maybe 150 poets would survive, as in 1941. No such cuts will happen, of course, if only because there are so many generous-hearted and wealthy people around who cannot imagine that more money for something good in itself (poetry) will not produce more of the good; and may actually stifle it.
Meanwhile the best of luck to Elizabeth Alexander. Her website assures us that she is “one of the most vital poets of her generation,” and, what’s more, “a pivotal figure in American poetry.” So she will not be needing my blessing. Her pivotal performance showed that she moves with great self-assurance in the mainstream of today’s academic poetry. But I wonder how many of her rivals envy her credentials, and the accidents of birth, which conferred upon her this rare distinction.
About the Author
Tom Bethell is a senior editor of The American Spectator and author of The Politically Incorrect Guide to Science, The Noblest Triumph: Property and Prosperity Through the Ages, and most recently Questioning Einstein: Is Relativity Necessary? (2009).
Letter to the Editor View all comments (37) | Leave a comment
More Articles by Tom Bethell
More Articles From Capitol Ideas
http://spectator.org/archives/2009/03/03/poets-galore-and-subsidized-po
Follow us:
ADVERTISEMENT
SPONSORED LINKS
FLASHBACK TO: 1995
-
Pope Culture
A man of faith in a godless age is hitting Americans where it hurts.
-
Why the GOP Does Not, Like, Totally Suck
Mr. and Mrs. American Spectator Reader, let P.J. O’Rourke talk sense to your kids.
-
Dames at Sea
-
In the Absence of Guns
In Britain, defending your property can get you life.
-
The Metaphysical Martini
-
Counting the Costs of Clintonism
The debacle of this president’s administration is both a cause and a symptom of the decline of American values. Unless Congress impeaches him, that decline will go on unchecked. An eminent jurist surveys the damage and assesses the chances for the recovery of our culture.
-
Chuck McHagel
It won’t take long for conservatives to scratch this presidential wannabe off their 2008 scorecard.
-
The Legacy of Old John and Mother Fresh-Roasted
-
It’s the Best Time of the Year
The American Christmas, like the songs that celebrate it, makes room for everybody under the rainbow. Is that why so many people seem to be hostile to it?
-
The Bush Crack-Up
Was the President done in by the economy, or by the politics of the economy?
Clip of the Day
ADVERTISEMENT
frost| 3.3.09 @ 6:16AM
Un-huh, I recall myself shaking my head, almost giggling, that this weird exhibition should be a part of a presidential inauguration? Pathetic!
Aside from its other ingredients (or the lack thereof), there was one sage who said words to the effect that: "Poetry which doesn't rhyme is like playing tennis without a net." Even worse when loaded with Pabulum Puke crap...
Robbins Mitchell| 3.3.09 @ 7:08AM
You want real poetry?...I'll give you real poetry....I once heard a recording of British Poet Laureat John Masefield reciting his poem 'Sea Fever'....."I must go down to the sea again,to the lonely sea and the sky...and all I ask is a tall ship and a star to steer her by.".....made me want to climb the rigging right then and there
Melvin| 3.3.09 @ 8:03AM
Elizabeth Alexander should have recited the poem, "The poet and the jackass."
Melvin| 3.3.09 @ 8:04AM
Elizabeth Alexander should have recited the poem, "The poet and the jackass."
Melvin| 3.3.09 @ 8:06AM
My apologies for the dbl. posting, bad fingers, bad fingers.
Wankel| 3.3.09 @ 8:26AM
Oh well, at least it was a step up from the mutterings of Maya Angelou. Then again, maybe not...
Trotter| 3.3.09 @ 9:16AM
I'm still laughing at Laura Ingraham's spoof of the Alexander "poem".
Seriously, how have we gotten to this point in our Nation's history that Angelou's and Alexander's works are deemed worthy of presidential inaugurations? Good grief, talk about dumbed-down. If Barry wins a 2nd term, it should simply play the clip of Eddie Murphy on SNL doing his "Landlord" poem. At least that made sense.
Gene Schmidt| 3.3.09 @ 9:23AM
The popularity of the singer/songwriters of the 1970s was, I think, a reaction to the underwhelming emtions that modern poetry aroused in most individuals. Bob Dylan and Jackson Browne and Joni Mitchell may or may not have been creating significant art, but at the very least their lyrics addressed recognizably human concerns---love, family, place in society, etc. Modern poetry, in contrast, had simply become murky and incomprehensible during this time.
Appleby| 3.3.09 @ 9:31AM
Obama? Inauguration? When was that?
Oh, right, I took that day off from work, where they were fawning and fainting (and we are in Kanukistan, with our own government trembling on the edge of the abyss -- slated to collapse in 7 days) and after my charity stint in the morning, I took my computer into the shop for a tune-up, shut off all my electronics save the stereo, put on some new CDs containing love songs of the 1930s and 1940s, and spent the day reading a Dorothy Sayers mystery.
Oh, and as an English major, had I been paying attention to that farce, I would have read something from Matthew Arnold.
Or possibly "Terence, This Is Stupid Stuff," with its trenchant couplet:
"Thus malt doth more than Milton can/to justify God's ways to man."
frost| 3.3.09 @ 9:37AM
The demise of a Great America?
I read somewhere that it may have all started some years ago when the hapless (but best-selling) “poet” Rod McKuen was the Howard Cosell of verse, during the dawn of Political Correctness…
There again, perhaps it was Richard Bach and J. L. Seagull.
Or Barbara Hershey renaming herself Seagull...?
