The American Spectator

home
ADVERTISEMENT
Print Email
Text Size

Special Report

The Festival Is Over

President Obama's inauguration generated excitement, but his speech fell flat. Can he meet the unprecedented expectations for his administration?

(Page 2 of 2)

As far as this goes, Obama isn't breaking new ground. In his own first inaugural address, Reagan said, "Now, so there will be no misunderstanding, it is not my intention to do away with government. It is, rather, to make it work…"

The debate isn't over whether or not government should work -- good luck finding one politician who touts ineffective government. The debate is over whether a smaller or larger government works better, and about the criteria for measuring what constitutes a working government.

For Reagan in 1981, government needed to "work with us, not over us; to stand by our side, not ride on our back. Government can and must provide opportunity, not smother it; foster productivity, not stifle it." While for Obama in 2009, government is working if "it helps families find jobs at a decent wage, care they can afford, [and] a retirement that is dignified."

Obama also insisted that the question isn't "whether the market is a force for good or ill. Its power to generate wealth and expand freedom is unmatched, but this crisis has reminded us that without a watchful eye, the market can spin out of control…"

But that statement is meaningless, because a "watchful eye" can mean anything from an NFL referee to Big Brother.


IN FOREIGN AND NATIONAL security policy, Obama's statements are no less problematic. He wants to renew America's leadership role in the world and reach out the hand of friendship to all willing countries. But in this world of jealous nations, sometimes befriending one nation alienates another.

Also, in what is being touted as a clear break with the Bush administration, Obama "reject[ed] as false the choice between our safety and our ideals." But even before taking the oath of office, Obama already stretched his timeline for closing Guantanamo Bay to within his first term, and has recognized it’s a much more complicated process than he let on during the campaign.

Ever since he launched his candidacy nearly two years ago, Obama has been able to use well-crafted rhetoric to paper over contradictory signals, and his lack of executive experience created questions about how he would govern. Would he rule from the center or left? Is he a radical or a political pragmatist? Will he be a transformational liberal leader or a merely another Democratic president?

This morning, as President Obama awakes from a night of revelry with the entire nation rooting for him, the guessing game will be over, and the American people will begin to judge him on the decisions he makes, and the results.

Page:   12

About the Author

Philip Klein is The American Spectator's Washington correspondent. You can follow him on Twitter at: http://twitter.com/Philipaklein

Letter to the Editor View all comments (55) | Leave a comment

Jason| 1.21.09 @ 6:31AM

"...the American people will begin to judge him on the decisions he makes, and the results."

So help us, God.
http://www.rightklik.net/

Michael L. Hauschild| 1.21.09 @ 7:15AM

I recall a Explorer Scout meeting where my scout leader, an “Elder” in my church, lamented to me “The country was ruined because we had elected a ‘Catholic.’” Other than my first exposure to “a Card” I also remember that he could not look me in the eye as he said it. I expect quite a bit of that same involuntary behavior soon.

Jeremiah| 1.21.09 @ 7:54AM

I've attached a link to Safire's analysis of the speech, which is strong and reasonable.

Lots of cynicism here at the Spectator.

Jason's right. Obama will be judged by his decisions.

Yesterday, he made some important decisions in his address.

He decided to go with a sturdy, lecturish, somewhat sinewy speech.

He purged his rhetoric of black country-preacher rhetoric: no rousing emotionalism.

This was an important political distinction, and a signal he's now president, not Inspirer in Chief.

In the scheme of things it probably won't be that important an event, but I respect him for it.

Robert Rosencrans| 1.21.09 @ 8:50AM

The speech was ridiculous because all it did was tell people to fall in line. That's not an American principle.

Gerard E.| 1.21.09 @ 9:22AM

If the speech fell flat, it is due to how he is somewhat sobered by the responsibilities to come. How the bad guys of the world- yes, Obamaites, we mean Iran, Syria, etc.- will test him early and often. How the Dow reacted Tuesday with a 300-point downturn. On the heels of significant layoffs at Warner Bros., Clear Channel, Rohm and Haas. Under the crushing weight of his most devout supporters. The fun stopped after the last dance with Michele. Now it gets serious.

HOPE| 1.21.09 @ 9:42AM

Americans cannot expect miracles, the economy is in a grave and dire situation. This problem could go on for 10 years and even longer.

The thing about wars they cost money. Droppping a 5 Million Dollar bomb on any city killing civillians, and when it comes to dropping 100 bombs in a day, it's a lot of money.

Americans bankrupted it self, a few poor people buying houses cannot bankrupt a country the size of America, it's far deeper than that.

Obama will do his best, to move the country towards productivity in new technology, which is the only way forward.

Americans needs a new way of thinking, everything does not need to end in a war.

The thing that America needs to avoid is a world war. Because these types of depression normally result in world war.

