The American Spectator

home
ADVERTISEMENT
Reader Mail
Print Email
Text Size

Reader Mail

Far From the Tree

Apostates of the right. Health careless. Not buying what the media's selling. Plus more.

(Page 2 of 3)

I, for one, reject socialized medicine in its entirety. For that matter, I would vote for the first politician who vowed to repeal the Social Security Act and apply my money instead to the national debt. You see, I have no fear of my impending old age nor do I fear of suffering, either physically or economically, if that should one day prove to be my fate. Many have suffered before me so that I might live in freedom. What I do fear, however, is the judgment of my grand-children, whose future we have mortgaged through our selfish desire to live better lives at their expense. To me, it is shameful and immoral for the generation of Americans now living to burden with indebtedness those as yet unborn. 

Each time I bounce my grandson on my knee, I can't help wondering what his son will think of me when his history professor one day informs him that the Age of Freedom ended because Great-Grandpa failed pay his bills. 

-- Thomas Donley

PUNISHINGLY NIHILISTIC

Re: James Bowman's review of Burn After Reading:

The Coens' movies at times evidence a nihilist view of existence (always an absurdist view). I found Burn After Reading to be punishingly nihilistic. A bitter disappointment after the great No Country for Old Men. I also found the Coens to have no affection or respect for their characters in this movie, settling on one dimensional and unbelievable traits and actions. Only Ted's character rises above, and Richard Jenkins does such a great job that McDormand, Pitt and Clooney are left far behind in showier, yet empty roles. And Malkovich sings one note only. His character quickly became tiresome and predictable. Who cares what happens to any of them? The Coens never give us a reason to care. Madcap comedies work when the characterizations are sharp and the characters are likeable, even if flawed or villainous. In the end, this "comedy" commits the unforgivable sin of being not funny.
-- Roger McCrary

WE'RE SUPPOSED TO THINK THEY'RE BETTER?

Re: Larry Thornberry's Did I Hear That Right?

The media has me a little confused... I'm supposed to vote against McCain because George Bush has been a failure... On the other hand, I'm supposed to vote the Democrat Congress back in and increase their numbers, even though they've been in control for the past two years, and even though things were fine before they took over, and even though their approval rating is around 10%...Help me out here, media.

-- G.Gonzalez
Loreto, Texas

RESPECT UNEARNED

Re: H.W. Crocker, III's How Would Jefferson Davis Vote?

Jefferson Davis was morally blind.

A practicing Christian, he could read the words of Jesus but could not see the evil that was at the heart of his rebellion.

Jefferson Davis through his actions bequeathed to this nation a legacy of sorrow for both white and black Americans from which we have yet to be delivered.

Page:   12 3  

Letter to the Editor View all comments (8) | Leave a comment

Thomas Donley| 10.22.08 @ 8:51AM

Ms. Smith, you once wrote a letter to the editor in this publication responding to a letter that I, in turn, had written regarding the Virginia Tech shootings. Therein, you very graciously credited me by saying that it had taken "some courage" to express my particular opinion. I now return the favor.

Your defense of George Bush also shows some courage, especially considering his unpopularity and the vehemence with which he is hated by the political left. You are quite right, of course, that he has done an admirable job of preventing another terrorist attack on American soil. With regard to his economic performance, many blame him for the current economic crisis. Those who do neglect the fact Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae were largely created through liberal legislative initiative and were managed by those of liberal pursuasion. They also neglect the fact that many liberals, including Al Gore and Bill Clinton, grew rich during George Bush's administration. Further neglected is the fact that the downturn we now experience began after the Democratic Party took control of Congress, the only branch of government which can approve expenditures. Also left unsaid by our national media, which so bitterly criticizes his economic performance, is the fact that his administration, during a time of war, was also forced to cope with two natural disasters of epic proportions - events which cost staggeringly large sums of money to cope with.
It is to his credit that the nation was not brought to it's knees.

Like you, I have a grandson whom I would never desert for any reason, much less for something as trivial as the outcome of an election. Your grandchildren are fortunate to have so noble a grandmother as yourself, and I hope that they one day find pride in the fact that your courageous voice brings both truth and clarity to this epic battle to preserve traditional American culture.

Kate Shaw| 10.22.08 @ 9:56AM

Ms. Smith, I have travelled extensively in my youth and am glad for the chance as many of the places I have been are either too dangerous or too dilapidated to revisit now. Only Singapore remains on my list of To Go ... except, of course, for the one place I have longed to visit since I was a girl of 10: outer space.

I am living in Canada (Kanukistan) now and recommend that for anyone in the USA whose eyes see "Here Be Dragons" outside their own borders, a stint in a really socialist and collapsing country run by ants for the benefit of a growing horde of locusts, to step across the border and live in Toronto for five years as One Of Us and understand thoroughly and completely what Obama stands for and how Not Fun it will be.