Anyway, am reminded that one bad poet's 'work' doesn't make sense, 'cept to another bad poet... or, as Michael Moorcock said: "The ideas of Byron and Shelley have probably caused more young men to lose their lives in hopeless, idiotic, romantic causes than the ideas of Karl Marx. Romanticism is the disease of the Modern Age."
Your witness...?
Mimi Evans Winship| 3.3.09 @ 9:39AM
As a versifier of conservative mien,
I know my readership is lean.
I don’t aspire to modern poetessness.
My goal is merely to repossess
Some modicum of whimsy, some tiny scrap of wit.
Am I a P.J. O’Roark of poesy, or perhaps a little bit
Of R. Emmett Tyrrell in rhyme serene,
Skewering the modern scene.
I flounder in a PC sea,
Determined to recapture poetry.
Mimi Evans Winship
whiterb| 3.3.09 @ 9:43AM
I wish somebody would ask Obama if he was inspired by the poem.
And if so why? Would somebody just ask basic questions please ?
whiterb| 3.3.09 @ 9:47AM
When I grow up and become president Mimi will be asked to give the inauguration poem.
frost| 3.3.09 @ 9:49AM
I check back to see if any new interesting inclusions may have been added/offered... and, lo-and-behold, already: Mimi, I love you. Great stuff.
Mike | 3.3.09 @ 11:05AM
Let me see if I have this right: the DOW sank below 7000 wiping out 50% of its former value, AIG posted the largest loss in U.S. corporate history, we still don't know if we are going to avoid going into a world wide depression and Mr. Bethell is worrying about a poem. You wonder why I consider AmSpec the right wing equivalent of Comedy Central?
Mike| 3.3.09 @ 12:15PM
What hideous drivel! Elizabeth Alexander is a poster child for the anti-affirmative action argument. When she finished the crowd had no idea the fat lady had sung, and it delayed its obligatory applause for several uncomfortable seconds. Pathetic.
Jim| 3.3.09 @ 3:08PM
None of us wonder Mike and quite honestly do not care. Mi Grandiose Amigo
Why, I wonder, would one find a diversion, respite if you will, from the daily mantra of "the sky is falling," bothersome.
Ben| 3.3.09 @ 3:24PM
I taped the inauguration ceremony as a matter of historical significance. During the reading, there is a kid sitting near Mrs. Obama. The look on his face is classic. It was the same as mine was. It said "huh?"
Mack Hall| 3.3.09 @ 5:32PM
Yes, I worry about a poem. Humans live because of economic activity, but not FOR human activity. We life for truth and beauty. Keats shows us beauty; government-approved poets show us drivel.
Niel Rosenthalis| 3.4.09 @ 1:14AM
As a current college student (english and spanish double major, creative writing minor), and as a writer of poetry, I'm concerned with this article's claims. Part of me wants to agree with the skepticism of this article. I mean--this inaugural poem WAS really pathetic. A huge letdown, especially since it was an opportunity to show poetry to a huge audience, get them interested in poetry. And that's what the poetry community gives the country as a good example of poetry? The head of the Poetry Foundation (bless them) called the selection of Alexander "perfect."
I'm in a poetry workshop class now--should I not be? I'm refusing to not publish; in order to not be cynical about writing, you must be cynical about publishing (to paraphrase Alan Shapiro). And I'm working on learning the tools of the trade, so to speak. I'm trying to become a meaningful poet--well, I'm trying to be the best I can be. I completely agree that there is a lot of crap floating around that passes for good poetry. That it passes for poetry makes me quite nervous about the future of poetry. And if given the same opportunities, would Eliot and Frost have applied for all these grants and fellowships (et cetera)? Or would they have stuck to their day jobs?
Thank you for writing this article, though I wish I could come away from it with a clearer sense of what to do about the problem. I guess I'll just keep reading the masters (Keats, Bishop, Plath, Eliot, Frost, maybe Rich) and learning all I can from them.
I hope this ship rights itself again.
Hammer of the Dogs| 3.4.09 @ 10:31AM
There was once a young man from chicagya,
who wanted the US to be just like Kenya,
Where we live in mud huts, eating berries and nuts,
and use cowchips to warm our rear endsya.
irv | 3.5.09 @ 7:07PM
I recently read a book of personal letters written by Raymond Chandler. He complained in the early fifties that critics couldn't tell quality, they just liked whatever was about the correct subjects. It could have been written today.
Chandler was not a very good poet but having had the benefit of a classical education, he knew it.
Alan Brooks| 3.11.09 @ 3:13PM
then why come here Mikey boy, if you want SERIOUS doom and gloom? what's wrong with a poem now and then?
don't stay up at night worrying about AIG, the 50 percent losses, or the possible depression--
you need your beauty sleep.
Bill Boyd| 3.22.09 @ 12:15PM
I was a fiction writer in a writer's workshop back in the 70's. The poetry side of the shop was where the real competition lay. Those who failed to get into the poetry workshop but who did gain admission to the English graduate program were especially suspicious of the accomplishments of those who had supposedly made the poetical grade. Among all those struggling poets, I can recall only one who really stood out. As for me, I have yet to produce even the mediocre American novel, much less the great one. My unfinished latest attempt sits in a memory card on my Pocket PC, and all I regularly produce are emails which occasionally inspire criticism from my boss for being too sarcastic and or praise from a co-workers for an insightful turn of phrase regarding some controversy in the IT department.
gfhfgh| 12.2.09 @ 1:44AM
H264 Converter,
H264 Converter for Mac