If people refuse to learn they will suffer.

ncatty| 1.21.09 @ 9:48AM

He has come a long way since Iowa, hasn't he? I am talking about the distance from his left position then to his centrist position now. It doesn't bother me but it must stun those on the left. Anyway, he is our president now so God bless him.

Dustoff| 1.21.09 @ 10:44AM

Have any of you seen the pictures of these areas after big bash.
It's a huge trash dump!
So much for caring about the land.

Anthony| 1.21.09 @ 10:55AM

Actually, I found the speech to be better than some of the critiques given, but still not a great speech by any streach. That said, Mr. Obama has a herculean task ahead for himself. He remains a complete unknown to both his supporters and his critics. His true moral compass is a mystery; his core beliefs shrouded in conflicting rhetoric. We really don't know what makes this man tick. Seldom in the history of this republic has a man been elected to the presidency that has been so completely unvetted by the media and the citizens who elected him, shocking given today's technology, but not so, given the political bent of the MSM. He can be the long sought for "progressive" that will finally fulfill the dying wishes of the radical '60s generation, or a man tempered by the awesome power and responsibilities of the office, such that he will transcend his philosophical bent in the acknowledgment of the unique greatness of our constitutional republic. Then again, he might not be either; he just might be an over achiever that even his ego can't help save, and we will flounder as a nation for 4 years in a deep transformative economic malaise. God help us all, the mystery is about to unfold.

L. Ross| 1.21.09 @ 11:21AM

Hope:

I hate to break it to you, but this credit crisis is a lot bigger than just a few poor people buying homes they couldn't afford. This is about a failed effort to restructure the entire mortgage industry in the United States. The 60 to 150% increase in home value between 2000 and 2007, followed by the ongoing crash of the last two years is plenty to destroy the economy of this country.

Judging from what you wrote, I'm guessing that you have never made a mortgage payment, and don't quite understand how inter-related all this is.

Yes, wars cost a lot of money, but I don't recall the U.S. getting into financial trouble because of a war. The usually boost the economy.

Tim| 1.21.09 @ 11:27AM

L. Ross,
You bring up an excellent point and one that very few folks have dared to discuss which is to say that Obama may be forced to engage the USA in a huge war..........to help get us out of this economic mess.....
and wouldn't that be the Irony of Ironies?

Jeff| 1.21.09 @ 11:38AM

I wonder how many carbon credits they had to purchase to offset the CO2 emissions from the huge heaters they had in place yesterday.

Gene| 1.21.09 @ 11:44AM

Hey Anthony , you nailed it, it has been said "they know not what they voted for.

Ammo Guy| 1.21.09 @ 12:06PM

I was forced to listen to this speech because they piped it into the hangar at Andrews Air Force Base where I and my family were waiting to bid President Bush and his family a gracious farewell. IMHO, President Bush's impromptu remarks to us before he left were more eloquent and heartfelt than anything I heard from our new President...but then, I'm a W fan whose mind is not clouded by BDS. For those who care, I thought President Bush looked more relaxed than I've seen him in years and we wished him a long and pleasant retirement. OK, now let me have it...I simply don't care anymore.

james23| 1.21.09 @ 12:37PM

Drudge showing a picture of DC after the Obamuration. What a pig sty!

JoshFranklin| 1.21.09 @ 1:16PM

"The American people will begin to judge him on the decisions he makes, and the results." But don't forget the large segment of Kool-Aid drinking Americans who will judge him on a curve based on his predecessor's approval ratings. Even gross misconduct on the part of The Anointed One will be met by them with "Yeah? Well ... Bush Sucks".

Michael L. Hauschild| 1.21.09 @ 1:40PM

Ammo Guy,
I may be as ignorant as some suggest. After all I never quibbled and fought those commies for Richard Nixon with one hand tied behind my back. But I know one thing for sure, Petraeus with his Bush ordered surge to victory beats Kissenger and his "peace with honor" all to hell. I for one wish I would have been standing there with you in that hanger, at attention and saluting.

Michele San Pietro| 1.21.09 @ 3:00PM

I hoped Obama would not repeat Clinton's mistake of spending loads of money for the inauguration. Regrettably, I was proven wrong. Now that the festival is over, I hope Obama will do something concrete in order to keep his promises. Everybody is able to talk, but not everybody is able to act.

Anthony| 1.21.09 @ 3:17PM

Ammo Guy, Thanks for helping give President Bush the send off he and Laura deserved. I wish I could have joined you, millions of rational people do as well. Fox was the only station to show his Texas return speech, I had tears in my eyes watching it. It was eloquence from conviction, not eloquence from rhetorical style. Sums up the man quite well, I think. Hang in there buddy, we need you!!

Dustoff| 1.21.09 @ 3:19PM

Obama freezes the pay of his new people making over 100.000. Really Barry, so what do they make to start off with.

