The American Spectator

home
ADVERTISEMENT
Print Email
Text Size

Feature

Providing Relief from the Crisis

How to spare the economy further crippling government intervention by suspending mark-to-market accounting

(Page 5 of 5)

More questions: If the “impairment” results from lack of liquidity because markets aren’t working, why can’t banks simply hold on to their securities—until maturity if necessary? Why must they assume a fire sale at fire-sale prices for something they don’t have to sell? If some of the impairment results from actual losses on the underlying mortgages, why can’t they write off only that portion of the impairment? Does it really make sense to force write-offs of the whole bundle of mortgages when only a few would have to be written off if the mortgages were held individually?

What makes the answers so crucial is that these write-offs we’re talking about reduce the banks’ regulatory capital dollar for dollar. That used to mean failure or a forced marriage when capital reaches zero. These days it only has to approach zero to preserve insurance funds and stretch bailout money.

The answers to my questions apparently have to do with transparency—investors and creditors need to see exactly what you’ve got in your portfolio. Well, show them. Surely you can show them what’s in the sack without having to throw the sack away. Surely transparency can be achieved without throwing common sense out the door.

In a recent blog posting, I described a variant, the PWC proposal, which would count only the markdowns attributable to credit impairment against regulatory capital and would treat those attributable to illiquidity in another manner. Show it all; let it all hang out; just don’t crucify our financial system and economy on the cross of mark-to-market accounting.

Now is the time for all good accountants to come to the aid of their country, and put some fairness in fair value. 

Bob McTeer is the former president of the Dallas Federal Reserve Bank.

Page: ‹ First   3 45

Letter to the Editor View all comments (18) |

Alan Brooks| 3.4.09 @ 9:05PM

Even if you suspend mark-to-mark accounting and do whatever else you can to turn the economy around, you'll just end up with a situation similar to the one we were in during the late '90s when the public-- the public whose judgment we overrate-- got overconfident and made so many mistakes that we ended up with another financial 'crisis' (an overused word). Foolish people have to learn the hard way, and since the overwhelming majority are fools it now appears genuine progress is a mirage. We all walk in a maze of self deception.

Life is basically making mistakes until we die.

Pingback| 9.16.09 @ 6:08PM

Recommended Mark to Market Article links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

Recommended Mark to Market Article Home September 16, 2009 Recommended Mark to Market Article Providing Relief from the Crisis excerpt: Devotees of market value accounting cringe at the thought of suspending the rules. They argue it would result in a loss of transparency and an overstatement of values. To the…

hgjhg| 11.23.09 @ 8:11PM

TOD Converter Mac,
TOD File Converter Mac

asdf| 1.5.10 @ 4:49AM

This powerful Streaming Video Capture supports comprehensive video sharing websites, online TV channels, Internet radio station, online movie, live sport, live news report and other streaming video websites. It enables you to easily capture all these videos and save on your local hard disk. It is the best tool to capture streaming video from Internet.Capture Streaming Video,iPhone To Computer Transfer

trytry| 3.1.10 @ 10:06PM

iPod to PC Transfer,
iPod to PC Transfer

ikaynak | 5.4.10 @ 11:03AM

thanks.

guo | 7.1.10 @ 5:08AM

www.wmvconverterformac.com

More Articles From Feature

http://spectator.org/archives/2009/02/01/providing-relief-from-the-cris

ADVERTISEMENT

SPONSORED LINKS

FLASHBACK TO: 1995

Clip of the Day

ADVERTISEMENT