The American Spectator

Reader Mail

(Page 8 of 14)

LEAVE THE KIDS AT HOME br> Re: David N. Bass's Batman Turns Bad : /p>

Mr. Bass it is clear you are no comic book fan. If you were, then you would not only be happy with the Dark Knight's presentation, you would know from where it comes. Batman, the comic, was never the campy, funny defender of truth and justice that the 1960's television show would lead you to believe. While you are absolutely correct that parents should do more research before they take their children to such a dark movie filled with adult situations, this movie is a faithful adaptation of the Batman comics. Then again, the Dark Knight's portrayal of Batman would also present scores of parents with good opportunity to talk about the difficulty of making good moral decisions. It's filled with imagery of the difficulty of the protector archetype. How do you fight the most evil, sadistic, and dangerous of people without becoming something like them? How can you keep yourself from going over the edge and into the pit of despair? I'm not going to attempt to answer these questions, I have no experience upon which to draw, not even second-hand. Instead, the Dark Knight makes a good-faith effort to answer these questions as does the comic book that is its inspirational source.

For all of you parents out there who wonder why comic book movies can be so dark and dangerous, try to remember something, please. Comic books are not necessarily for kids. Just because they have pictures in them doesn't mean the storylines or the characters are the kind of saccharine caricatures that we normally associate with children's entertainment. In Frank Miller's (yes, the same Frank Miller who did Sin City and 300) rendition of Batman, called The Dark Knight Returns, the Joker beats Robin to death with a crowbar. Let us not forget that Bruce Wayne is motivated by the senseless killing of his parents right in front of him when he was a child. Again, not something we normally associate with children's movies, is it? How "child friendly" is a story about a vigilante anyways? Batman has always been, from the very beginning, a story of a vigilante detective, struggling against the darkness of his city even as he struggles against the darkness within himself.

Wonder Woman was written by a polygamist (really). It's filled with imagery and storylines dealing with polygamy and homosexuality. X-Men characters are killed, mutilated, and otherwise darkly affected on a continual basis. Some of the latest storylines include battles between Wolverine and Cyclopes that end with Cyclopes dead and Wolverine missing a hand. Even Superman and Spiderman, the two most "wholesome" of DC and Marvel's main comic lines, have had their dark days.

The reason that Batman Begins and The Dark Knight are such very good films is that they stay true to the story and themes of the Batman storyline. The actors provide amazing performances and the screen writers are excellent, which helps their cause. But they wouldn't be such good movies if they attempted to return to the camp and silliness of the Batman TV show. For supporting evidence, I provide you with Batman Forever and Batman and Robin, both made good money but both were horrible movies.

I don't think the studios are really marketing this movie for children. The previews that I saw (and I saw plenty) all suggest the dark and dangerous atmosphere of the movie. And as for the action-figures, try to remember a couple of things. First, the collection of move-based toys has been a part of the geek subculture (the subculture that breaths and breeds comic books) sense the Star Wars days. And second, you can buy your child a Dark Knight action figure without taking them to see the movie.

p>And finally, I'm not about to suggest taking your child to see this movie. I wouldn't take mine, I know the Batman series well enough to know better. But once she has turned the corner into the double-digit range and shows the maturity to understand such dark and complex themes, I will have a different approach. However, when you consider the plethora of influences out there right now, you can do a lot worse than a brooding Dark Knight. br> -- Charles Campbell br> Austin, Texas /p>

topics:
Health Care, John McCain, Television, Business, Abortion, Books, Movies, Law, Military, Russia, NATO, Africa, Conservatism, Immigration, Oil