First day and already the BS is flowing.

Alan brooks| 1.21.09 @ 3:26PM

nothing wrong with Obama, it is those such as Jeremiah who have filters wired into their skulls disenabling them from understanding the basics; they can comprehend the details but not the fundamental flaws of human nature and govt.
O. can smooth things over but many of those who work for him will remain hacks. and now is the age of diverse hacks; equal opportunity hacks; multicultural hacks. govt mules with masters in political science and so forth who, like the losel (not lozel) demented, witless cad Jeremiah (Have A "Nice" Day:) are smart but-- like my family-- just cant think on it: men are swine and that is reflected in govt. As Lieberman said, O. can do wonderful things for this country, but pigs are pigs, and since some have to be sacrificed on the altar of status and govt power, that causes a bit of un-grooviness, un-copacetic behavior, verbiage and unending confusion. but we'll stumble through merrily on our way.
forget i mentioned it, you phony liberal fake. its payback time, homeboy!
you know who.

rssg| 1.21.09 @ 3:52PM

The enemy is Islam and when the West finally wakens to this, there will be hope. Not until then.

The USA needs to stop all immigration, especially Moooslim immigration.

Melvin | 1.21.09 @ 3:56PM

Liberals leave the Washington Mall looking like a garbage heap. (picture on Drudge) but that is to be expected because th typical Liberal mindset of, "Hey it wasn't our fault, your just being racist."

Alan Brooks| 1.21.09 @ 3:58PM

Muslim men cant help it theyre pigs. it's their EDUKATION
hope that can be said without harming anyone's wittle bitty self esteem.

and far be it from ex libs to get uppity.

Bush hater| 1.21.09 @ 4:55PM

George W. Bush is a baby killin' asshole!!!

Alan Brooks| 1.21.09 @ 5:03PM

Bush HATER! youre baaaaccckkk
aww how sweet.
and cute of you.
naturally, none of us really WANTS to make waves or cause trouble. were just twying to be understanding... to find ourselfies... to grow....to gwow, be more tolerant of violent aminals who are oppwessed, who need love like Idi Amin and Stalin, Pol Pot and Jeffwie Damner needed love.
we are so tolerant (except of those around us we dont like) so big of us to be BIG hearted and be cute to those poor 'pressed peole far far away

Alan Brooks| 1.21.09 @ 5:06PM

of course we mustn't be cynical... we must be loving and sweet and cute and as condescending as we can without being religious about it.

bush hater you twit, you imbecilic piece of you know what...

Robert Rosencrans| 1.21.09 @ 6:22PM

Here is the best piece I've read yet of why Obama should not be beyond criticism. It points out what I've said, that those who do not point out the flawsare actually doing him a disservice. This is from Juan Williams, NPR, and a regular on FOX. I always thought it was kind of daffy to have he and Gloria Borger on FOX, basically two quasi-governmental employees. Anyway, it's the read of the day.
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB123249791178500439.html

It is neither overweening emotion nor partisanship to see King's moral universe bending toward justice in the act of the first non-white man taking the oath of the presidency. But now that this moment has arrived, there is a question: How shall we judge our new leader?

If his presidency is to represent the full power of the idea that black Americans are just like everyone else -- fully human and fully capable of intellect, courage and patriotism -- then Barack Obama has to be subject to the same rough and tumble of political criticism experienced by his predecessors. To treat the first black president as if he is a fragile flower is certain to hobble him. It is also to waste a tremendous opportunity for improving race relations by doing away with stereotypes and seeing the potential in all Americans.

Yet there is fear, especially among black people, that criticism of him or any of his failures might be twisted into evidence that people of color cannot effectively lead. That amounts to wasting time and energy reacting to hateful stereotypes. It also leads to treating all criticism of Mr. Obama, whether legitimate, wrong-headed or even mean-spirited, as racist.

This is patronizing. Worse, it carries an implicit presumption of inferiority. Every American president must be held to the highest standard. No president of any color should be given a free pass for screw-ups, lies or failure to keep a promise.

During the Democrats' primaries and caucuses, candidate Obama often got affectionate if not fawning treatment from the American media. Editors, news anchors, columnists and commentators, both white and black but especially those on the political left, too often acted as if they were in a hurry to claim their role in history as supporters of the first black president.

For example, Mr. Obama was forced to give a speech on race as a result of revelations that he'd long attended a church led by a demagogue. It was an ordinary speech. At best it was successful at minimizing a political problem. Yet some in the media equated it to the Gettysburg Address.

The importance of a proud, adversarial press speaking truth about a powerful politician and offering impartial accounts of his actions was frequently and embarrassingly lost. When Mr. Obama's opponents, such as the Clintons, challenged his lack of experience, or pointed out that he was not in the U.S. Senate when he expressed early opposition to the war in Iraq, they were depicted as petty.