James M. Farrell| 10.22.08 @ 11:50AM

Ms. Smith: May God always bless you. I am a temporary ex-pat living in far southern Mexico in the beautiful town of San Cristobal de Las Casas. I've been here not quite one year and there are quite a few retired American ex-pats here, the preponderance of whom are Old School Liberals who, if I take them at their word, have considerable contempt for the nation of their birth. I had the unfortunate pleasure of viewing the debates with many of them as a group. Not only was I shocked by the level of their animosity towards President Bush and Senator Mc Cain but a few drinks opened many of them up to the degree that they averred their hope that President Obama and a radical Left Congress would "bring America to its knees!"

Many of these otherwise decent folks have children and grandchildren in the States! When asked about how their political fantasies would affect their offspring they openly confess that they really don't care; an America with a diminished role in the world would be worth the price! I guess we're all lucky they are here in Mexico and not marauding around in the lower 48!

Thank you for being there and taking care of our future!

David Govett| 10.22.08 @ 1:21PM

Reasonable or not, if elected Obama will determine the competence of future black presidential candidates in the minds of white Americans. Should he fail to defend the U.S. against enemies foreign and domestic, should he damage the economy, it is unlikely another black would be elected for many, many years.

Diane Smith| 10.22.08 @ 11:08PM

Thank you, Thomas Donley, Kate Shaw and James Farrell for your kind words. Aging grandmas sometimes speak at their own peril, so enthralled as they are in their roles - a kind of combination Mary Poppins and Glenda the Good Witch. I took a vow when I was 59 that not a grandchild of mine would ever see the inside of a day care center and furthermore would never be entrusted to a 17 year old Nicaraguan "nanny" - so my first grandson is a senior at UC Davis and is on the campus fire department. My middle one has followed his brother to becoming an Eagle Scout and a member of the high school water polo team. The six year old is with me 10 hours a day, 5 days a week and doesn't understand how 81 one year old Diane is not delighted to lay miles of Thomas the Train track all over my house. When I started on this last one, an acquaintance asked me if I hadn't learned my lesson with the first two..."When you could be traveling - you could be anywhere you want to be - -" I interrupted with "I am anywhere I want to be - in a nursery rocking chair with a baby in my lap."

Kate - when I was a little girl, I had an aunt who loved to drive my bothers and me on long vacations. When we got older, we teased her a little that our entire trips were in second gear - but one of the places we went was Lake Louise - but that was maybe 1938, But I have been to Canada. My problem with traveling the world is every urchin you see on your way to marvel at the Taj Mahal - - well, I want to take them back to the hotel, give them a bath and order room service. If you are ever in SF - I am 15 minutes from the airport - I'll buy you lunch.

And, Mr. Farrell, thank you for confirming my dark thoughts about folks who cut and run to wherever their money will go the farthest in retirement. We used to go fishing in Mazatlan when I was young, and I met a few of them then. How do these folks bear not being around to teach their grandchildren to read? My six year old reads - with expresssion and full comprehensison - at 5th grade level and I take credit for some of it.

Diane Smith

ruth| 10.23.08 @ 1:05AM

Diane, I've been reading your AmSpec Letters to the Editor for years and i have enjoyed every one! I must say though-- a Texas girl in San Francisco, i think i feel sorry for you. Lovely town but so liberal! (and I'm a SoCal native) I lived at Stanford for five years and loved it but was glad to return to my Red County roots. Your grandsons are so blessed to have you. Ruth

Thomas Donley| 10.23.08 @ 1:43AM

Ms. Smith:

No thanks are necessary because, to the contrary, it is I who owe you gratitude. Your many letters I've read on this site have provided me with much insight and, more importantly, your admirable and steadfast devotion to your family enriches my heart beyond measure.

My - 81 years old! How I would love to spend an afternoon gleaning the wisdom of your perspective! Alas, while I do love to travel, I'm afraid I prefer the beauty and tranquility of my historic Michigan farm to that of urban California. Be that as it may, should you ever foresee a trip to my state, please know that my family and I would be truely honored to offer you and yours warm, clean beds and home-cooked meals fresh from our bountiful garden.

Take good care, Ms. Smith, and thank you sincerely for the inspiration your letters unfailingly provide to us all.

Thomas Donley

Ms. Know| 10.30.08 @ 12:41AM

All those buying into the socialist illuminati promises will soon be hurt when they find out it was a scam. From the no tax increase, to the healthcare.

Leave a Comment

N.B. We encourage readers to share and discuss their thoughtful and relevant comments about this Spectator article. Comments are routinely monitored and will be deleted if profane, bigoted, or grossly impolite. Please be respectful. (And don't feed the trolls!) Thank you.

More Articles From Reader Mail

http://spectator.org/archives/2008/10/22/far-from-the-tree
ADVERTISEMENT

Clip of the Day

Most Popular Articles

Who Castrated Ann Coulter?

David Catron | 2.6.12

Bigoted Barack, Red in Tooth and Clause

George Neumayr | 2.10.12

Unsafe at Any Smoke

Eric Peters | 2.10.12

Access This

Ross Kaminsky | 2.10.12

The Delousing of a Movement

R. Emmett Tyrrell, Jr. | 2.9.12

The Show Me State's No Show Primary

Andrew B. Wilson | 2.10.12

Justice Ginsburg Should Resign

William Tucker | 2.8.12

No Double Play

Peter Hannaford | 2.10.12

ADVERTISEMENT