The American Spectator

home
ADVERTISEMENT
Reader Mail
Print Email
Text Size

Reader Mail

Judicial Activists Strike Again

Let the states string 'em up. Mad in Massachusetts. Mystery Machiavellian. Plus more.

(Page 3 of 20)

br> -- Glen Hoffing br> Camden, New Jersey /p> p> Nice argument, but that's the kind of policy that LEGISLATURES discuss. The SCOTUS was limited to deciding if it was "cruel or unusual" under the Constitution. You've fallen prey to the liberal mindset: "Tyranny is OK if I get what I want." br> -- Matthew Eckel, J.D. /p>

I agree in the main with Mr. Tucker's conclusion that the death penalty should be reserved for murder. (In the main, because what about treason during war?)

However, Tucker sidestepped the real question: what gives the Supreme Court the right to overturn a Louisiana statute regarding punishment of offenders? Presumably this statute was passed by the legislature of Louisiana, a duly elected body representative of the people of Louisiana.

Where in the Constitution is the Supreme Court given the right to interfere in domestic matters involving crime and punishment? Cruel and unusual punishment (8th Amendment) is a limitation on the Federal government, not on the States. And even if it were a limitation on the States, it's primarily a limitation on the process of punishment (torture, drawing & quartering, etc.) prior to execution, not on the sentence itself.

p>Our country is no longer governed by the People (WE the People), but is instead government by five or six unelected judges, who through a spurious incorporation doctrine, continue to usurp the rights of the People to self-determination in the pursuit of happiness (and that includes making laws and punishments to effect that purpose). br> -- Vern Crisler br> Gilbert, Arizona
Page:   1 23 4 5   Last ›

topics:
Trade, Barack Obama, Business, Federal Budget, Satire, Religion, Islam, Environment, Constitution, Law, Supreme Court, Iraq, NATO, Fascism, Conservatism, Libertarianism, Oil

Letter to the Editor View all comments (4) | Leave a comment

mtejrtj| 3.18.10 @ 1:38AM

Quite excellent anfshop!

mrrty| 3.18.10 @ 1:39AM

Share the xcar with your best friends!

Leave a Comment

N.B. We encourage readers to share and discuss their thoughtful and relevant comments about this Spectator article. Comments are routinely monitored and will be deleted if profane, bigoted, or grossly impolite. Please be respectful. (And don't feed the trolls!) Thank you.

Related Articles

More Articles From Reader Mail

http://spectator.org/archives/2008/06/27/judicial-activists-strike-agai
ADVERTISEMENT

Clip of the Day

Most Popular Articles

Who Castrated Ann Coulter?

David Catron | 2.6.12

Bigoted Barack, Red in Tooth and Clause

George Neumayr | 2.10.12

Unsafe at Any Smoke

Eric Peters | 2.10.12

Access This

Ross Kaminsky | 2.10.12

The Delousing of a Movement

R. Emmett Tyrrell, Jr. | 2.9.12

The Show Me State's No Show Primary

Andrew B. Wilson | 2.10.12

Justice Ginsburg Should Resign

William Tucker | 2.8.12

No Double Play

Peter Hannaford | 2.10.12

ADVERTISEMENT