The American Spectator

Reader Mail

Heavy Loads

8.16.02 @ 12:01AM

GOING SO FAST
Re: Francis X. Rocca's Trains, Planes, and Zeppelins:

If I read one more nostalgic tome to American passenger trains, I'm going to vomit.

America, TODAY, in 2002, has the most incredible railroad system in the world. It carries billions of ton-miles of FREIGHT every year, 37% of the nation's total. America's four primary freight railroads -- Union Pacific and Burlington Northern Santa Fe in the western states; CSX and Norfolk Southern in the East -- carry massive amounts of cargo with world-class efficiency. Nobody pays attention to this fact, however, because they are commercial carriers and have no sex appeal for Hollywood starlets or the New York media elite.

In what other nation do 15,000-ton (yes, their gross weight is fifteen-thousand TONS each) trains haul coal at 70 MPH from the Powder River Basin of Wyoming to power plants in Alabama, Florida, Ohio etc. on a "conveyor belt" of coal that runs day and night, 365 days a year? What other nation's railroads can deliver a BOXCAR from Los Angeles to Chicago on a passenger train schedule as BNSF does every day? What other country has produced the most powerful locomotives in the world from the Union Pacific "Big Boy" steamer of the 1930s to today's 6,000 horsepower super-efficient General Electric and General Motors mountain-conquering diesel-electric behemoths?

Europe's passenger railroads are little choo-choo trains in comparison.

And consider this: Our American freight railroads make profits, pay taxes, and do not depend on the government. Japan's "bullet trains," on the other hand, have wracked up more than ONE TRILLION DOLLARS in debt since their inception.

If Amtrak expands its schedule and its use of America's freight railroads' tracks, slowing down freight movements even more, as Amtrak does today, more trucks will take cargo business from the railroads. Consequently, any cut in automobile traffic will be made up by increased truck traffic on the highway.

Go ahead and propagate your pipe dreams about intercity passenger trains running high-speed on dedicated new supertracks. It will be a massive boondoggle. The environmentalists will fight it every step of the way. It will never happen. In the meantime, go check out America's freight railroads. They are the most awesome trains in the world today.
-- Steve Nikitas
Pittsfield, Massachusetts

Francis X. Rocca replies:: Mr. Nikitas is absolutely correct. In no other nation do trains regularly haul coal from Wyoming to Florida. Only in America. But I don't know where he got the idea that I support spending tax dollars to make U.S. passenger trains more like those in Europe -- since what I wrote says precisely the opposite.

FINALLY
Re: John Corry's Hawkish Nerve:

Mr. Corry: Isn't a bit presumptuous for you to think that anyone cares what an ex-New York Times so-called reporter thinks about our military strategy, or better yet, if you are nervous or not?

If we want to find out the truth, most of us go to the experts, not another civilian dove with an agenda. We can get this predictable nonsense from dozens of mediocre news stories on a daily basis.

You should leave important matters such as these to people with experience and stick to what you do best, whatever that may be.
-- Neil A. Runyon

I'm glad to see SOMEBODY in a conservative publication say what John Corry did.

Personally, I can't work up much enthusiasm for a war against Iraq. It seems the reasoning behind it is, "We want to fight somebody, so who can we fight next? Iraq, I guess." That's no way to decide on war.

Letter to the Editor

topics:
Taxes, Business, Environment, Hollywood, Law, Military, Iraq, Israel, Oil