The American Spectator

Reader Mail

(Page 5 of 7)

"It did, as has been so frequently repeated, destroy at once what it came across; it did exterminate all those who would not accept Islam..."

The actual quote is:

"It did NOT, as has been so frequently repeated, destroy at once what it came across; it did NOT exterminate all those who would not accept Islam..."

Belloc's point was that Muslims, far from wiping out the culture they conquered, in fact made major borrowings from that culture. He then goes on to say that, contrary to the opinion of some people, this wasn't because they were "tolerant" but because they were initially few and disorganized. (The entire Belloc article can be found here.)

As far as the actual substance of the article, I partially agree, but I hasten to reassure Mr. Neumayr that the left is, in fact, not in the least motivated by a love of Islam. Rather, they are motivated by the desire to massacre unborn infants and a blinding hatred towards anyone who might stand in their way. ...

The basic intra-left controversy, in which both sides take for granted that the real enemy is serious Christianity, is whether to blame Christians for being anti-Muslim bigots, or to jump on the anti-Muslim bandwagon themselves and labor mightily to establish as the conventional wisdom that all "fundamentalists" are alike and that, therefore, any pro-lifer is morally equivalent to the Taliban.

p>The first side would be your average politically correct leftoid, second side would be people like Andrew Sullivan and Christopher Hitchens. I figure it is probably better for the country, in the short term, if they adopt the second strategy. Anybody whose opinion of Christianity changes as a result of such horse waste probably is already anti-Christian, so it won't hurt Christians, and if it does, we can handle it. So, if the left thinks 1) that by getting behind the war effort they can hurt Christians, and 2) that they themselves, or anybody they know, won't have to, you know, like, actually fight themselves or anything, then the left might actually shut up and let us fight the war we have to fight, which would be a major improvement over their usual behavior and would spare everyone a lot of headaches. br> -- Roy Koczela /p>

Your article on Islam and its followers was gratefully received by those of us who have wearied of persons in high places referring to it as a "religion of peace." I really thought Jerry Falwell would hold up to his own understanding of the nature of Islam but he caved. You are a man of courage and I thank you for your willingness to speak the truth. I would say to expect a Fatwah shortly, but this is the first time I have read The American Prowler or any of your articles and wonder if the "evil eye" might pass by your words as well.

p>On the other hand, with NRO

topics:
Religion, Islam, Iraq, Iran, North Korea