The American Spectator

home
ADVERTISEMENT
Political Hay
Print Email
Text Size

Political Hay

Placebo Propaganda

Sicko scores some points against HMO's. Otherwise, it's as potent as sweetened cough drops.

(Page 2 of 2)

, Guido Sigler Amaya, is in pretty bad shape: br> /p>
Due to the inhumane prison conditions he is forced to endure Guido is suffering from more than ten serious illnesses: oral infection with bleeding sores on his gums and tongue, hypertension, renal and duodenal cysts, chronic gastritis and migraines, dilatation of the aorta, partial loss of vision, inflamed prostate, premature aging, excessive weight loss, difficulty in ambulation, dehydration, thrombosed hemorrhoids with one surgical intervention and more planned.
br> Alas, that would have undermined that Bash-America-First theme of Sicko .

Some conservatives are worried that Sicko will move us in the direction of socialized medicine. I doubt it. While Sicko may inform the health care debate in this country for the next month or so, it will probably have about as much impact on our health care system as Fahrenheit 9/11 had on the 2004 election — which is to say, not much. Through contacts in the film industry, conservative author Byron York discovered that Moore’s Fahrenheit 9/11 had outperformed expectations in “Blue America” areas like San Francisco, Los Angeles and New York City, but underperformed in “Red America” areas like the Midwest. Chances are, Moore’s new love affair with big government will suffer a similar fate. Furthermore, its timing leaves something to be desired, being released over a year before the next presidential election, when it might have had a much bigger effect.

Besides, with the exception of some folks on the left, most Americans probably realize by now that Moore is not really a documentary maker. He’s just a propagandist.

David Hogberg is a Washington writer and host of the website Health Hog.

Page:   12

topics:
Education, Health Care, Movies

About the Author

David Hogberg is a senior fellow at the National Center for Public Policy Research. Follow him on Twitter.

Letter to the Editor View all comments (2) |

JudgeX | 10.28.08 @ 11:37AM

For an article so one-sided, I was amazed that you didn't really provide any evidence for what was wrong with Sicko.

He "shot himself in the foot" by knocking on our public education system after heralding publicly funded other things? What? You know, Moore was relying on you to have an IQ over 90 for that one. You have to realize that since France, UK, and USA have publicly funded education systems, and, France, UK, Canada, Australia, etc all have well educated students who perform better in tests, that OUR IMPLEMENTATION is lacking, not our METHOD OF FUNDING.

I'm sure he didn't delve into that because he, foolishly, expected us to THINK about his film rather than sit and try to call him out on every nuance.

Wake up and learn what insurance companies are saying about "pre-existing conditions" before you propose that it isn't about profit.

You harp on the problem with HMOs being the government regulations rather than the greedy profit machine. What regulations? Sorry if I'm being daft, I'm not a lawyer, but, what regulation forces an HMO to decline me treatment for congenital defects or high blood pressure that I acquired prior to getting "coverage"?

Feel free to shoot me an e-mail and let me know.

Related Articles

More Articles by David Hogberg

More Articles From Political Hay

http://spectator.org/archives/2007/06/26/placebo-propaganda

ADVERTISEMENT

SPONSORED LINKS

FLASHBACK TO: 1995

Clip of the Day

ADVERTISEMENT