Bill Clinton got hit hard when he called Mr. Obama's claims to be a long-standing opponent of the Iraq war "the biggest fairy tale I've ever seen." The former president accurately said that there was no difference in actual Senate votes on the war between his wife and Mr. Obama. But his comments were not treated by the press as legitimate, hard-ball political fighting. They were cast as possibly racist.

This led to Saturday Night Live's mocking skit -- where the debate moderator was busy hammering the other Democratic nominees with tough questions while inquiring if Mr. Obama was comfortable and needed more water.

When fellow Democrats contending for the nomination rightly pointed to Mr. Obama's thin proposals for dealing with terrorism and extricating the U.S. from Iraq, they were drowned out by loud if often vacuous shouts for change. Yet in the general election campaign and during the transition period, Mr. Obama steadily moved to his former opponents' positions. In fact, he approached Bush-Cheney stands on immunity for telecommunications companies that cooperate in warrantless surveillance.

Alan Brooks| 1.21.09 @ 6:37PM

we need humor in these lite times. read Gore Vidal's piece on why tim mcveigh was oppwessed.

written may '01, right before timmy went to that great gun show in the sky.

ruth| 1.22.09 @ 2:32AM

B. Hater, may you drown in your own bile. Ammo, no worries, you (and W.) are among friends here. I am glad that the President can finally rest. He looks so tired. I know I couldn't have done what he did. May God bless him for his stalwart efforts on our behalf.

Michele San Pietro| 1.22.09 @ 3:10PM

It's not just a matter of rejecting all Muslim immigrants. Not all Muslims are islamic fundamentalists. You should rather reject all foreigners who don't respect the USA, who continuously say it is an absurd country that should not exist. Believe me, they are many in Europe, too, including my Italy: I get insulted by them every single day.

HOPE| 1.22.09 @ 5:35PM

L ROSS.

You don't think I have ever made a mortgage payment in my life, you should not generalise so much. I have brought 3 homes in the last 35 years and have a 16.000 mortgage.

HOPE| 1.22.09 @ 5:47PM

The Wall Street shuffel, naked short selling, is what caused the crash. The stockmarket crash has nothing to do with poor people buying homes.

The BAILOUT is going into a black hole of debt. America is paying 3 BILLION per day in interest payments to her creditors, and will default.
The Chinese don't want anymore of US Bonds, because they are worthless like the American dollars. So here is the solution they want assets for the debts.

The healthcare bubble is next to collapse.

America is just a major counterfeiting operation, that has ran its course.

Alan Brooks| 1.22.09 @ 8:09PM

"nothing to do" ? with poor people...

yeah sure,

Alan Brooks| 1.22.09 @ 8:45PM

couldn't be Daphnes comment two posts above, it is too careful in its spelling.

Alan Brooks| 1.22.09 @ 9:50PM

'lots of cynics here' at amspec, sayeth the jeremiad.

THEN GO ELSEWHERE, YOU PUTZ

Hope| 1.23.09 @ 1:23PM

Hello people it's time to have a laugh and cheer yourselves up.

You can all learn from your mistakes, or continue the same way.

Look up Youtube Part 1/2 Bird & fortune financial crisis silly money Nov 08. If that does not make you laugh nothing will.

Michele San Pietro| 1.24.09 @ 4:02PM

It's incredibile how died-in-the-wool anti-Americans have been repeating the same crap for decades. Every time they predict the forthcoming collapse of America. And yet, America is still there.

Pingback| 1.28.09 @ 3:49AM

Pajamas Media » Has Obama Derangement Syndrome Arrived? links to this page.

jjhjh| 11.18.09 @ 8:10PM

Mac TOD Converter,
TOD Converter for Windows

dsfs| 1.11.10 @ 2:25AM

FLV to WMV Converter,
Free FLV to WMV converter

Leave a Comment

N.B. We encourage readers to share and discuss their thoughtful and relevant comments about this Spectator article. Comments are routinely monitored and will be deleted if profane, bigoted, or grossly impolite. Please be respectful. (And don't feed the trolls!) Thank you.

More Articles by Philip Klein

More Articles From Special Report

http://spectator.org/archives/2009/01/21/the-festival-is-over
ADVERTISEMENT

Clip of the Day

Most Popular Articles

Who Castrated Ann Coulter?

David Catron | 2.6.12

Bigoted Barack, Red in Tooth and Clause

George Neumayr | 2.10.12

Unsafe at Any Smoke

Eric Peters | 2.10.12

Access This

Ross Kaminsky | 2.10.12

The Show Me State's No Show Primary

Andrew B. Wilson | 2.10.12

Justice Ginsburg Should Resign

William Tucker | 2.8.12

The Delousing of a Movement

R. Emmett Tyrrell, Jr. | 2.9.12

ADVERTISEMENT