When a reporter botches the facts in his very first sentence, is he sloppy or dishonest? I respect Ryan Lizza’s work, and the meticulous research invested in his profile on Sen. George Allen. Yet from the first sentence, the perspective through which Lizza is reading Allen is clear: Allen’s a Southern racist hick, and a fake at that.
As it happens, I am also writing a profile on Senator Allen. In the middle of this yesterday, I read that the New Republic has a piece on Allen coming out. ABC News’s The Note carried excerpts hours before TNR published it on its website. TNR must have released it to them. So it thinks it has a pretty hot story on its hands.
The article is a hit piece. Lizza brings up the old stories about Allen hanging a Confederate flag in his Earlysville home and a noose in his law office. He dutifully reports that Allen, like many Virginians, opposed placing Martin Luther King Jr. Day on Lee-Jackson Day. He joined a “Richmond social club with a well-known history of discrimination” (sounds like Augusta National).
Which part did TNR release to ABC? Lizza found Allen’s high school yearbook picture, complete with Confederate flag lapel pin. He called up his acquaintances — friends and enemies — to find a football game day prank involving “racially tinged” spray paint. No one agrees what it said. Allen placed a Confederate flag on his Mustang, wore boots, and took to Johnny Cash. (And I thought Cash was cool.)
On top of that, Lizza depicts it all as an act. Allen “resembles a froufrou version of Toby Keith.” (What is that supposed to mean?) His opinions “about red-state cultural aesthetics” are “finely honed.” His “s[—]t-kickin’ image may be the subject of certain Republican consultant fantasies.” It’s a “shtick” similar to President Bush’s, but “that folksy act looks a little spent.”
THE ONLY ACT THAT LOOKS SPENT is the postmodern portrait writer following the Southern Republican politician and finding a closet racist. Lizza is awfully suspicious of Allen’s place among Virginians at one event in particular: Shad Planking.
I attended Shad Planking. From Lizza’s reporting, we must have been in the same small group of reporters (less than 15 people) surrounding Allen late in the afternoon as he interviewed with a radio station, 800 AM WSVS.
So I find it curious that Lizza’s very first sentence is “Senator George Allen is the only person in Virginia who wears cowboy boots.” I wore cowboy boots that day, just feet from Lizza.
As did a young man I met minutes later, after Senator Allen left. Ben Marchi, a Vienna, Virginia resident, was there with his buddy Howard Cook, the Marine sergeant I mentioned in my article. When I read Lizza’s line, I called Marchi and relayed it to him. Originally from Charlottesville and a Virginia resident all but a year of his life, Marchi said he “never leave[s] home without ‘em.” How many other Virginians wear cowboy boots? “South of the Rappahannock [River, which runs through Fredericksburg about 50 miles south of Alexandria], more than tune in to the New York Yankees.” Admittedly, not a high threshold. Elsewhere in the state though, Marchi said, “I’d invite whoever wrote that article to visit Floyd County on a Friday night at the country store down there.” And at Shad Planking? “I think around an event like Shad Planking it’d be pretty hard to miss people with boots on.”
In fact, cowboy boots are so common in Virginia that L. Douglas Wilder, mayor of Richmond and Allen’s predecessor as governor, was seen this week wearing a pair.
Contacted yesterday, Lizza said he “didn’t see any cowboy boots at Shad Planking except Allen’s.” Sadly, that poor reporting reflects the rest of his article. Just as he decided that there were no other cowboy boots to be found at Shad Planking, he decided that George Allen’s enthusiastic embrace of the South is disingenuous and racist. So Allen is faking it, except when he’s not.
Which one to believe? Neither. Lizza’s picture of Allen is willfully incomplete. He couldn’t find any “Confederate flags or coded racial appeals” in Allen’s stump speech, which Lizza admits he spends on substantial policy items. While Allen discusses energy policy during their interview, all Lizza can think of is the Confederate flag. In my interviews with Allen, race came up once — as the Senator’s point of departure with Thomas Jefferson’s political philosophy. In that area, he said, he prefers the thinking of George Mason, who wrote that slavery is “that slow poison, which is daily contaminating the minds and morals of our people.”
THROUGHOUT HIS ARTICLE, LIZZA blindly sneers at all things Southern and rural. Allen’s penchant for snuff tobacco is depicted most unflatteringly, in the tone of “civilized people just don’t do that.” The Confederate flag is bandied about as a quick-and-easy sign of Allen’s backwardness without any historical context. It’s not a cut-and-dry racist banner. For example, Lynyrd Skynyrd is known to unfurl an enormous one during their concerts at the beginning of “Sweet Home Alabama.” The General Lee displayed it on the roof in The Dukes of Hazzard. It’s a symbol of the South, and not necessarily racist, a point about which intelligent people may disagree. Many have used it as a racist symbol, undoubtedly. As best as I can tell, being a Western transplant to Virginia, many others wave it in pride for the South, or in defiance of those who don’t try to understand them.
Lizza reveals himself as part of that group. His general tone indicates a prejudice toward the South, but one sentence in particular clinches that: “Whuppin’ his siblings might have been a natural prelude to Confederate sympathies and noose-collecting if Allen had grown up in, say, a shack in Alabama.” In other words, poor Alabamians are naturally racist. Lizza implicitly asks, how did George Allen, son of a cosmopolitan woman growing up in the big city, end up a racist?
The suggestion that Allen’s demeanor is an act is the most remarkable part of Lizza’s article. He has evidently spent little time with Allen. Allen’s embrace of country music and NASCAR is authentic. His favorite current driver is Elliot Sadler. As has been noted elsewhere, he still has a “3” for Dale Earnhardt on the back of his pickup truck. But to Allen, Richard Petty is always tops — “King Richard was my hero,” he told me. He lights up with enthusiasm when discussing road trips through areas Lizza might refer to as “flyover country.”
A man of faith in a godless age is hitting Americans where it hurts.
Mr. and Mrs. American Spectator Reader, let P.J. O’Rourke talk sense to your kids.
In Britain, defending your property can get you life.
The debacle of this president’s administration is both a cause and a symptom of the decline of American values. Unless Congress impeaches him, that decline will go on unchecked. An eminent jurist surveys the damage and assesses the chances for the recovery of our culture.
It won’t take long for conservatives to scratch this presidential wannabe off their 2008 scorecard.
The American Christmas, like the songs that celebrate it, makes room for everybody under the rainbow. Is that why so many people seem to be hostile to it?
Was the President done in by the economy, or by the politics of the economy?